3 ms·
I won't get into a debate over the merits of JFK's catch phrase, "Ask not how the state can serve you, ask how you can serve the state." If having the populatio
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I won't get into a debate over the merits of JFK's catch phrase, "Ask not how the state can serve you, ask how you can serve the state." If having the population serve the state is the goal, why not actually help them serve the state in some significant way?
All I was pointing out is that the vast majority of what you find on this site is irrelevant. It's nothing innovative, it's just advertisement for various departmental outreach projects. A poster contest on carbon monoxide safety? "Help Fight Environmental Crime Art Contest"? "A video contest promoting a healthy weight..."?
If you actually want to crowdsource public problems, do it. I seriously doubt that will happen, since disruptive innovation might put some government workers out of work, but if you can do it, great. This site just isn't it, and isn't even in the ballpark.
(I'll grant that a couple of good prizes are advertised there, as pointed out by poet. I clicked around a bit more, but didn't see any significant contests besides the green car/green plane contest he pointed out.)
- jbooth 16y agoYou got JFK's quote wrong. If you're deliberately going to mischaracterize anyone to the left of Newt Gingrich, why even pretend to debate?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOops, my mistake, I substituted one synonym ("state") for another ("country"). But how did I mischaracterize the quote? In what way is the meaning different. Regardless, you are ducking the main point to nitpick a small quotation error.
- gjm11 16y ago> In what way is the meaning different? The "state" means not only the nation but the government. The "country" means, er, the country. JFK did not say, and plainly did not mean, "ask what you can do to help the government".
- krschultz 16y agoAsk not what your neighbors can do for you, ask what you can do for your neighbors. Ask not what the building inspector can do for you, but what you can do for the building inspector. That is the differene between "country" and "state" on a local level.
- jbooth 16y agoThere's a world of difference, and you know that, otherwise you wouldn't have rephrased it in order to try and provoke an emotional reaction. The main point was, what, that not every single project on this list is world changing? Good. Little changes add up and are easier to achieve. There were some big projects on the list as well.
- krschultz 16y agoCountry != government
- anigbrowl 16y agoVirtual worlds, digital forensics, spaceship batteries, wireless power transmission, nano-satellites, tether materials suitable for space use, economic modelling tools for the small/medium business sector - I see plenty of tech-oriented, hacker-friendly challenges which would cost a lot of money if they were contracted out, and which would have quite legitimate uses in defense, security, space, or treasury - areas where most agree the government has legitimate functions, even if you disapprove of government involvement in social policy.