6 ms·
I haven't been following this stuff super closely, but hasn't there been ongoing counternarrative of how CA data analysis and its 50 million profiles may not ha
by danso 9y ago
I haven't been following this stuff super closely, but hasn't there been ongoing counternarrative of how CA data analysis and its 50 million profiles may not have been very useful, period? Because there's a concurrent (and legitimate) narrative of Facebook's questionable data practices, I've been wondering whether CA has been an overhyped antagonist in our media's rush to find the true villains.
Yesterday Drudge Report (still one of our biggest news drivers) had a headline [A] that almost made my eyes roll through the back of my head. It was "WHISTLEBLOWER: FACEBOOK CAN HEAR YOU!" But the linked story [B] contained nothing more than Wylie speculating how it was physically possible for Facebook (and other apps) to do this, but they probably weren't, but if they were, it could lead into some bad shit or something.
Yeah, Wylie can't control what linkbaiters write about him. Or what politicians ask him in a public hearing. But because he was a whistleblower about CA's abuse of FB's data, he's been considered an expert/whistleblower in domains far beyond what he actually has experience in. Being a good data analyst and having a bunch of FB scraped data is still not enough to remotely guarantee success in the startup scene.
In terms of the election, what's the most substantive discussion/proof that CA and its magic data was any more a game changer than, say, Brad Pascale [0]? And I also haven't read out CA's insights were a gamechanger in boosting the Russians' alleged propaganda and fake news bots schemes. I haven't yet read a better reporter on this angle than the New Yorker's Adrian Chen, and his relative reluctance to blame big data/bot schemes has perhaps made me too skeptical every time I read media stories about CA's magical mind-bending dataset [1].
[A] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DZVzHctU8AAZBxa.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DZVzHctU8AAZBxa.jpg:large
[B] http://web.archive.org/web/20180328111429/https://pjmedia.com/trending/cambridge-analytica-whistleblower-facebook-may-listening-home-work/ http://web.archive.org/web/20180328111429/https://pjmedia.co...
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2018/02/27/trumps-facebook-advertising-advantage-explained/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2018/02/27/t...
[1] https://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/a-so-called-experts-uneasy-dive-into-the-trump-russia-frenzy https://www.newyorker.com/tech/elements/a-so-called-experts-...
- bromuro 9y agoIndeed I even think the overreactions we see about this “scandal” is because media in general love to follow such catastrophic plots and spread false or enhanced news. As always. Many articles i read don’t understand even what happened and, from here, the whole thing seems a big bluff that will shake the internet based economy and powers. Best we can do is ignore this case and go back to our life. It’s however an interesting phenomenon under many points of view.
- tmuir 9y agoYou know how Donald Trump says he doesn't telegraph his moves? You know how Donald Trumps supporters talk a lot about 4D chess? There are several people playing 4D chess with Donald. The Cambridge Analytica story is lining up a path to Donald's opponent's queen, to entice him into taking that queen. Once the queen is taken, Donald Trump is in check, possibly mate. And its all because Donald telegraphed his moves. You've been triggered so hard to believe the Fake News narrative, you don't have a snowballs chance in hell at detecting the difference in this story. Its the same for your boy. Facebook is the Red Herring, the delicious smoked creature served up on a platter to those most likely to bite into it. Donald Trump will be (already is) in check, because once he bites on the controversy that Facebook losing control of the data is the actual problem at the root of this story, he will gush to us all about his far superior data operation, that hardly relied on facebook at all. It is as Donald spits these flakes of herring meat he will confess. You know how I've told you alot of this story in the future tense. Well, it turns out some of the players confessed right away, but they still don't know it. Here's one now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fFbVwuU8bM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fFbVwuU8bM
- tmuir 9y agoOh, I almost forgot. A good way to think about downvotes is your subconcsious admission that the best recourse you have to any argument is to try and make sure as few other people read it as possible. That means part of you that you have no control over knows the truth, but for whatever reason, decides your better off not knowing that truth.
- rdtsc 9y ago> There are several people playing 4D chess with Donald. The Cambridge Analytica story is lining up a path to Donald's opponent's queen, to entice him into taking that queen. Once the queen is taken, Donald Trump is in check, possibly mate. > It is as Donald spits these flakes of herring meat he will confess. Who are these people setting this 4D (special relativity?) chess game up? If I had to guess why your posts are downvoted is because they sound too conspiratory. The conspiracy is what I like to call "Trump is getting impeached next Thursday" conspiracy. This has been running since inauguration pretty much. He was going to be impeached after Comey's hearing, after Flynn was talking with Mueller, after Russians were indicted and in general pretty much every other week in between. Your post is in the same category as it has the "aha he is taking the bait, and we finally go him, just wait a few more days...".
- IAmEveryone 9y agoThe doubts about CA's real-world effectiveness are actually well-represented in the media, as your example or [0] show. This actually closely follows the a similar news cycle right after the election. I distinctly remember reading several articles casting doubt on CA's effectiveness in The New York Times and The Atlantic. I also don't think many reports actually assert that CA was responsible for, say, a 10% swing. Why people are taking this serious is, I believe, because we now know that it's possible to get such data and we have seen the sort of feats that machine learning can do today. It's doubtful that CA was the company to successfully combine those two ingredients. But without changes it's all but guaranteed that someone will soon will. Plus there is the fact that the election just happened to be incredibly close. You can make a list with about ten possible reasons for the result, from people being tired of Hillary, to the FBI's strange moves regarding the e-mail investigation, third-party candidates, russian trolls, the free media Trump got, Cambridge Analytica, and probably the weather in eastern Ohio. It's possible that the absence of any two or three of these would have changed the outcome. [0]: example: https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/23/17152564/cambridge-analytica-psychographic-microtargeting-what https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/3/23/17152564/ca...
- tmuir 9y agoLets imagine you developed a Deep Learning algorithm that proved beyond a shadow of a doubt to be able to pull off what CA pulled off. Why on god's green earth would you ever tell people that you have the algorithm, if you could instead use it for your own benefit? Why would you ever publish?
- mmirate 9y agoAnswer A: in the case that you think you can publish at just the right time such that every political party would have enough time to master the tech before the next election cycle. Answer B: in the case that you can charge exorbitantly for access to the published algorithm, and that - being a rational actor without nationalistic pride - you don't give two hoots and a holler what happens to the nation where you publish, so long as you can walk away with a fat paycheck.
- deckard1 9y agoThe effectiveness of CA is a red herring. All one has to do is watch Channel 4's Cambridge Analytica videos to see that the CEO is on video promising things which are both unethical and illegal, and a subversion of democracy. Sales pitch or not, the content itself is damning. If I promise you I can provide you illegal drugs, weapons, child porn, etc. but don't actually have those things, does that make me a better person than if I actually did have those things? At the very best, I'm still a lying snake oil salesman. Except, I'm not promising a medical remedy. I'm promising you illegal and unethical things. This isn't a car that just happens to be a lemon.
- quadrangle 9y agoI hate-hate-hate-hate to be putting any doubt on this particular case, but we have to start prepping for the world when it's trivial enough to create complete faked videos. The tech is here already. So, at least in the future, it will be possible that even such videos as those are merely inserting completely faked words and gestures etc. How will we evaluate truth in the future? It won't be by trusting videos. It will somehow go back to he-said she-said and figuring out who we can trust. But if different people trust totally different sources, then agreement about truths seems it will end up being limited to easily testable facts and predictions. What is going to happen in a world where your comment could apply to anyone because such a video of unethical promises could be generated of anyone??
- tmuir 9y agoWell, then you're gonna love love love love this. Faked videos are certainly bad, but lets travel in our mental time machines back to February 18th 1990, the day before Photoshop was released. "We are rapidly nearing a world when its trivial enough to create complete faked pictures", they cried. "How will we evaluate truth in the future?" "Hah," you exclaim. "You can just look at the pixels. There is always a way to tell if you look close enough." But alas, they can't hear you, because this is my time machine, and I said so. Just because we haven't had to adapt our lives to the new reality yet, doesn't mean we wont with the same relative ease we always have once that reality smacks us in the face.
- conistonwater 9y agoWhy does it have to be counternarrative (specifically counter-)? Crooks don't need to be effective to be crooks.