2 ms·
> Democratic voting is always manipulated, every media source and conversation and political speech you see is "manipulation". I don't like this kind of slippe
by munificent 9y ago
> Democratic voting is always manipulated, every media source and conversation and political speech you see is "manipulation".
I don't like this kind of slippery slope whataboutism because shades of difference do matter, often profoundly. If I pat you on the back, slap you in the face, or kick you in the genitals, they're all "hitting you", so what's the difference, right? But those are different things, and discarding information by tossing them all in the same bucket makes for a less sophisticated analysis.
There are real differences between:
* A trusted friend telling you they like candidate X because Y.
* A reputable news organization writing a factual article about something candidate X did.
* A biased media source writing a clickbait opinion piece that presents itself as "news" when it's really pushing an agenda funded by its backers.
* A political advertisement paid for and from a candidate.
* A political advertisement paid for and acknowledging itself to be from some corporate super PAC.
* A political advertisement that is paid for by a corporate interest but deliberately obscures that fact.
* A political advertisement stating things that are factually untrue.
* A political advertisement that claims to be from group A but is actually from group B.
Etc.
In order to correctly process the information we're receiving, we need to know the context around it. The way that context is presented or obscured, relative to our own expectations for that context, matters hugely.
> Why is social media any different?
Because it was hyper-targeted to individuals based on psychological profiles of what those people are predisposed to believe and accept. The manipulation was expressly designed to undermine our ability to reason critically and correctly understand the intent and accuracy of the presented information.
- dilap 9y agoThe whole idea that underlies the premise of your comment is that people cannot be trusted to make up their own minds about the arguments they are exposed to, and must be protected from bad information. I think that idea is contrary to the ideal of a free society.