5 ms·
Is there any reason that Cassandra is the focus of this article? It is really silly and irresponsible to peg a nascent project like that without any reasoning o
by cookiecaper 16y ago
Is there any reason that Cassandra is the focus of this article? It is really silly and irresponsible to peg a nascent project like that without any reasoning or sources. I'm sure something changed besides just a Cassandra rollout, and wasn't Digg using it on v3 too?
I think Cassandra is pretty well tested. There have been lots of super-large-scale deployments. It just seems lame to blame it on that, but I guess maybe their anonymous sources inside Digg revealed it? But then we'd hope they'd know if the problem was with the datastore or the implementation.
- riffraff 16y agoas far as I remember: yes they were using it on v3 too, for some things
- sfrench 16y agoCassandra was used for a single feature on v3 called "Green Badges". I believe there is a post on the digg blog about the project, in particular.
- wsongk 16y agoAbout a year ago, they were using it to store a list of friends of viewing user who dugg the viewing news. original blog post: http://about.digg.com/blog/looking-future-cassandra http://about.digg.com/blog/looking-future-cassandra Treads on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813528 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=813528
- sliverstorm 16y agoPlacing all the blame on Cassandra helps Digg justify letting go the VP, since he was allegedly the guy who pushed it.
- TheCondor 16y agoSo what's the digg story here? I get that some VP suggested a new buzzwordy technology, they gave him enough rope to hang himself and he did and left the company with a broken pile of crap. It could happen, if you have a healthy company you give trust to people. That it got this far doesn't speak well of the rest of management. It doesn't speak really well of the rest of the team either. Shouldn't there have been some circuit breakers or something? Digg isn't a poor, bring-your-own-laptop startup. They've got resources, they've had substantial investment. They can afford to build and test software and I know of no real marketing reason they had to push something untested out. Rose could go out and say it wasn't done, it's going to take more time. How does Rose keep his job? Wasn't he this VP's boss? And it's single technology? That couldn't have been vetted and tested independently of all of digg? Really? And MongoDB, or hadoop, or one of the dozens of other nosqls wouldn't work, either? You do what you have to do and there is never a 'truth' with VPs and CxOs are canned, but it all doesn't float with me, just looks like another over valued and under talented company, got lucky and the blind squirrel found the nut, there isn't gonna be a second act. Maybe it just seems low brow to me, name and finger the guy, blame the opensource tool you use, never explain or elaborate why you launched anyways when you were fixing bugs in the tool at the 11th hour.
- sliverstorm 16y agoNever said I supported it. If my comment came across that way, I apologize.
- TheCondor 16y agoNo, I apologize. I didn't mean to sound like I was attacking you or suggest that you supported it. It just seemed like a good place to interject. It's such a transparent move on Digg's part.
- ojbyrne 16y agoI'm sure the real story is different. My rough guess at it is * the main marketing tool that digg has left is "Kevin Rose as genius" * Kevin and the people he drinks with pushed for the adoption of new cool technology. * the entire thing was a giant clusterfuck because of Kevin and the people he drinks with. * but once that became obvious there was a need for a scapegoat so that digg could keep its primary marketing tool.
- dillydally 16y agoThat reads like sour grapes.
- davidw 16y agoThat doesn't necessarily make it wrong, either:-)
- binaryfinery 16y agoReads like "industry experience" to me.
- nailer 16y agoPerhaps it's both?
- ojbyrne 16y ago
- jshen 16y agoReminds me of the way NASA blamed lisp back in the day
- epoxy 16y agoPart of the reason that Cassandra may be the focus is that Kevin Rose places much of the stability problems on Cassandra's shoulders. Two or three minutes into the most recent diggnation he talks about Cassandra and describes Cassandra as "very beta-stage software" and says how days before the launch at least some of their focus was on fixing "Cassandra problems" rather than issues with Digg v4. http://techcrunch.com/2010/09/07/kevin-rose-responds-to-digg-criticism-on-diggnation-mostly-tells-users-to-chill/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/09/07/kevin-rose-responds-to-digg...
- brown9-2 16y agoIf true, it's a lame excuse: blame should be placed on the people that decided to use the beta software to power their very-important-to-their-paycheck website
- mikeryan 16y agoSo if you watch the Revision3 video where they talk about the stability issues Kevin throws Cassandra out there nothing really specific but when discussing downtime its the only technical factor he mentions. He calls it "still beta software" and states they were fixing bugs in Cassandra during the days leading up to the release of v4.
- hga 16y agoIn reply to you and epoxy, sounds like a gross failure of engineering management. If you're having problems of this sort of foundational nature a few days before the planned release, it strongly suggests you should delay and figure out what's generally gone wrong with the project.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]