4 ms·
In what way is this a "startup"? It looks more like thinly veiled advertising for the government than anything else. Some "challenges": "How Has Social Securit
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
In what way is this a "startup"? It looks more like thinly veiled advertising for the government than anything else.
Some "challenges": "How Has Social Security Made a Difference in Your Life?" "Write about how you've used government information in your life and have your story posted on GovGab"
Ignoring the most blatant propaganda, the rest are just feel-good projects of no consequence. On the front page, the only project that even pretends to be significant is "Connecting Kids To Coverage Challenge". Apparently there are 5 million children who have de facto health insurance, but are counted by the census as "uninsured". Your challenge is to change their census characterization by encouraging their parents to fill out some paperwork.
It's obvious that our enlightened bureaucrats are unwilling to risk losing their jobs if a crowdsourced solution actually works better than they do (witness the backlash against, for instance, charter schools and vouchers). Why should we care that, as a purely propaganda move, the government is crowdsourcing the problem of teaching children how to become president?
- jrallison 16y agoOur startup is ChallengePost.com. Challenge.gov is the second site to use our platform.
- imp 16y agoThat wasn't clear from your title. Thanks for the clarification.
- poet 16y agoTough talk like that will win you cheap points, but you're just wasting peoples' time by taking a rushed and uninformed barf in the comment box. Let's examine your basic claim that: "[excluding the blatant propaganda, the projects] are just feel-good projects of no consequence". Here are some challenges featured on the front page: * An X prize for green cars with a prize pool of $10,000,000. Run by Progressive Insurance and the X Prize Foundation. * An X prize for green aerospace with a prize pool of $16,500,000. Run by NASA and the Comparative Aircraft Flight Efficiency Foundation. It took me about 5 minutes to verify that you just cherry picked from the data to support your preconceived notions. I have absolutely no idea how you could have thought you were adding to the conversation.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI didn't cherrypick, I just didn't search the entire site. I looked at the front page, "economy" and the first page of "education". I'm sorry my post didn't more clearly specify that.
- jbooth 16y agoSo, if we set aside all of the ideology about how if anything involves the word government, then we all need to jump on some kind of bandwagon.. If we set all of that aside, this looks like a decent idea, no? More engagement is what we need in this country. Ask not what your country can do for you and all of that.
- hugh3 16y agoMore engagement of what in what? I'd like to see less engagement of the government in everything. Why is the US Federal Government offering me twelve thousand dollars to come up with recipes? I hate to sound like one of those Ron Paul folks, but when did acting as a middleman for the procurement of recipes become a duty of the US Federal Government?
- jbooth 16y agoIf you hate to sound like one of those Ron Paul folks, don't say things like "I'd like to see less engagement of the government in everything". That doesn't make any sense. You're taking a whole bunch of big complicated problems, shrinking them to a single simplification that you can get your head around, and then prescribing one-size-fits-all solutions. That's never a good recipe. The Federal Government happens to be in a place where they can expend small money for big national gains in a number of places -- energy research in particular is one of those. Federally funded energy research just plain makes sense, especially when you compare it to all of the indirectly-federally-funded oil exploration that happens on a dollar for dollar basis. EDIT: For "what in what", I meant "people" in "solving the problems we have in this country".
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOne problem people have in this country: I'm hungry but too busy at work to cook. Some frenchies, mexicans and indians solved that for me [1]. Another problem: my stuff is in house A, but I want it in house B. Some Ukrainians solved that problem for me. I'm highly engaged in solving the problem of "you want to sell your stocks, but no one wants to buy them right now." While there are an unusually large number of people not doing this right now, it's mainly due to assorted frictions. Some of them don't know what problems need to be solved, or are not very good at solving the problems that currently need to be solved, or just live too far away to help. That's a problem, but it's really not clear how this site helps with it. It seems like a site such as monster.com would be more useful. [1] Temporarily, at least. My local city council is trying to shut them down.