6 ms·
This is typical. As a techie, you're triggered by technical detail because you understand the technical details of that example that is intended to illustrate t
by mrtksn 9y ago
This is typical. As a techie, you're triggered by technical detail because you understand the technical details of that example that is intended to illustrate the size of the data collected.
Rest assured that this happens all the time and when people read news about a topic that they are an expert on, they cringe all the time. For example, a paraglider pilot will get triggered if the reporter uses the word "Jumped" in a story about a paraglider pilot who crash-landed and injured two more people. This is because paragliders don't jump but take off from hills etc.
Usually reporting on technical topics is very hard because you need to reach the non-technical audience so you will HAVE TO use illustrative examples and not exactly accurate descriptions so that can be absorbed by the non-technical readers. Unfortunately, this will put you in a position where can be called on by technical readers who are triggered by the "implementation details" of your story.
I do believe that calling out the 5GB illustrative example is missing the point of the article. It's just a way to portray size of the data collected on you, it doesn't have any meaning even if this data was 3Mb or 100Gb. For example, if it was 3Mb Google might have used it to convey how little data they collect on you as if the size that this data takes has any correlation about the impact, then why even bother with such an irrelevant point of the "article implementation"?
- Beamer92 9y agoIs it really the responsibility of a journalist to hold the hand of people not well versed in the topic at the expense of technical correctness? I don't think so, I'd prefer we hold a standard of being correct and put the onus of education on the readers. They can Google what they don't understand. We can educate the public better to not be afraid of technical details. I agree with danarmak, this piece like so many others is just a bunch of sensationalized details. You should know what you're signing up for, nobody should be surprised by anything in there.
- mrtksn 9y ago>Is it really the responsibility of a journalist to hold the hand of people not well versed in the topic at the expense of technical correctness I think they don't have a choice but to do it this way. A typical news outlet will report on hundreds of topics a day and probably covering the entire spectrum of topics out there. How likely it is that all of the readers will be well versed in all the areas of expertise that human race was able to achieve in the last few thousands of years of recorded history? Also, these journalists[not necessarily this one but in general] are usually not experts on the topic that they write on and the better ones usually would consult with someone who is well versed on that topic. There's no way that the expert that the journalist is consulting with, will be able to educate the journalist, so he/she will dumb it down and then the reporter will dumb it down further and re-shape it in a form that the news outlet can sell it to its audience(right wing, left wing, alt-right, communist, highly educated ... whatever, they too are making a product for their customers).
- contextfree 9y agoIn this case the author is not (yet? apparently he is hoping to do this kind of thing full-time) a professional journalist but someone who made a viral Twitter thread, which was picked up by the media and of which the article is a lightly edited version.
- AmIFirstToThink 9y ago>You should know what you're signing up for, nobody should be surprised by anything in there. I agree. People will deal with this responsibility the way they deal with any other responsibility that an individual faces. - Ignore it. Go on hoping that it doesn't affect them. Hoping that someone more capable is looking into it and will stop these companies from doing the wrong thing. - Realize the significance of what they are agreeing to, and try to deal with it. They may find themselves hopelessly inadequate to deal with the might of Google/Facebook/Amazon/Twitter/Microsoft/Reddit. They may decide to be a monk going into hiding in the woods of no social presence, or they would try to live with the risk while realizing that the risk is always going to be there. - Realize that the risk they knew about has materialized. They would realize that it has gone way beyond their respective abilities to handle it as an individual. They would try to band together and demand change. Class action lawsuits, and legal restrictions. We stopped telecom companies, credit card companies, mortgage companies, electrical, water, gas utilities from doing certain things as part of the law of the land. Internet services like Google/Amazon/Microsoft/Facebook/Twitter can get regulated. - Outsource the responsibility. Consumer Protection Boards. Regulatory bodies. Auditors. Laws with punishment to get desired behavior. I was surprised by the position of Google/Facebook/Amazon/Twitter/Microsoft/Reddit/Netflix on Net Neutrality, just the sheet hypocrisy of it. They jumped up and down about an ISP possibly deteriorating the user experience for monetary gains. While they have been applying their powers for anything they wish, including political gains and psyops, not just monetary gains but power. Why isn't Canadian Human Rights commissions jumping up and down over YouTube and Twitter accounts being silenced? Baker should bake the cake but YouTube shouldn't show the video? I guess, the Baker should simply come up with community guidelines and call it a day. This is too funny.
- honr 9y agoSome of us do not subscribe to the "ends justify the means" theory. And with that, I'd consider this example a form of failed journalism. Regardless of whether or not there is actually an underlying point, this particular piece of pseudo-journalism didn't capture it. I chuckled when I read the author's description of himself/herself: "... who does extensive research into spreading technical awareness ...". One might think with the extensive research they have done so far, some of that technical awareness should have had reached the author, themselves.
- mrtksn 9y ago> Some of us do not subscribe to the "ends justify the means" theory I don't think that this is the case here. To be an "end justifies means" the writer would have to give a false information on an information that is relevant to the core of the story. Does it really matter what's the size of some digital data? Would it be O.K. if Google collected 100Mb of data but totally unacceptable if that was 5Gb? The size of the data is an irrelevant implementation detail of the story. Even assuming that this is all the data about you is silly in the first place but the articla is not about that - even if the title says so.
- danarmak 9y agoMy point was exactly that the size is irrelevant - because the data being measured is irrelevant to the story.
- danarmak 9y ago> I do believe that calling out the 5GB illustrative example is missing the point of the article. Please see my reply to bhauer's sibling comment, I think it applies here too. The problem isn't with the 5GB size or how they compare it to 3 million Word docs. The problem is with measuring the size of something completely irrelevant. The problem is with saying "Google collects data on you for advertising, they have data you wouldn't expect them to have" and then linking to data you explicitly, deliberately uploaded to Google yourself. The problem is with linking to Google Takeout and pretending it's something that it's not.
- Zak 9y agoThe difference between an incorrect description of a paraglider launch and a nonsensical comparison regarding the amount of data Google stores is that the latter is intentionally being presented as a proxy for the potential impact of that data. To be able to interpret the article in a useful way, it is important to be aware that a single long, high-res youtube video could be 5.5 Gb and therefore that figure doesn't imply anything about what google knows about you. Of course, it would be easy for a non-expert to mischaracterize an aircraft accident in a way that matters to a layperson's understanding of why the accident happened and who is responsible.
- faitswulff 9y agoThe word "triggered" should really be reserved for military vets and those who have experienced traumatic events in their past that would cause severe distress, not as a synonym for "annoyed." A veteran who relives the horrors of war when fireworks go off is not nearly in the same space as a developer who is annoyed that someone misused technical jargon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Xeoncross 9y ago> The word "triggered" should really be reserved for military vets Certainly not. While many military personal certainly have faced mind-altering situations, they are far from the only ones who have ever suffered from traumatic events. Children and Women are the subjects of the most twisted and abusive stories I've ever been able to fathom.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- therapeutic 9y agoThe full quote is: > The word "triggered" should really be reserved for military vets AND those who have experienced traumatic events in their past that would cause severe distress (emphasis mine) You can't just cut a sentence in half and then try to form an argument against it. That's not fair.
- Xeoncross 9y agoI agree, I don't think it said that when I wrote my comment.
- faitswulff 9y agoIt likely did not, I edited a few times.
- abandonliberty 9y agorelated: https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-gell-mann-amnesia-effect-is-as-follows-you https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-ge... “Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray's case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the "wet streets cause rain" stories. Paper's full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.”
- mrtksn 9y agoThank you for that!
- stronglikedan 9y agoWhen you start your article with, "I’m going to show just how much of your information the likes of Facebook and Google store about you without you even realising it", then include the user uploaded data in your proof, it's a bit disingenuous and reeks of FUD.
- wale 9y agoExactly.
- noxecanexx 9y agoBut that's the thing..the 5Gb data is mostly made of stuff you "uploaded" to Google, not stuff that was "collected"