4 ms·
I don't need to believe there was a conspiracy to protect Uber here. This spot apparently has a history of pedestrian crossing, and many police departments have
by jcranmer 9y ago
I don't need to believe there was a conspiracy to protect Uber here. This spot apparently has a history of pedestrian crossing, and many police departments have a habit of assigning all blame to the pedestrian in a pedestrian/vehicle collision. This blame is reinforced by the driver's "evidence" (driver didn't see anything, but she wasn't looking) and the dashcam (can't see anything, but the quality is atrocious and not at all reflective of what most drivers would see).
One thing we should take away from this incident is that we need to seriously push back on immediate "pedestrian's fault" rulings when police make them after a pedestrian/vehicle collision. It was readily apparent within hours that the story didn't add up, but people only paid so much attention because it's the first such crash involving an autonomous vehicle.
The more interesting question is how that shockingly poor dashcam footage came to be. That quality is so poor that I find it hard to believe that Uber is actively using it as a sensor input. Hell, it's worse than most dashcams I've seen on Youtube...
- mannykannot 9y agoI assume the poor dashcam footage came out because it fits the narrative they were all trying to push. I don't think there is any reason to believe it was the input to the driving system, but either way, it does not look good for Uber, and if it is apparently deliberately misleading, or, worse, has been tampered with, then that would take it to a new level. The release of the interior shot might have been an attempt to throw the 'safety' driver under the bus, so to speak, and while her inattentiveness was a very serious matter, it also does not look good for Uber.
- scoggs 9y agoYeah, they did not need to show the footage of her blatantly distracted away from the road. That was my biggest takeaway. I'm not sure who decided what footage got shown publicly but I immediately found that interesting to say the least.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoI thought it looked a bit like they were throwing their human backup driver under the bus as well. Not cool.
- JeremyBanks 9y agoWhy is it not cool? Certainly Uber the company is systemically responsible for this failure, but the driver also had a role in preventing harm, and they were negligent. There's more than enough blame to share.
- cesarb 9y ago> That quality is so poor that I find it hard to believe that Uber is actively using it as a sensor input. It probably isn't used as sensor input. It's probably an off-the-shelf dashcam (the cheapest they could find that could also record the driver) added as an afterthought. It also wouldn't surprise me if the windshield were tinted, which would make the dashcam recording even darker (since it's behind the windshield).
- usefulcat 9y agoI don't know about AZ, but windshield tinting is usually illegal in TX, except (I believe) for certain newer methods of tinting that are designed to filter only IR frequencies. But I think those newer forms are also fairly rare. In any case, I definitely wouldn't assume the windshield was tinted.
- taylorexpander 9y agoYou are severely mistaken. Window tinting is legal in AZ (resident) and a quick search tells me TX as well. Maybe you’re thinking of the black out style tinting that you see in movies but most people tint to filter out like 5-20% light.
- Implicated 9y agoYou're not making the distinction between "window tinting" and "windSHIELD tinting". Big difference. I'm not aware of anywhere that it's legal to tint your windshield below the top 4-5 inches. (Not saying it isn't but it certainly isn't in AZ or TX)
- cesarb 9y ago> I'm not aware of anywhere that it's legal to tint your windshield below the top 4-5 inches. In my country, you can put a tinted film on the whole windshield, as long as it allows at least 75% of the light to pass (the side and rear windows can be much darker: the film must allow at least 28% of the light). They're a common sight.