3 ms·
> Self-driving cars have to be at least as safe as human-driven ones for them to ever become accepted and thus widespread. Do they? There are other technologie
by lostlogin 9y ago
> Self-driving cars have to be at least as safe as human-driven ones for them to ever become accepted and thus widespread.
Do they? There are other technologies that started out less safe but were accepted and became safer after acceptance, further boosting their popularity. Planes and cars would be examples and mills in the industrial revolution, but there are undoubtably others.
- stctgion 9y agoBoth of those examples occurred at a time when human life held less value
- lostlogin 9y agoGood point. I’m struggling to think of a recent example but maybe smart phones? How you would find stats on deaths due to smart phones though? Obviously lives have been saved with them too, but the number lost due to distraction must be considerable.
- gambiting 9y agoMachines cannot have an operating mode where they can kill someone, even if in the grand scheme of things they are saving lives. Prime example: Therac radiotheraphy machines - it's without a doubt that these machines have saved countless lives, but they had a weird error state where instead of treating the patient, they would kill them instead. At that point we didn't go "oh well, a human operated radiotherapy machine would have killed more people because humans are inherently worse at this stuff" - we banned all of them until the problem could be found, rectified, the solution tested and implemented. It also contributed to much stronger industry testing standards for medical devices. I'd say an automonous car which can completely fail to react to a person in its path is firmly in the "therac-level of failure" category - even if on average they crash much less than humans do. They should all be taken off road and only allowed once we determine through rigorous industrial-level proof testing that it can't happen again.
- lostlogin 9y ago> Machnes cannot have an operating mode where they can kill someone. I agree that they shouldn’t, but they certain do. Strangely we seem fairly ok with devices that kill us when we use them wrong (eg cars, power tools, weapons) but we are outraged when devices that make decisions for themselves kills us. For the victim it’s little different, but somehow it is.
- majewsky 9y agoI believe the difference is that the decision is taken by someone who has a conscious mental model of how he's going to be punished for killing someone.
- lostlogin 9y agoI think it more that if someone is killed by something they control it is seen as more acceptable than them being killed by something they don’t have any control over. For example someone dying in a car crash on the way to work is not front page news. However if someone dies on the way to work when the train crashes, it is.
- majewsky 9y agoCar crashes vs. train crashes is because of frequency: Trains crash seldomly enough for it to be newsworthy. When more cars are autonomous, we may also see news about fatal incidents fade into the background noise.
- lostlogin 9y agoIf that alone explains it, then the situation is even stranger. We are alarmed at an infrequent event but accept as normal that lots of people die because of cars. Not seeing the wood for the trees.
- kolinko 9y agoSo, you're saying that unless we can achieve zero failure rate of automated cars, we should stick with 3000 fatalities caused by humans every day? You also believe that it's possible to do lab tests so good that real-world testing will not be necessary. Finally, you believe that the radiotherapy machines are 100% safe right now, and will never have a life-threatening problem again. Right?