5 ms·
I read one theory that products like Amazon Spark or Facebook Mail exist to ward off antitrust regulators' attention by giving the appearance of more competitio
by emodendroket 9y ago
I read one theory that products like Amazon Spark or Facebook Mail exist to ward off antitrust regulators' attention by giving the appearance of more competition between tech giants without having a serious expectation of success. I'm not sure if that's true but it's interesting to consider.
- patentatt 9y agoWell that is diabolical, and a very plausible theory. It does explain some of the more oddball products put out by large dominate companies.
- brokensegue 9y agoplausible? hardly.
- emodendroket 9y agoWhat makes you say that?
- cerved 9y agoProbably because it assumes it's more likely that this is the result of an ingenious, diabolical plan as opposed to incompetence.
- stagbeetle 9y agoThe greatest trick the devil ever played, was to convince everyone he was stupid. The second part of Hanlon's Razor, was to not rule out malice.
- chris_wot 9y agoI must be missing the irony somewhere, but I wasn't aware of a second part to Hanlon's Razor.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere's no irony. It's often given in that form.
- chris_wot 9y agoThe "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" makes that rather odd.
- emodendroket 9y agoI suppose, but a little more nuance is welcome. The CJR ran a piece about Seymour Hersh, but I think a lot of the things they had to say about Hanlon's Razor and similar aphorisms are thoughtful and relevant to this discussion: https://www.cjr.org/analysis/seymour_hersh_osama_bin_laden.php https://www.cjr.org/analysis/seymour_hersh_osama_bin_laden.p... > No phrase has been bandied about more than “conspiracy theory” in describing Hersh’s reporting. Critics argue that he’s accusing “hundreds of people across three governments of staging a massive international hoax that has gone on for years.” How could that be possible? > [...] > [I]t is extraordinarily naive to think the government is incapable of keeping a large secret involving dozens, hundreds, or even thousands of people. I am reminded of this passage from the memoirs of Pentagon Papers whistleblower Daniel Ellsberg, who knows a thing or two about how government secrecy works. Not only is the idea that you can’t keep secrets in Washington “flatly false,” Ellsberg writes, but by repeating it you’re doing the government’s work for them. >> [Such sayings] are in fact cover stories, ways of flattering and misleading journalists and their readers, part of the process of keeping secrets well. Of course eventually many secrets do get out that wouldn’t in a fully totalitarian society. But the fact is that the overwhelming majority of secrets do not leak to the American public … The reality unknown to the public and to most members of Congress and the press is that secrets that would be of the greatest import to many of them can be kept from them reliably for decades by the executive branch, even though they are known to thousands of insiders. > [...] > The old adage that “three people can only keep a secret if two are dead” is a fantasy, and journalists should stop mindlessly repeating it.
- emodendroket 9y ago"Ingenious" is laying it on a little thick, don't you think?
- kozikow 9y agoHow does it help the company in question? In the scenario, you propose Facebook mail is selflessly helping to fend off antitrust regulators off Gmail.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt's not selfless; it's mutually beneficial. Someone looks at the existence of Facebook's core platform, Google+, GMail, and Facebook Mail, and concludes that nothing is amiss, since the bigger products have well-funded competition.
- scrooched_moose 9y agoGoogle pretends to have shopping [1] to shield Amazon, Amazon pretends to have social media [2] to shield Facebook, Facebook pretended to have mail to shield Google [3]. It's an interesting thought, especially considering how half-assed most of these non-core projects are. 1) https://www.google.com/shopping https://www.google.com/shopping 2) https://www.amazon.com/Spark/b?ie=UTF8&node=16907772011 https://www.amazon.com/Spark/b?ie=UTF8&node=16907772011 3) https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/24/5443454/facebook-retires-its-email-service https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/24/5443454/facebook-retires-... Combine it with the wage collusion case [4] from a few years ago and it's entering the plausible territory 4) http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jobs-settlement-20150903-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-job...
- j-c-hewitt 9y agoActually makes a ton of sense considering that tech company stock prices often move in tandem or are otherwise aggregated together by ETFs and mutual funds. Why not collude off the record to ward off antitrust? It makes stuff like Google+ not completely stupid.
- patentatt 9y agoCould also be Amazon pretends to have social media, and then when challenged as being a monopoly they can say something like "well, ecommerce is but one of our many products and across out entire portfolio we have lots of competition" or something to that effect. Just redirect to the sham loser products to make an appearance of competition, even though the lion's share of revenue is derived from a line of business that has a monopoly position.
- ABCLAW 9y agoJust so people know, these are generally known as 'complimentary' or 'covering' bids in the public procurement world. Market allocation agreements are also another heading that this would fall under in these specific examples. Those terms should give you a wealth of information about how and why these strategies work to conceal collusion between competitors.
- wnevets 9y agoNever thought about that, very interesting but not completely surprising when you hear stories of Apple and Google working together to keep salaries low.
- woodpanel 9y agoI honestly think it's a very interesting and plausible theory, but let's assume these are serious attempts of said companies: I just think it's hilarious that these products (AMZN Spark, FB Mail...) are so bad that people believe in conspiracy theories rather than accepting a dry truth as an explanation.