4 ms·
Won't the market sort out whatever this is? Is there a specific unfair mechanism at play that would prevent supply and demand from finding its balance?
by Waterluvian 9y ago
Won't the market sort out whatever this is?
Is there a specific unfair mechanism at play that would prevent supply and demand from finding its balance?
- chroem- 9y agoThe fact that people need a source of income to live, and that they have very little influence on the price of their labor without collective bargaining.
- apsec112 9y agoPeople also need food to live, and they have no influence on the price of food; you can't go into Safeway and get a prime steak for $1.50. Yet there is such an abundance of food at such low prices that half of Westerners are overweight. The labor market must have other issues, besides these, if it's having more problems than the food market.
- 1812Overture 9y agoThe grocery stores I go to have price tags on everything.
- AstralStorm 9y agoAnd job offers typically come without price brackets. Moreover the requirements are often written (or processed into mush) by a person who has no clue. This puts you at a major disadvantage. And then there is the problem that a company can easily outwit and outwait you as they have a big buffer. Only people currently in stable jobs or with plenty of f.u. money can match it. If there is a slump in demand or peak in worker supply you will have even less bargaining power.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoThat's not how supply and demand works. I'm on the supply side of the labor supply-and-demand curve. I set the price that I'm willing to sell my time at. Nobody else sets my price, and I don't set anybody else's price. On the demand side, there are a bunch of employers who each have their own price for what they're willing to pay for a certain set of skills. Each sets their own price. Nobody else sets it for them. In particular, nobody on the supply side can possibly set the price the demand side is willing to pay. Now, all of what I just said presumes a functioning supply-and-demand market. It breaks down if there's collusion between employers, or in a single-employer situation. Unions may well be needed in such situations. But in a working labor market, demanding more than market price for labor will result in lower demand for labor.
- AstralStorm 9y agoIt also breaks due to secrecy in salary structure at companies on demand side. A worker on supply side only has very limited resources to figure out how valuable the offers are.
- paulddraper 9y agoDon't forget the fact that companies need employees to survive and they have very little influence on the price of the labor without (illegal) collusion.
- AstralStorm 9y agoNot true. They have the ultimate influence on the salaries once they have hired enough people. They can just not hire. A person cannot really "not be hired" for prolonged time unless they're already rich. Most cannot tolerate unemployment for even a short time. Even students who don't have many commitments cannot do so for too long. Only for very small companies this is somewhat true.
- paulddraper 9y ago> They have the ultimate influence on the salaries once they have hired enough people. They can just not hire. Likewise, employees have the ultimate influence on salaries once they have enough leverage in the job market. A company hiring is like a person finding a job: they only have to once for a long period of time. A company paying a salary is like a person working a job: they have to do it constantly. --- You can say the cards are stack in the favor of employers, and they sometimes are, but remember 4 out of 5 businesses fail. Four out of five individuals do not go bankrupt.
- quaunaut 9y agoDisclaimer: I use no data, only going off of personal experience and friend circle anecdotes to create a theory. The balance is that in some ways, we have economy-wide collusion-by-default to keep wages artificially low. I know this sounds ridiculous, but I think we've hit the point of increasing returns on job growth depression. When one looks at the rate of underemployment and the employment rate writ large, it seems like the number of jobs is just few enough that the pay doesn't have to go up, regardless. Furthermore, many industries don't seem to really pay attention to using wage as a lever. Often, this is because individual companies have difficulty justifying hiring someone at 20-30% more than their counterparts, and their counterparts haven't received a significant wage increase in years, often decades. When combined with the rate of inflation not being matched by wage growth, it begins to look "normal" to many employers that wages should be particularly low.
- patientplatypus 9y agoLike, duh. Classic Marx https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_army_of_labour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_army_of_labour
- quickben 9y agoThere is. It's called rent to pay. The employers can out wait the potential employee. My biggest career jumps were when I had a job. Toronto, Canada: all job offers when I was unemployed were advertised+2k. All job offers while employed were at least 5k over current salary (and up to 20k).
- ken 9y agoThe market always clears, but while that's good for the market, it's not necessarily good for the participants. For example, if women don't apply for jobs unless they meet 100% of the listed requirements [1], and men are much more willing to fudge it, that means this particular market won't clear in a fair manner. This hiring data isn't public, so a company won't lose sales over it, so the market can't correct it on the other end, either. And that's probably not the only way to slice the set of job-seekers into people who will/won't apply for a job based on the requirements. Essentially, impossible-sounding criteria do filter your set of applicants, but not by the criteria you claim to care about. [1]: https://hbr.org/2014/08/why-women-dont-apply-for-jobs-unless-theyre-100-qualified https://hbr.org/2014/08/why-women-dont-apply-for-jobs-unless...
- crimsonalucard 9y agoThings in nature are rarely in equilibrium. What you see with your eyes to today is the aftermath of what remains after multitudes of systems have overloaded and destroyed themselves. To assume that markets sort everything out is folly. Nature tends towards entropy.
- mrob 9y agoMarkets only sort everything out if the incentives are right. Stock markets are efficient because people can make money out of predicting future prices. But people don't always benefit from making good hiring decisions. They might even be punished for hiring the best, because companies are made out of competing individuals, and an excessively good candidate could make them look worse by comparison. Hiring markets are optimized for ass-covering, not profit. The experience requirements let people deflect the blame if anything goes wrong.