3 ms·
It's always bothered me when people, (justifiably) frustrated with the bubble effect that personalization can effect upon search results, want to see Google ret
by danso 9y ago
It's always bothered me when people, (justifiably) frustrated with the bubble effect that personalization can effect upon search results, want to see Google return to "objective" results. But PageRank/BackRub was never an objective metric, it was always affected by what webmasters chose to link to and the semantic markup they wrote. It seemed to be a good metric for a majority of these things, but assuming few webmasters in the early years were black women or black, then the "objective" metric of PageRank/BackRub is going to be dismal.
So yes, I agree that more pressure needs to be put on the algorithm-makers, so that there isn't complacency about accepting the results of "pure" computation. But I feel too much weight is given toward the sentiment of "If Google isn’t responsible for its algorithm, then who is?", as if the problems could be wholly or even substantially fixed through "modifications to its algorithm". The other side of the equation is the data -- and diversity is as important to have in media as it is to tech, even if tech feels like the stronger, more immediate lever in changing things.
Now that it's been a long time (in tech time) since 2010/2012, it'd be interesting to hear exactly what modifications/improvements Google made to its algorithm to return such different results for "black girls". Was it a de-emphasizing of negative/outdated sources? Or an arbitrary boost for such entities as "Black Girls Code"? Or was BGC not given an arbitrary boost, but found to have been unjustly ignored/under-weighted when it came to determining SERP? I understand not wanting to reveal details of search engine tweaks the day/month/year after they've been implemented. But half a decade later, hopefully learning more details of these "tweaks" won't leave Google vulnerable to black-hat SEO.