6 ms·
This is a perfect summation of how people feel about Google and Amazon, or Sears in the 1920s and Kodak in the 1960s. And it's a perfect reminder that monopolie
by legitster 9y ago
This is a perfect summation of how people feel about Google and Amazon, or Sears in the 1920s and Kodak in the 1960s. And it's a perfect reminder that monopolies are much more fleeting than people realize.
- twiceaday 9y agoI have a sneaking suspicion that with every dissolved monopoly future monopolies get stronger. They must religiously case study all prior cases and strengthen the right areas.
- tantalor 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- falcolas 9y agoWell, yes. Evolution is heavily influenced by survivorship biases.
- nostrademons 9y agoI don't think that's true. We speak of AppAmaGooBook now (i.e. an oligopoly of 4 major players), while in the 1990s it was "Wintel" (2 players, one a hardware monopoly and one a software monopoly) and in the 60s it was "IBM and the 7 dwarfs" (i.e. IBM was the only relevant computer company). IBM controlled 70 percent of the whole computer market, around what Google controls of the Search market now, which is a small subfield of computation. And these all pale in comparison to 19th century monopolies, like Standard Oil (90% of U.S. refining capacity in 1880) or American Tobacco (100% of the tobacco market in 1900). I think the reason they seem bigger is because the economy is bigger, and so in dollar and output terms they are bigger. But that also means there are more niches and greater complexity, and it becomes harder to sustain a monopoly against multiple competitive threats over time. While the playbook of monopoly managers has expanded since 1900, the number of adversaries they face has expanded faster.
- aidos 9y agoIronically it took me a moment to realize that Book was Facebook :-) This is a great comment to put things in perspective. It’s easy to forget that Google has only had “dominance” for about a decade. They have diversified quite a lot though (autonomous vehicles, the mobile market etc). And Apple literally have enough cash stockpiled to takeover countries if they choose to wage war. It’s all pretty fleeting though.
- zjaffee 9y agoThe difficult comparison here is that we have never seen any company monopolize so much of media as we have facebook and google do world wide. The only comparable example I see is possibly disney, and I wouldn't be surprised to see facebook and google succeeding far into the future due to well targeted acquisitions. Additionally, it's important to remember that all of the largest american oil companies today are descendants of standard oil, and I imagine such could very well be likely if any of these other big monopolies were broken up today when it comes to the internet.
- mseebach 9y agoThe point is that when declaring "this time it's different", you have to explain away all the many, many things that are exactly the same, and not just point out the one thing that's a little different. The Facebook/CA scandal broke in traditional media, and traditional media hasn't exactly been downplaying the possibility of Facebook-powered "fake news" influencing of elections, either. I think that tells you everything you need to know about the purported monopolisation of the media by Facebook.
- ohtwenty 9y agoThere's an interesting point in comparing to old companies, mainly that they were actually ridiculously big: https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2012/08/22/a-history-of-ridiculously-big-companies.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2012/08/22/a-history-...
- amphibian87 9y agothat's what Frank Herbert theorized with CHOAM Company in Dune. Eventually one company managed everything from food stuffs to military kit to intergalactic space engine fuel. I think they even set the contracts for the pilot's guild, and do orbital surveillance, so it's not just goods but services. Seems realistic to me, when capitalism stops working as envisaged by its own founder, because the mechanism of the state gets bought out by the capitalists, and isn't enforcing anti-trust laws or competition.
- brianpan 9y agoI'm not so sure that FB's place will be so fleeting. I think they will lose their place at the same rate that Microsoft lost theirs. They will still be around in 15 years later, just not quite as relevant.
- dexterdog 9y agoBut a social media site that is what they are can't live with 33% market penetration. They need to be at 90+.
- rb808 9y agotodays market cap: MSFT: 688.28B FB: 444.55B
- treis 9y agoFB is different because they buy competitors. Between WhatsApp and Instagram they've managed to insulate themselves against game changing competitors. So even if traditional FB dies Facebook the company will live on.
- gfo 9y ago"Embrace, extend, extinguish" -Microsoft's old motto. This is exactly how they previously did business and still do, frankly. Facebook's core business functions purely on user data though and that's how they use the rest of their businesses to make money. If traditional Facebook dies their other businesses won't be far behind without significant change that doesn't disrupt revenue.
- gfo 9y agoMicrosoft is coming back in a big way though. Sure, it may not have the dominance it used to have but they've learned from the problems of the Ballmer era. Satya Nadella seems to be a huge proponent of meeting customers where they are and it's paying off in a huge way. If Facebook learns to listen to their customers the way Microsoft has (as opposed to trying to tell them what they want) then they could recover. But with Facebook, users are starting to have large issues with its core business model, and to listen to customers and adopt the changes they want, it would cost them too much and would eventually disappear as so many others have before them.
- Nomentatus 9y ago"Fleeting" - in that another more permanent and more powerful monopoly supersedes them, such as Wordstar, then Wordperfect, then Word. Eventually the roulette ball comes to rest, particularly if the laws that countervail market power aren't enforced.
- mseebach 9y agoThe roulette ball is still moving. Word is getting hammered by lightweight, online, mobile-available, collaboration-first tools, such as Google Docs and Quip.
- tazjin 9y agoSocial platforms are much "easier" to rebuild and actually gain market share with (because they're to a large extent self-contained, you "just" need the users). No company is really competing with Google on search. There's DuckDuckGo and all that, which is a nice idea, but their results are just nowhere near as good as Google's in most cases.
- yellowapple 9y ago"There's DuckDuckGo and all that, which is a nice idea, but their results are just nowhere near as good as Google's in most cases." I don't agree with that assessment. Occasionally I'll need to stick a !g at the front of my search, but usually DDG does a good enough job with the results (and when it fails, Google usually fails, too).
- seba_dos1 9y agoRecently I have switched all my browsers to DDG and found myself almost never having to fallback to Google. It became pretty good, sometimes even better due to Google trying too hard to interpret what I meant.
- emodendroket 9y agoSometimes the synonym searching doesn't make a lot of sense -- you can search for "mens socks" and it'll give you "womens socks," with "womens" highlighted. You can fix this with quoting terms, but how many people know to do that?
- jiveturkey 9y agoyour evaluation is different than the GP’s. your DDG results are usually “good enough” so you don’t check google until they aren’t. since i’ve gone back to using google as primary i’ve found the results are better. anyway you are both speaking anecdotally but arguing as if you speak for the general case. at the risk of making the same mistake, i bet that in the general case google is better.
- wainstead 9y ago> how people feel about Google and Amazon, or Sears in the 1920s and Kodak in the 1960s Or IBM. https://www.nytimes.com/1981/02/15/business/us-vsibm.html https://www.nytimes.com/1981/02/15/business/us-vsibm.html
- lr4444lr 9y agoIndeed. The Pennsylvania Railroad Company still holds the record for longest sequence of years (over 100) paying out stock dividends. Sic transit gloria mundi!
- djsumdog 9y agoThe other examples weren't really monopolies. AT&T was a monopoly, but there were other camera and film manufactures even in the Kodak days. Just because they're the biggest doesn't make them a monopoly. Google is probably the closest to a modern day monopoly in many (but not all) markets. The competitors like DDG, Bing and Yahoo make up such a small percentage of the market share that Google has become the de-facto standard for search, unless you're in places like China and Russia. I'm using the term loosely too, because technically a Monopoly is when only a single supplier exists on the market. Typically monopolies start out as government agencies (AT&T, Telstra, TelecomNZ .. telecos are great examples of this btw) but the rest are really relative monopolies. There are other suppliers, but they pale in market percentage (Microsoft was declared a monopoly by many EU courts even when people were still using macos).
- lerpa 9y agoNatural monopolies are like that. Artificial ones are either Govenrment enterprises or Government enforced taking what was initially natural one and making it into law, and tend to overstay their welcome because of that. Monopolies are good as long as they can be gone in the flip of a hat if people decide so.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn the meantime a monopoly can have a huge effect on people's lives.