9 ms·
Eating out increases levels of phthalates in the body, study finds
- pluma 9y agoSounds like this is mostly about fast food chains, not restaurants in general. It also seems like this story should really be about calling out specific restaurants/chains for contaminated food, not presenting it as a general fact about restaurants.
- forgotmypw 9y agoThere is little difference between "fast food chains" and "restaurants in general". Fast food chains make their food from prepared components that they buy in bulk through some sort of homogenized supply chain. So do most restaurants. Fast food chains involve a lot of plastic in their food preparation, even hot food and even while cooking. So do most restaurants. Fast food chains use food components that are optimized for shelf life, using whatever chemicals that the FDA said are "generally recognized as safe" in 1958. So do most restaurants. And so on. Places where the chef goes out to the farmer's market every morning, hand-selecting the ingredients, and then painstakingly crafts your meal using only metal and ceramic are the exception rather than the norm. Even one-off family restaurants where you get "good" food are doing most of this stuff, just because it is the norm, and they don't see anything wrong with it. If you don't believe me, just go in the kitchen of your favorite restaurant and observe what the chef does and read the ingredients on the big containers of "raw" ingredients.
- goldenkey 9y agoIsn't this like saying macro-nutrients are all that matters? Pop a vitamin and eat slop made from grounding up all the animal parts? In theory it makes sense but we haven't even begun to understand the millions of different hydrocarbons in a small piece of meat. So there is an unscientific albeit widely believed statement about quality ingredients. There isn't legislation to make sure only X is allowed in a processed food - there are only laws that exclude known harmful things like brain matter because of prions, or antibiotics if labeled as such, or pesticides if labeled as organic. /u/given even linked a study less than 2 weeks ago showing that an array of human vaccines tested had a slew of metal and other contaminants. The only vaccine tested that lacked contaminents was a veterinary vaccine for distemper..smh [1] The closest, one would think to getting pure macros, is plant or whey-based proteins, carbohydrates, and oils/lipids like coconut oil. But most of the pure plant protein powders and supplements have an even worse infiltration - high levels of metals from the soil the plants were grown in. Highly dependent on the country of origin. Now, I'd garner that if these companies cared enough and could spend more money, they'd be able to chellate or use ion-exchange filters, or maybe just mechnical methods like centrifugal separation / sub-micron filters, etc.. to remove the metals and other undesirables. Do biological contaminents in plants get even near the possible ones' in animals like cortisol? Does a poorly sunlit plant produce stress chemicals? I'd guess that because the animal kingdom is a divergent evolution to the plant kingdom, harmful compounds would be lesser. Yes, we have phytoestrogens from soy, and tobacco, hemp, poppy, and all kinds of poisonous plants out there. A side note, plant alkaloids serve two functions, to poison to protect the plant or to create desire for the purpose of spreading seeds; this is why poisons are often found on leaves, while desirable drugs or flavors are found on the fruit or seedbearing parts. It's not an easy distinction to make, poison vs drug - many substances we consider drugs are actually made by the plants to protect themselves, ie. tobacco or willow bark (aspirin). In any case, the chemicals naturally found in acceptable farmed plant species are likely to be less reactive in an animal body, than a poorly treated cortisol-filled animals' internal chemistry. It'd be awesome if there truly was a micron-filtered food supplement out there. But even Soylent isn't that. The protein powders on the market, pea, crickets, whey, etc.. all have the aforementioned issues with heavy metals or hormones. It's a grace of our generation to know most of the vitamins and minerals required by our bodies. To be able to eat just pure carbs, fats, and proteins, and pop a vitamin for the rest. But we still don't have food products that provide pure macros. When will we see the futuristic "slab" or "paste" that is literally only a single digit number of compounds? I think it's about time that we get something like this. I'm actually in the process of producing a bee-derived meal replacement shake that will feature sub-micron filtration. [2] Honey might be your first thought but bee pollen is the main ingredient - it's actually packed with tons of protein and isn't sweet. Let me know if you would be interested in a purely bee honey, pollen, royal jelly based meal replacement. I haven't gauged interest yet so it'd be interesting to see if HN is interested. Cheers. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27756430/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27756430/ [2] https://imgur.com/a/YFTTQ https://imgur.com/a/YFTTQ
- forgotmypw 9y agoI'm not sure if you thought I was defending fast food. I was merely saying that most prepared food that is not "fast food" is not great either. I think that the best we can do today is approximate as closely as possible the diet (and lifestyle) we have been evolving for in the millions of years prior to industrial agriculture. To me, that means a diet of mainly plants and a little meat, mostly raw, some cooked with direct heat, occasional fasting, sleep and rest as allowed by circumstances, lots of getting dirty, and not stressing about macro things we can't change. P.S. nih.gov links do not work without JS. I like your logo design.
- origami777 9y agoThanks for clarifying. That makes a ton of sense.
- goldenkey 9y agoI agree with you. But I also don't think it's terrible to have macro isolates that are chemical-grade. Everyone wants pure water but we never think about purifying foods, only processing them which is a crude process. And I put the wrong link for the vaccine study. It is actually: http://medcraveonline.com/IJVV/IJVV-04-00072.php http://medcraveonline.com/IJVV/IJVV-04-00072.php
- coldtea 9y ago>Fast food chains make their food from prepared components that they buy in bulk through some sort of homogenized supply chain. So do most restaurants. Fast food chains involve a lot of plastic in their food preparation, even hot food and even while cooking. So do most restaurants. Fast food chains use food components that are optimized for shelf life, using whatever chemicals that the FDA said are "generally recognized as safe" in 1958. So do most restaurants. Depends if in "non fast-food restaurants" you include a TGIF or a Chipotle.
- forgotmypw 9y agoI'm including both corporate chains like TGIF and Chipotle, in addition to: * that sushi restaurant in the strip mall, that serves you rice cooked with fluoride water and soy sauce with sodium beonzoate * that "gourmet" deli that serves you sodium nitrate-laden on top of pesticide- and preservative-laden bread with a yellow #5 pickle. * that coffee shop that pours a hot beverage at 140F/60C into a plastic-lined, plastic-lidded cup. * that cafeteria in that corporate office that heats up frozen soup in a plastic bag before pouring it into the serving pot. * and so on Our food system resembles a Brave New World-esque intelligence test that most of us are failing.
- AstralStorm 9y agoAnd again, this miniscule phthalate level increases matters why? (Even cumulative.) Please answer with solid evidence of morbidity. Guardian did not do the homework. The studies on phthalates are quite tenuous for adults. There are a few which link to developmental problems. This is a very different case from children chewing on phthalate containing foams or sleeping in such. Which has been quite clearly linked. The risk is mainly for pregnant women then? Regardless, most of the problems would be related to packaging. Ditch styrofoam and plastic. Use ones certified phthalate free. Oh and Guardian published this some years ago in a better way. Misrepresenting evidence then too. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/feb/10/phthalates-plastics-chemicals-research-analysis https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/feb/10/phthala... Sounds like some sort of agenda. The other quotes border on conspiracy theory.
- marak830 9y agoFrom my experience, it is pretty much down to how much you're willing to pay. When I was younger and worked in lower quality places, a lot would be purchased through a supplier (although very rare to see premade items purchased), where as now (I work at a fine dining establishment), the current head chef indeed goes to the farmers market once a month - he will go through their produce, and select which items he will want for that months menu (note we get deliveries daily, and check each for quality - anything subpar gets returned and if happens more than once we will find a different supplier). The same goes for our meats and seafood. As for those places that order in bulk, optomised for shelf life. They do not deserve to be called restaurants, they are just a fast food joint with a different name. (Source: 17 years as a chef).
- sametmax 9y agoSemantics. Restaurant are places where you eat. For most people, restaurants don't have star. In France, they mostly buy their stuff at Metro. That's why I pay more and more money to go to very good restaurant. But I care deeply about food, I love it, I cook, and I have money. That's not the usual situation.
- marak830 9y agoI agree it is semantics, but it shouldn't be in my opinion. While it will never happen, I would prefer to call yourself a restaurant you would need to prove that you had hired qualified chefs and that you were producing all the for you sell. It's a major gripe of the industry that people like me do the work to create real quality food, and then get lumped in with places that use premade crap. I should probably stop my rant now, I could go on for a while haha.
- portofcall 9y agoIt’s also always worth thinking about the health impact of eating a lot of restaurant/fast/chain food simply from a nutritional perspective. If you’re eating a double quarter pounder with cheese, fries and a soda, the actual food is by far the worst part of the experience. The carcinogenic and cardiovascular downsides of such a fatty, low fiber, high sugar and sodium diet are profound and well understood. A friend of mine recently came to me with an article that a “chemical found in silly putty” was found in fry oil. They were horrified, but I pointed out that it’s known to be inert. They were still horrified. I pointed out that to get a mg of the stuff, you’d have to eat half a kilogram of fry oil (not a kg of fries, but oil). If you’re packing in half s kilo of grease, it’s not the mg of additive you should be worried about!
- billfruit 9y agoIMO writing from the third world, it is almost always a safer bet to eat from an established fast food chain franchise, than restaurants, due to the poor state of regulation and enforcement of food safety standards. At least the chain franchise will have some guidelines on the quality of food, which ensures atleast that the food is not deadly if not healthy, where as with traditional restaurants all bets are off.
- GordonS 9y agoI've found across the whole of Asia, its perfectly safe to eat in independent restaurants, from hole-in-the wall places, street stalls and even old women frying chicken using portable burners on pavements in Indonesia. I've always gone to places that are popular with locals - think about it, they wouldn't be popular if they gave customers the raging shits. I can only assume that this holds true across other parts of the world. You don't make money without returning customers.
- thefounder 9y agoThe headline is misleading
- vixen99 9y agoMisleading in some measure, as is almost every headline - given that appropriate qualifiers necessarily disqualify the text as a headline. But most of us assume that's the case and judge accordingly on the content.
- pipio21 9y agoThis should be "Eating out in industrialized fast food American food chains increases levels of phthalates in the body". A restaurant is a different thing. In places like Spain, France or Italy when you say "restaurant" you never refer to "MacDonnals", "BurgerKing" or "FostersHollywood".
- coldtea 9y agoAnd rarely to some non-fast-food franchize chain either.
- prepend 9y agoWhat are you talking about? BurgerKing is certainly classified as a restaurant in Spain, France, and Italy. What do they call these places? I’m not sure how you validate such an absolute statement. My own travels had many examples of people in these countries using restaurant to refer to both fast food and sit down restaurants. There are thousands of web pages like this s one using restaurant to describe McDonalds in Spain - https://www.quora.com/What-is-mcdonalds-in-Spain-like https://www.quora.com/What-is-mcdonalds-in-Spain-like
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- arthurbrown 9y agoYou're referencing a quora post by an American about some time spent in Spain. How is this an authoritative source? The following answer specifically rails against fast food and contrasts it against "restaurants and tapas bars", implying a difference. Sure you can use restaurant as a term to refer to a "place where food can be ordered" -- but if someone speaks the word, fast food is not what comes to mind.
- mynameishere 9y agoWell, the word will come to mind for those of us who use words correctly, rather than twisting them because we feel superior to the people at one establishment or another. a business establishment where meals or refreshments may be purchased https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/restaurant https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/restaurant My impression of the food service industry is that you have big companies like MCD that control their own supply chains, really expensive places where the chef goes to market every morning, and 95 percent of everything else where they serve whatever arrives on the Sysco truck. There's no need to get uptight--it's all just calories with a 1000 percent markup.
- spodek 9y agoI can't tell if we treat our environment or our bodies worse, but the same mental process seems to drive how we treat each. The result is the same: to save a percent here and there we trash both.
- gnulinux 9y agoI'm really sorry but I don't get the anaology. Eating home is significantly cheaper than eating out. How are those two things similar?
- subpixel 9y agoIn my office, I see seemingly reasonable white-collar employees regularly microwave their lunch in all sorts of flimsy plastic containers. I’m not even shocked anymore.
- stronglikedan 9y agoI think the people who know not to microwave plastic, and don't, are a very small minority. The people who have never heard it are in a slightly larger minority. The people who have heard it's bad, but choose not to heed the warnings for convenience sake, are seemingly the majority. Most times I've mentioned it to someone who is about to microwave plastic, they say something along the lines of "oh yeah, I've heard that before", as they continue to put their plastic in the microwave and start it up. I've given up on trying to educate people about it.
- vorotato 9y agoI thought this title was referring to the euphemism.
- liberte82 9y agoAre phthalates bad?
- jmhyer123 9y ago> Researchers investigating levels of phthalates in the human body, which have been linked to asthma, breast cancer, type 2 diabetes and fertility issues in the past few years...
- wgj 9y agoNeither CDC nor Wikipedia show very clear support for this assertion, especially given that the actual levels in the study weren't reported. Just relative percentages. https://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Phthalates_FactSheet.html https://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Phthalates_FactSheet.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate#Health_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate#Health_effects
- Steve44 9y agoThis only seems to be a correlation between people reporting having eaten out and the test levels. I can't see why restaurant food would be that much different to home cooked food unless there was something very wrong with the supply chain or kitchen practices. The newspaper article does not mention if they have looked at following the source of these phthalates back up the chain to see where they actually come from.
- sametmax 9y agoMy theory is that most affordables restaurant don't make food anymore, they assemble it. So it comes from multiple packages. Add the fact there is a lot of take away / doggy bags, which means repackaging the finished product, and stronger hygiene regulation, which mean detergent used in contact with the food, and you have more opportunities for phthalates to come by. While at home, you may very well cook it from more raw ingredients, with less packaging, put it on a plate, and just quickly wipe the table and plate when you're done. You will also cook a big meal for the entire house, while a lot of restaurant are just fast food, preparing one meal per person. Remember, for most families, they won't go to a michelin restaurant. They will got to Scramblz', Chipotle or the local "italian".
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAbout restaurant-packaged foods - around here, they still cook (Iowa). I'm thinking back on the last dozen restaurants I've visited - they all cook I think! And I eat lunch at a different place every day. Trick is, avoid the chains I guess? I choose various hole-in-the-wall Indian, Mexican, Texas, Japanese eateries and diners.
- nicoburns 9y agoI think this may be US-specific. In the UK, there are certainly chains that 'assemble' food, but there are also a whole bunch of similarly priced chains amd independent resturants that cook fresh food. It's not michelin star quality, but it's fresh. In general I think resturaunts tend to add more seasoning (such as salt, sugar, etc) than most people cooking at home would.
- xutopia 9y agoEverybody here has an idea of why this occurs and they all mention packaging. Did you see inside a McDonalds kitchen? They use plastic trays to cook and hold foods instead of stainless steel we would see in high end restaurants. I am certain that food grade plastics leak into food at high heat when oils and other food compounds are present.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djyaz1200 9y agoIt's the receipts, they are printed on paper that has these chemicals and handed to people right before they eat. As a test try not to touch the recipe when they attempt to hand it to you and get ready to be just about assaulted by the clerks as they try to force you to take it. https://cen.acs.org/articles/95/i35/Touching-thermal-paper-receipts-extend.html https://cen.acs.org/articles/95/i35/Touching-thermal-paper-r...
- wgj 9y agoIn addition to the issue of relying entirely on correlation, this report only states relative percentage increase without stating absolute levels or comparison to any known risk thresholds. Maybe 35% higher exposure isn't a significantly greater risk. If it is a significant risk, I don't think I can rest easier only getting two thirds the exposure staying at home. That's still a lot of plastic if I'm actually that close to a toxicity threshold. Edit: Also, as I noted in another comment, both CDC and Wikipedia are much more conservative about the health impact, making the question about toxicity threshold even more relevant. https://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Phthalates_FactSheet.html https://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Phthalates_FactSheet.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate#Health_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phthalate#Health_effects
- alphanumeric0 9y agoI'd be interested to see more at-home test kits for these sorts of biomarkers.