13 ms·
Amazon Takes Fresh Stab at $16B Housekeeping Industry
- noemit 9y agoas a customer, I think it's great. Few purchases make me as happy as the amazon house cleaning.
- ows_vs_obama 9y agoAfter ruining Whole Foods, I’m excited for them to take a stab at ruining another industry. I can’t wait to see what they do with this one! Unsafe but cheap cleaning supplies? Slave wages for the workers? So exciting!
- koolba 9y ago> A weekly cleaning of a 1,500-square-foot home runs about $156. It doesn’t say what’s included but off hand that seems 2-4x expensive for a weekly house cleaning of that size. That (relatively) high pricing may be specific to Seattle though as they’ve got a high ($15/hr) min wage laws there that would apply. Combined with non-contractor employees, FICA, and benefits, they’re easily looking at $20+/hr in labor costs.
- sokoloff 9y ago> "Any products that require additional services beyond opening a box, Amazon doesn’t do well," Kalyanam said. Well, there’s AWS, which smashes that mold.
- pjc50 9y agoHow's AWS human customer service?
- sokoloff 9y agoQuite good for us. We have a team from AWS on-site every other Thursday (and subject matter experts from AWS that we can call in as/if needed). AWS started out as a REST-services-only take-it-or-leave-it business. They've expanded quite substantially their human-provided sales, service, success operation in recent years. Even on my personal account (spending <$50/month), I get quick and sensible email replies to my account-related inquiries.
- athenot 9y agoPretty good if you're a big fish. I've been mostly satisfied with their human CS.
- ghaff 9y agoAmazon seems to do a mostly reasonable job of customer service, especially given their scale. However, I'd argue that's something quite different from managing an army of low-wage contract workers. Yes, they have their warehouses and there's even Mechanical Turk (though you don't really hear much about that these days) but those seem different and much more constrained that people providing personal services of various sorts. That's generally proven to be a hard type of thing to deliver at scale.
- neogodless 9y agoI'm in the weird position where, we are family planning, but (to our knowledge) unsuccessful, but started getting a series of emails from Amazon congratulating us and offering up suggestions like vitamins, baby registry and, of course, housecleaning services w/ discounts available. (The first email was, to put it lightly, premature. Now we got one that says "week one", and it could be right, or not. We don't know yet.) These emails puzzle me, because I pored over my shopping history, and I can't find any indicator that would tip off their algorithm. But I do get the idea of trying to sell things to expectant mothers. Such as convenience services.
- origami777 9y agoMaybe they are purchasing data from other providers about your search history, site history, etc.
- mabbo 9y agoWe may not be there yet, but there's certainly going to be a day where online advertisers know a woman is pregnant before she does based on the changes in her behavior. I'm not sure if that counts as a dystopia or not. Is there a good word for "Weirdtopia"?
- anorwell 9y agoThis article talks about how Target predicts when a woman is pregnant, and the steps they go to to make it less weird: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits....
- mabbo 9y agoOne of my favorite incidents and exactly what I was thinking about.
- athenot 9y agoWe are not far from that point, with Target who figured out a girl was pregnant before her dad knew: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targ...
- mabbo 9y ago> The online retailer is swapping the low cost of contract workers for the greater control of employing its own people. Doing so puts it on the hook for things like minimum wage, workers compensation and overtime pay. But it also lets Amazon determine how the workers are trained, which cleaning products they use and how they organize their schedules. As an Amazon employee, I very much hope this trend continues. Amazon logistics has gone the industry standard route of contractors hiring contractors and no one seems to be happy with it at all. When Amazon is the employer, Amazon can control quality better. Customer obsession means more than just lowest possible price. (My own personal opinion and of course I don't speak for the company)
- Eridrus 9y agoI think the fact that cleaning services are a lot less standardized is what drives the need to hire people. There's very little difference in logistics: its both easy to do an average job (just take the route google maps suggests) and its easy to monitor if contractors are doing a reasonable job. The impression I get for cleaning services from people who have hired them is that the person doing it will generally do the smallest/easiest amount of work possible in the allocated time, which leads to poor customer satisfaction/retention, so exercising more control as an employer is necessary.
- hownottowrite 9y agoCached Version: https://archive.is/SdQas https://archive.is/SdQas
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoAmazon and Google will end up being the middle men for everything. You simply can't compete with a company that has all the data, all the money, the best engineers, the patents, etc... Once they like your business model, you are out of business. This is happening at an increasingly faster pase. There will be an Amazon AirBnB, and Amazon Uber, Amazon Food, Amazon Freight, etc... the future of free markets is not free. They will own every slot in the monopoly game and we will receive a basic income to keep the game going.
- mseebach 9y ago> Amazon and Google A couple of weeks ago, your list would have included Facebook. The future is a lot less deterministic than you think.
- castis 9y agoYes, but does this make OPs forecast any less possible?
- mseebach 9y agoThe OPs forecast is predicated on an understanding of companies like Google and Amazon being so big and powerful that they are immune to the ebb and flow that define normal market conditions and allow new entrants to prosper and old companies to whither when they no longer create enough value for consumers. My argument is that when Facebook, a company until a few weeks ago commonly understood to be every bit as immortal as Google and Amazon, can be so deeply upset by a scandal that isn't even predominantly their own making (I don't mean to imply that FB isn't culpable, but CA did the bad stuff and explicitly and broadly broke terms in doing so), this immortality is a lot shallower than it seems. Facebook isn't dead, and won't be for a long time, but the idea that Facebook moving into Airbnb's space will immediately monopolise it for the detriment of consumers seems rather more of a silly fantasy than a "forecast".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yalogin 9y agoThey have the keys to your house through Ring and others. So now we see their conquest of our homes coming to a completion.
- Dowwie 9y agoDoes anyone remember HomeJoy? See [1] and [2] below. Amazon isn't necessarily using this business model so that it may differentiate itself from hands-off matching services. In this case, regulation and legal battles that have destroyed entrepreneurial enterprises like HomeJoy are guiding Amazon. Improved customer experience is a side effect. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellenhuet/2015/07/23/what-really-killed-homejoy-it-couldnt-hold-onto-its-customers/#59188c4e1874 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellenhuet/2015/07/23/what-reall... [2] https://www.recode.net/2015/7/17/11614814/cleaning-services-startup-homejoy-shuts-down-after-battling-worker https://www.recode.net/2015/7/17/11614814/cleaning-services-...
- mdasen 9y agoAaron Cheung, co-founder of HomeJoy, launched Homeaglow which seem like the same business model as HomeJoy. Xiao Wei Chen, COO at HomeJoy, is also a co-founder of Homeaglow. I'm not saying it'll succeed this time, but two execs at HomeJoy have decided to dedicate another 3 years of their lives to the idea with Homeaglow. I know that the articles mention the lawsuits over classification of independent-contractor vs employee, but nestled in there is a huge customer acquisition cost against a low lifetime value. Offering an initial $19 cleaning means very high acquisition costs and you're getting customers who probably won't return with $100 a month later. The Forbes article notes that Handy has a much better customer retention rate and recurring revenue is so important. It also sounds like HomeJoy might have been over-staffed. Re/code notes that 20 employees of HomeJoy would be joining Googles product and engineering teams. That seems like a lot of salary. I don't know what HomeJoy's site was like, but Homeaglow's seems simplistic - some PHP just meant to handle the booking/matching/reviews. Even small things like the forms are the kinda simplistic looking ones where the zip-code box takes up the full width of the form on a new line (the way it would if you grabbed Bootstrap and didn't want to customize anything) rather than having a form with a more natural City, State, Zip layout. But it gets the job done and looks like it can be maintained with minimal effort. If you have 20 employees of Google-caliber, you have to imagine a lot of salary cost. From LinkedIn, it looks like Homeaglow is a 2-person shop. It could just be that while it's a large industry, they had trouble retaining customers and had a high run rate at HomeJoy. With a lower run rate and some alterations, Homeaglow might be a happy business. They don't seem to discount first cleanings hugely. It looks like they offer a free half hour on a 3 hour cleaning for first-time users, but that means that someone is willing to spend a hundred compared to someone that just sees a deal at $19. They also only allow recurring plans that you can cancel, but it gets you into the mindset that this should be a weekly/bi-weekly/monthly recurring expense.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yesiamyourdad 9y agoData point: I just moved and Amazon sent me a $20 off cleaning offer, which I used to clean out my old rental this past weekend. They did a nice job (I think, haven't gotten my deposit back yet). I was talking to the cleaner and she said she used to work through HomeAdvisor exclusively but has put HA on hold because Amazon takes less commission and keeps her just as busy. The price was OK with $20 off, I know you can do better if you search out the right service, but I imagine that you can already ask Alexa to schedule a house cleaning, so the integration & convenience would have to be pretty compelling for me to make it a regular thing.
- yellowstuff 9y agoThe general problem with "Uber for X" is that mostly consumers don't want one-time anonymous services. It works for cabs and probably for one-time cleaning, but if I'm going to have someone clean my apartment every week I want the same person there every time, and I think that's pretty typical.