7 ms·
Facebook critic: Company ‘will not survive long term’
- vectorEQ 9y agoit will survive atleast as long as the main user base is still alive... new people perhaps look at alternatives, but they have plenty of cash to become part of a future platform for these people too. long term , a company generally changes and adapts, and these adaptations don't seem to be accounted in these kinds of critiques. anyone who thinks a company as big as this wouldn't take into acount the changing world around them is as stuborn or more as they suggest/assume the target of their critique to be...
- anocendi 9y ago>> but they have plenty of cash to become part of a future platform for these people too And don't forget: Facebook has been buying out every social media platform of any legitimacy (well, except Snap Inc.?) which might rise up to challenge it one day, especially at times like these. With copious cash it has and no legitimate contender in sight, Facebook has a lot of time and opportunity to morph and adapt itself into a future platform. I find this article's assessment kind of near-sighted, and naive.
- cirgue 9y ago> it will survive atleast as long as the main user base is still alive... So did Yahoo.
- overcast 9y agoIt will survive in some form, at the very least the social authentication aspect. It's become a utility for many, MANY other websites around the world.
- sjg007 9y agoI mean it is easy to change your Oauth provider if they both use the same underlying email address.
- dingo_bat 9y agoYou can say that about any company though.
- cvaidya1986 9y agoInstagram and WhatsApp will survive.
- jadeddrag 9y agoAnd Oculus VR.
- fullshark 9y agoAnd Facebook
- taneq 9y agoThat's still around?
- inventingwithmo 9y agoOdd comment as XR is in its infancy
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jerf 9y agoUseless without the critic putting a number on "long term". In the long run, we are all dead. I also predict that Facebook will not be around three billion years from now. Can I have a politico article?
- ohsnapman 9y agoDoes the word "long term" have no meaning, then? I agree it would be better to say "within the few 2 decades" or slap a timeframe on it. But this characterization is silly.
- jerf 9y agoThen what is the meaning, then? I tend to use 50 years as my rough "long term" definition. "Facebook won't be around in 50 years" is not very impressive. "Facebook won't be around in 2020" would be a bold prediction, but doesn't seem very "long term". "Facebook won't be around in 2025" might be starting to get into "long term", but is also definitely starting to feel vacuous if we think of it as "The probability of Facebook being around as a distinct entity in 2025"... well, no duh it's not going to be 100%, but the probabilities get fairly uninteresting quickly. 50/50 is a decent initial guess for that, and it isn't until you get into the 90s on either side that it starts becoming an interesting prediction. I don't know how to turn "Facebook won't be around in the long term" into an interesting prediction without a time horizon. Here's a non-vacuous sort of example: There's a proof somewhere that the maximal probability of the expected future lifetime of a given organization like a country or a company is its current lifespan, projected into the future. So the maximal probability of when Facebook will be gone if it is currently 14 years old is 2032. However, I can not seem to Google up the discussion of this; all the search terms I can come up with are flooded by actuarial discussions of human mortality where this most assuredly is not the case.
- V-2 9y ago> There's a proof somewhere that the maximal probability of the expected future lifetime of a given organization like a country or a company is its current lifespan, projected into the future Sounds more like the good, old https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument than any sort of an actual proof...
- rokhayakebe 9y agoNon Facebook user question: Are we being unfair by only pointing to how FB had a negative impact on the US election? They had a very positive impact on other elections and helped (indirectly) overthrow bad governments.
- kosei 9y agoYes. This is a witch hunt right now.
- m52go 9y agoI think the important take-away here should be that Facebook has tremendous (nondemocratic) power to sway elections. Sometimes that power can be used for good, and sometimes that power can be used for bad. But the fact that it's controlled by a small number of people (who've made it clear that they aren't afraid of using their power to sway political opinion) AND that its very business model means it's always powered by the richest & most strategic advertiser should be alarming to any citizen of any country.
- kosei 9y agoCouldn't you make that same argument about news or TV organizations? Tremendous power to sway elections and public opinion, run by a few who aren't afraid to use that power for their own devices?
- m52go 9y agoFacebook is 1 entity, and even though mass media has consolidated quite a bit, it's still not all controlled by just 1 entity. Also, advertisers in mass media can't algorithmically target consumers with specific ideological messages. Mass media is still largely run by advertisers targeting relatively vague customer profiles with product branding messages. You're right that there's a similarity, but I think the magnitude of Facebook's power is vastly different.
- aylmao 9y ago
- m52go 9y agoNo company survives forever...every company eventually declines, and then either shuts down or gets acquired. It's clear Facebook won't just disappear--its assets (data) are too valuable. Intriguing questions to ask: what happens when Facebook does eventually decline? How much is Facebook's data worth? Who will ultimately acquire it? And perhaps more critically: what will their intentions be? This is why Zuckerberg's opinions / testifying don't really matter. He's created a tool that's more powerful and more dangerous than humans have any business creating. As with any such tool, it will be used to wreak havoc sooner or later...even if he's an innocent, well-meaning guy, he will not always be the one in charge of this power. I think of Facebook's power as similar to that of the atomic bomb. Yes it's a triumph of human ingenuity, and it can be used for good, but there's a catastrophic flip side.
- pwython 9y agoJust for fun, your comment reminded me of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_companies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_companies
- davidkuhta 9y agoFor the curious: Kongō Gumi Co., Ltd. is a Japanese construction company which was the world's oldest continuously ongoing independent company, operating for over 1,400 years until it was absorbed as a subsidiary of Takamatsu in 2006.
- rtx 9y agoToday Facebook is more similar to GoldMan Sachs. Companies like that only die once in a decade.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoIts data lose value unless they're constantly refreshed. If people stop using Facebook, a lot of that value will just fade away.
- thomasjudge 9y ago"In the long run we are all dead." - J.M. Keynes
- tw1010 9y ago"Thing I have publicly shorted will not survive in the long term."
- Bartweiss 9y agoSimilarly: "the public is increasingly focused on this topic", says person authoring scary stories about this topic for a major news source.
- uptown 9y agoAt this stage, regulation seems like it may help Facebook more than it'd hurt. Regulations that restrict the very behaviors that allowed Facebook to grow to its dominance might make it more difficult for startups to ever challenge them in a meaningful way.
- martin-adams 9y agoI agree with this, but the other thing to consider is whether Facebook's revenue is dependent on the things that are being restricted.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoThis now common argument doesn’t hold water. What if regulation restricted one social network per holding corporation? If Facebook was to lose Instagram and WhatsApp it would be a huge blow to the company, while also promoting a competitive business environment where major social networks can’t simply buy the competition out of existence.
- hanklazard 9y agoWhat you’re suggesting sounds more along the lines of antitrust and seems unlikely (though sounds great to me). I think that regulation around data security would be more likely and is what most people are suggesting. Whether this type regulation could be written competently in the US is my concern.
- dwc 9y agoI'm not convinced that meaningful regulation in the areas of concern would make it that hard for up and coming competition. Sure, the free-for-all exploitation would no longer be available, but that's not necessarily a startup killer. However, with giants like Google and Facebook in place there's a huge risk of regulatory capture[1] specifically aimed at inhibiting new competition. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- zombieprocesses 9y agoThat's my thinking as well. Regulations help the incumbent, not the up-and-coming.
- mpg33 9y agoI mean you can say this with any company really..
- danschumann 9y agoI'm not pro facebook, but the fact that so many people are saying bad about facebook means they still care, and that also means facebook knows there is a problem. I think a bigger indicator of death is when a company neglects problems, or lies about them. Facebook has not denied problems, which makes me think they might fix them. I had problems with facebook since 2005ish, and actually creating a rival to facebook was a big motivator for me to learn to code, but now I've since taken up my own interests, and am not so concerned with facebook, since I see it, in some ways, as a necessary evil. (though I would rather see some sort of decentralized blockchain thingy that serves as the global directory of connecting all people) Also, if you are in the valley, you are posh and already "over facebook", you are an early adopter of a facebook-less world, and you don't realize how obsessed with facebook people are in the midwest(where I am). I'm not saying a facebook-less world won't catch on here, but where I am, people aren't anti-facebook at all.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoWhat I don't understand is this, Facebook makes $7 per customer through selling their data to advertisers and other groups. I know most people don't want to PAY for Facebook, but maybe the people who really care about their privacy would. Could I opt out of advertising, or sharing my data with 3rd party apps of my friends if I paid Facebook $20 per year? For me $20 per year would be a good price for an ad free experience on Facebook. That way some people pay with real dollars, some people pay by being receptacles for advertising. Just like how there is Free TV, and there is HBO.
- binthere 9y agoWhat you are missing is that they knew about it all the time but did nothing until a big "scandal" like this happened. It's a problem with trust now.
- vernie 9y agoCritic criticizes
- phonebucket 9y ago"“But Facebook is essentially a 14-year-old design that for all its evolution is still founded on the ideas of 14 years ago. So no, the answer is it will not survive long term.”" author of that quote will likely just increment that 14 each year until they are right?
- stuffedBelly 9y agoI'd say the company might still be there but pivoting of core business will likely happen. Lots of companies survive this way, especially when they cover multiple business fields.