5 ms·
It's unnerving because: 1) It reinforces the idea that for young women, the only way to achieve business success is to be performatively "girly" -- being uncea
by smacktoward 9y ago
It's unnerving because:
1) It reinforces the idea that for young women, the only way to achieve business success is to be performatively "girly" -- being unceasingly cheerful and social, presenting a breathless aw-shucks ("so amazing!") demeanor, working on things like fashion lines and skin care products or on image-first careers like "Instagram influencer." Society accepts that ambitious young men will present to the world in lots of different ways, but when it comes to ambitious young women we try to hammer them all into the same shape.
2) It puts pressure on its readers, who are in an age bracket we generally associate with childhood, to trade the traditional privileges of childhood -- shielding from the pitiless demands of the market, space to experiment with different facets of their personality, time to dedicate to education and self-development -- for the precarious, rat-race lifestyle that adults live every day. Kids who are saying "there is no such thing as a regular 9 to 5. We work 24/7!" are kids who have internalized the idea that work is all there is, that their lives don't have room for anything else. That would be a sad thing for a fully grown adult to believe, much less a thirteen-year-old.
- kristianc 9y ago1) An alternative reading of the magazine is that it is celebrating young creators, who have achieved success through alternative routes (make up lines, t-shirts, YouTube channels) than the standard middle class millennial career path of "being born into the right family, liberal arts education, job at BuzzFeed/Vanity Fair/Teen Vogue/New Yorker while building out performative angst Twitter persona." Following that line, for most people without the right background/connections/ability to take an unpaid internship in New York for three months, results in them becoming on several levels completely unemployable. 2) The readers are self-consciously choosing this media themselves anyway - through the YouTube channels they subscribe to and watch, the Instagram influencers they follow, the products they buy. Instead of mindlessly scrolling through social media feeds, these readers are now being encouraged to think how they can follow in their footsteps. This article imo, reveals much more about the prejudices of the author than the readers or the publishers.
- smacktoward 9y ago> An alternative reading of the magazine is that it is celebrating young creators Who are creative within a narrow, conventionally "girly" band of creative endeavors. Teen Boss would not be interested in a 15-year-old girl who invented a revolutionary new type of automotive engine, because it is not a magazine about girls with grease on their hands. Girls who want to should be free to engage in those kinds of "girly" pursuits, of course. To each their own! But by focusing only on those pursuits, Teen Boss sends the message to girls who are interested in other things (like STEM!) that they're weirdos who are walking away from success instead of towards it in their own way.
- kristianc 9y ago> Who are creative within a narrow, conventionally "girly" band of creative endeavors. Teen Boss would not be interested in a 15-year-old girl who invented a revolutionary new type of automotive engine, because it is not a magazine about girls with grease on their hands. Perhaps not, but then you're being reductive by equating engineering with 'grease on their hands'. There's plenty of STEM careers that don't involve any grease - such as materials science, fashion design, sound engineering, to stuff that this magazine would wholeheartedly endorse, like developing your own make up line. 'I made thousands building a FaceTune competitor' certainly would. For that matter, how many people on Hacker News deal with grease in their day to day work? And is the kind of thing being discussed here that different from 'I made $32k a month recurring revenue' IndieHackers story, the likes of which regularly gets voted to the top of HN?
- adamsea 9y agoThat's not the point. A software engineer would work perfectly well for the example in the parent post.
- doctorstupid 9y agoSlow down and process the metaphor.
- spacehome 9y ago
- pnathan 9y agoRegarding point 2 - that is only traditional within the last 75 years for the modernized west; prior to that it was the upper class which had such ideations regarding children. Most cultures historically have expected children to work and contribute - work and play intermingled, and then at a point, they were graduated to primarily contributions. I wouldn't get too peturbed about children working. n.b., exploitation is a different thing, I want to make clear. But historically, children contributing is a thing, and it was not an evil.
- rayiner 9y ago> 1) It reinforces the idea that for young women, the only way to achieve business success is to be performatively "girly" -- being unceasingly cheerful and social, presenting a breathless aw-shucks ("so amazing!") demeanor Or, it takes girls, who are already socialized that way, and teaches them that pink and glitter isn’t inconsistent with making money. (Which is the most important thing for kids to learn, because we live in a country where you die without money.)
- replicatorblog 9y agoBeyond the covers and YouTube features, from what I've seen the magazine does have less traditionally gendered sections. E.g. this spread is a generic "learn to code" piece, featuring a female engineer and highlighting various career paths SW engineering skills can unlock: https://twitter.com/girlswhocode/status/909883045406281728 https://twitter.com/girlswhocode/status/909883045406281728 I've seen other spreads that highlight people like Tim Cook, who, while famous in our orbits, isn't a typical topic of conversation among my nieces.
- smacktoward 9y agoThat's good to hear!
- humanrebar 9y ago> ...to trade the traditional privileges of childhood... Traditionally children help out with chores, work on the farm, watch the other children, or even get jobs to help with the household expenses. > ...kids who have internalized the idea that work is all there is... There is a certain segment of the population that scrapes by and survival is the biggest concern. A certain level of privilege is needed to take principled stands on issues, invest large amounts of time and energy in charitable work, or even just travel and experience the world. That is to say, life as a struggle is actually pretty normal. And it's not new or unique to this time and culture. Maybe it's perverse to choose to struggle as a middle class kid. And maybe it's especially perverse to chose this kind of struggle. But there are many less healthy things for tweens and teens to invest their energy in.
- philwelch 9y agoThirteen year olds used to be adults. It's no coincidence that the traditional cultural markers of "transitioning from childhood to adulthood", like bar mitzvahs, take place around that age. Teenagers used to be apprentices or naval midshipmen. Then society got to the point where teenagers were no longer capable of doing anything useful, so society started extending childhood, to the point where nobody under the age of 30 considers themselves adults anymore. From that perspective, any reversion to the more natural pattern of human development is going to seem sad and destructive of childhood. But that perspective is formed by a very unnatural way of life. Teenage naval midshipmen weren't wracked with angst and depression the way contemporary American teenagers are. They didn't chafe and rebel against their parents the way contemporary American teenagers do, because they weren't treated like children; they were treated like young adults.