12 ms·
What frustrates me endlessly about the GMO debate is that "GMO" tells you about as much about safety as "chemical." You could certainly GM something into being
by whatshisface 9y ago
What frustrates me endlessly about the GMO debate is that "GMO" tells you about as much about safety as "chemical." You could certainly GM something into being dangerous or more dangerous, for example transplanting allergens or increasing the production of natural pest control toxins. You could also modify a protein into an equivalent protein, changing nothing.
The only real answer to fears about GMOs is to point people towards longitudinal studies that show that the specific modification in question isn't causing any problems. Sadly, this really isn't possible in our current system, as I have no idea which changes were made to the organisms that get put in the consumer products I buy. In an ideal world, I could read NGK-028181 off the tin of baked beans in my pantry and realize that I needed to throw it out because they discovered something wrong with that one specific genome (or because I know I'm allergic).
As a consumer, if I ever get suspicious about one specific change made to one specific breed, my only option is to buy non-GMO everything. That doesn't make any sense!
- kazinator 9y agoThe GMO debate isn't just about whether the molecules of something you're eating are safe in relation to the modifications. It includes considerations such as what kinds of practices are enabled by GMO: like producing a plant that is resistant to certain herbicides so that you can douse the heck out of the crop to kill everything else. Or how some genetically modified plant is someone's intellectual property, so you're a criminal if you happen to plant its seeds back in the soil. (Just two issues off the top of my head in regard to an area I don't think much about.)
- sanxiyn 9y agoOn the topic of intellectual property, you are completely wrong. Plant patents predate GMO (like 50 years) and they are not "enabled by GMO" in any sense whatsoever.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Plant patents predate GMO (like 50 years) Huh, didn't know--thank you. Plants have apparently been patentable since 1930 [1]. In 1970, the Congress gave breeders "up to 25 years of exclusive control over new, distinct, uniform, and stable sexually reproduced or tuber propagated plant varieties" [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Patent_Act_of_1930 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Patent_Act_of_1930 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Variety_Protection_Act_of_1970 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Variety_Protection_Act_o...
- sampo 9y agoLook how many times different mutations of the Red Delicious apple has been patented. 42 patents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Delicious https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Delicious
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> producing a plant that is resistant to certain herbicides so that you can douse the heck out of the crop to kill everything else I think you're referring to Round-up Ready? Wasn't the point of that program to reduce pesticide use?
- kazinator 9y agoNot referring to any specific program; note that pesticide /= herbicide.
- SlowBro 9y agoIn theory, yes. In practice... https://www.forbes.com/sites/bethhoffman/2013/07/02/gmo-crops-mean-more-herbicide-not-less/#4d4e5b3e3cd5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/bethhoffman/2013/07/02/gmo-crop...
- sampo 9y agoThis 2017 study says that herbicide use has been increasing overall, also on non-GMO crops such as wheat and rice. And that the increase rate in GMO crops (corn, soy, cotton) is no faster than in non-GMO crops. http://weedcontrolfreaks.com/2017/04/gmos-and-herbicides-its-complicated/ http://weedcontrolfreaks.com/2017/04/gmos-and-herbicides-its...
- SlowBro 9y agoApparently the answer is not settled on that yet. http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600850 http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600850 https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/09/01/492091546/how-gmos-cut-the-use-of-pesticides-and-perhaps-boosted-them-again https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/09/01/492091546/ho...
- sebleon 9y agoMonsanto released Roundup-Ready Soybean in 1996 to INCREASE herbicide use, without affecting crop yield [1] Programs like Bt-corn reduce pesticide use... by making the plant produce the herbicide in the fruit. So, instead of being able to peel or rinse fruit (with varying results), you're eating corn kernels that have pesticide on the inside. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_soybean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_soybean
- tptacek 9y agoThat's not a fair description of what GMO herbicide resistance means. The other way to frame it is: GMOs allow you to make use of simpler, broad-spectrum herbicides with fewer known health impacts on animal life, as opposed to selective grass- and broadleaf-targeting herbicides that have known, proven human health risks but no PR due to a lack of connection to GMOs. Unless you're paying $3/# for carrots, herbicides are in the mix one way or the other. GMOs allow us to be pickier about which herbicides we're exposed to. Regarding IPR issues: you're referring to Monsanto lawsuits. Monsanto enforced its IPR against people who not only planted Roundup-ready crops, but then used Roundup on them --- in other words, people who took advantage of the IPR itself, not merely people who happened to plant Roundup-ready seeds unknowingly. Farmers don't accidentally spray their crops with Glyphosate.
- Retric 9y agoWe are at the point where vast stretches of land are used to grow food that's turned into fuel because we don't have any other real use for it. People don't see benefit from increased farming efficiency at this point, they just get stuck with the risks. 15.1 billion bushels of corn... wasted.
- Fins 9y agoDoesn't that have something to do with government mandates and subsidies for adding ethanol to fuel? It could have been well used for something more important.
- PatchMonkey 9y agoRoundup causes some serious cancer. Maybe its not directly toxic like agent orange, but these chemicals are still dangerous.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoThis is reminiscent of the "debate" over cellular radiation causing cancer. How much Roundup do I have to drink to increase my cancer risk by a percentage point?
- SlowBro 9y agoAnother concern is cross-contamination. A three minute video from CBS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MkH08772A4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MkH08772A4
- wolco 9y agoUsing GMO to make plants resistant so they can dose at high levels is exactly what they are doing vs trying to grow a super carrot.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoThe use of pesticides in non-GMO crops is likely one of the major factors for a modern extinction event. There's been a 75% decline in the total biomass of flying insects over the last 27 years (http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0185809 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....). This is affecting the entire ecosystem. GMO crops can be engineered to be pest resistant, requiring far less use of pesticides, without harming the crop's suitability for human consumption. Ignorance on this issue is destroying ecosystems in agricultural areas.
- diyseguy 9y agohttp://news.cornell.edu/stories/1999/04/toxic-pollen-bt-corn-can-kill-monarch-butterflies http://news.cornell.edu/stories/1999/04/toxic-pollen-bt-corn...
- thaumaturgy 9y agoOkay, so pollen from Bt corn is lethal to monarch butterfly caterpillars. Meanwhile, pesticides are killing off 75% of all flying insects. I like monarchs, but if I had to choose between a world with no monarchs, and a world with no monarchs and also just 25% of the flying insect biomass we had 30 years ago and also fewer birds and everything else that consumes insects and all of the beneficial pollination that those 75% of insects would have accounted for ... well, that seems like a pretty easy choice to me. Gene editing would also provide an avenue for a different approach here, where the crop could be made resistant to its costliest pests without harming monarchs. Good luck doing that through cross-breeding.
- AstralStorm 9y agoBut can we live in a world where food is 1000% though? That would be the result of getting rid of pesticides and insecticides...
- avodonosov 9y ago> my only option is to buy non-GMO everything. That doesn't make any sense. A viable option actually.
- baumandm 9y agoSurprisingly, avoiding GMO foods may not be as viable as one might think: > Currently, up to 92% of U.S. corn is genetically engineered (GE), as are 94% of soybeans and 94% of cotton (cottonseed oil is often used in food products). It has been estimated that upwards of 75% of processed foods on supermarket shelves – from soda to soup, crackers to condiments – contain genetically engineered ingredients. [1] [1] https://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/issues/311/ge-foods/about-ge-foods https://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/issues/311/ge-foods/abou...
- code_duck 9y agoYou can buy all organic or non-GMO certified foods.
- RobLach 9y agoClose, but it’s food producers who buy organic and non-gmo certifications which additionally makes them jump through a couple arbitrary hoops to make it seemingly mean something.
- code_duck 9y agoSo, you are saying that the certifications are not meaningful in that companies and certifiers cheat on the standards, or that the standards are inadequate?
- baumandm 9y agoMy point was that it's easy for the average person to want to avoid GMO foods, but harder for them to give up their Coca-Colas, Oreos, etc.
- JepZ 9y agoI think there are lots of problems with GM stuff. It all starts with 'We have only one earth'. The vacuum of space combined with the stickiness of matter isolates biological systems very well. So if someone would start a genetically modified plant series on some space station or distant planet I would have much less of a problem with that. Second, I have got the feeling that many people who experiment with genetic manipulation don't know what they are actually doing. Yes, they might know it on a high-level perspective and for experiments that is fine, but as long as we can't simulate even single cells its is hard to tell that we know what we are doing. As a computer scientist it feels to me like someone is patching the binaries of 'grep' and 'cp' together and hopes to use the resulting binaries to build autonomous drones. It is just irresponsible to use the results are long as the have only one petri dish which is actually the one we are living in. So don't get me wrong, I am completely pro research, but also completely against usage outside of laboratories. There might be exceptions to that rule when it comes to 'specific modification' as you call it, but for me it ends where you could not achieve the same result with a handful of normal breeding cycles.
- UncleMeat 9y ago> Second, I have got the feeling that many people who experiment with genetic manipulation don't know what they are actually doing. This is frankly ridiculous. You describe yourself as a computer scientist and presumably have no expertise in the field and then use your gut feeling about how well people understand the consequences of their efforts? I know plenty of people who think that I'm just typing words and random until my code compiles. Demanding that we are able to model living organisms in computers before we can productionize gmo tech is like saying that we can't deploy any web app until it has been formally verified in Coq.
- JepZ 9y agoWell, the difference is that we aren't living in the web. So even if the web goes down, the rest of the internet is still there and even without the internet we would survive. So if we would live within the web, I would certainly demand to formally verify every web app before it would be deployed.
- SlowBro 9y ago> As a consumer, if I ever get suspicious about one specific change made to one specific breed, my only option is to buy non-GMO everything. That doesn't make any sense! It seems rational to me that the operation is on its head. If I want to grow GMO soy I just buy it, plant it, and spray it. But if I want to certify Organic I must go through a rigorous and expensive authorization process. I’d like to see it exactly the opposite: If you use proven, centuries-old methods it’s easy, but if you want to spray and use weird stuff it requires a rigorous and expensive authorization process. Don’t we do that in other industries? Why not with our own food?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 9y agoYou can grow food however you like, for the most part. If you want to participate in certification, then that's what you have to do. Furthermore, many modern 'organic' methods are anything but centuries old. Heavy use of Bacillus thuringiensis toxin, copper compounds, compost tea, etc. etc. are all quite new. That's not to say they aren't safe; there are a few practices which warrant more scrutiny, but for the most part they're alright. But the point is that many people are terribly mischaracterizing actual farming practices.
- SlowBro 9y ago> You can grow food however you like, for the most part. If you want to participate in certification, then that's what you have to do. Yes you can grow as you like but it seems backwards to me that you have to prove you are /not/ doing unusual things. If any regulation should occur it ought to be in doing the /unusual/ things. > Furthermore, many modern 'organic' methods I'm not speaking of newer methods. I would have any new method more strictly regulated until proven.
- thunfischbrot 9y agoI am not arguing against your core point, but would like to point out that "unusual" itself is going to be difficult to define, as are terms such as "natural".