4 ms·
> There is a very simple solution to this problem of politicians and unions leaving future taxpayers on the hook. The state simply pays an insurance company for
by pessimizer 9y ago
> There is a very simple solution to this problem of politicians and unions leaving future taxpayers on the hook. The state simply pays an insurance company for an equivalent annuity. Or the state pays the union the normal cost (the cost of whatever defined benefit pension is earned in a year of work), and then it's the union's problem to fix its deficits.
I'm not sure why you think that what would be (pragmatically in Illinois) giving over state pensions to some state official's cousin to manage at their overextended insurance company that will fail at the first sign of stock weakness would fix anything, or is significantly different from what actually happened.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt would fix the problem of taxpayers being on the hook for it. It's the union and pension recipients job to ensure that their retirement money is managed properly, just like the rest of us do with our 401k.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhat happens when the insurance company goes out of business, because they made the same forecasting mistakes that the state government made 30 years ago?
- lotsofpulp 9y agoSame thing that happens anytime insurers go bust, policy holders eat some or all of the losses. It would then get political on if they're getting bailed out or not, but at least the taxpayers in general aren't on the hook, and if they are, then at least it's explicit. But the thing is insurers are actually subject to reserving and reporting requirements such that they would more accurately price annuities, and quite frankly, no insurer is stupid enough to offer such lavish defined benefit pensions because they know it's not affordable...unless you have a lien on future taxpayer funds.