2 ms·
There are three camps: statehood, independence, and status quo. Over time, statehood has captured more and more of the vote, and probably constitutes a pluralit
by jcranmer 9y ago
There are three camps: statehood, independence, and status quo. Over time, statehood has captured more and more of the vote, and probably constitutes a plurality of the vote at this time (maybe a majority, I don't know), followed somewhat closely by status quo and very distantly by independence.
The operative word is probably: the most recent referendums were designed to provoke the statehood option, leading to the results being ignored as not providing a clear mandate. Constant relitigation of the issue over the past decade doesn't help with apathy. It doesn't help that status quo may not be a realistic option: there's a lot of unclear legal issues with little appetite to litigate them.
I suspect that Puerto Rico will eventually become a state, but it's politically difficult for that to happen without a clear mandate, and there doesn't seem to be much appetite for providing a truly fair and clear referendum in this matter.
- s2g 9y agoGetting screwed during the last hurricane will hopefully push more people towards statehood. Lot harder to ignore them when they have 2 senators and a rep to raise hell.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt'll push more people to decolonialization, I'm sure, but where statehood or independence gets the boost is unclear. It won't matter as long as Congress isn't interested in decolonialization.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The operative word is probably: the most recent referendums were designed to provoke the statehood option The most recent referendum was held only because the federal government preferred another referendum to honoring the statehood win in the prior referendum, which had 78.19% turnout, and a two-question format where a clear majority chose not to continue territorial status and a clear majority chose statehood as the new status. > I suspect that Puerto Rico will eventually become a state, but it's politically difficult for that to happen without a clear mandate There was a clear mandate after the 2012 status referendum. It is difficult when a majority of Congress doesn't want it to happen for reasons for mostly partisan political reasons, and will seize on any excuse to ignore thr clear desire to end the colonial relation.