4 ms·
I see this argument all the time, but these things are less dangerous than smartphones. First off, they ride off your own network so it is easy to see when the
by slg 9y ago
I see this argument all the time, but these things are less dangerous than smartphones. First off, they ride off your own network so it is easy to see when they are sending data back home unlike phones which can transfer data over harder to monitor 3rd party networks. They are cheaper and lower powered machines so they can't do a lot of processing on device and can't store a large amount of data for later transfer. They are stationary in your home and therefore likely spend a majority of the time listening to nothing unlike phones which might be at their owners side 24/7. They also only have one source of data which is audio as opposed to the other various sensors phones have like GPS. Finally, if you believe that these companies are shady enough that they are lying to their customers about what these smart speakers are doing, why do you think they aren't lying about what their mobile OSes or apps are doing?
All that said, I believe Apple, Amazon, and Google all have worlds more trust in this area than Facebook.
- lev99 9y agoI would suspect that small cpu inside them is better at real time voice processing than you think.
- musage 9y ago> these things are less dangerous than smartphones They're also orthogonal to smartphones. > why do you think they aren't lying about what their mobile OSes or apps are doing? Why do you think everybody thinks that? And why frame it that way from the get go, to what the companies themselves are doing today, and/or to what the widgets do in isolation? It's another vector of attack for all sorts of actors, present and future, including the companies themselves. > All that said, I believe Apple, Amazon, and Google all have worlds more trust in this area than Facebook. They're not the baseline, the baseline is none of these devices. And for me, those all have worlds less trust than entities I trust, and the difference between them and Facebook is pretty much irrelevant in the big picture.
- SlowRobotAhead 9y agoThank you, sometimes I feel like I’m nuts for seeing all these people run to install always on mics in their house. I don’t like the 1 second of buffer the iPhone has for Siri with Hey Siri disabled - but LOL if I’m going to install a single purpose always listening microphone for gimmick reasons.
- saagarjha 9y ago> these things are less dangerous than smartphones I disagree. > they ride off your own network so it is easy to see when they are sending data back home unlike phones which can transfer data over harder to monitor 3rd party networks …if you use a VPN, then you can check for traffic here as well. > They are cheaper and lower powered machines so they can't do a lot of processing on device and can't store a large amount of data for later transfer. HomePod has an Apple A8 processor, and Google Home has some sort of ARM SoC. These aren't low-powered machines; on the contrary, they can run 24/7 since they're always powered. > They are stationary in your home and therefore likely spend a majority of the time listening to nothing I think this makes them more likely to be overlooked, more than anything. > Finally, if you believe that these companies are shady enough that they are lying to their customers about what these smart speakers are doing, why do you think they aren't lying about what their mobile OSes or apps are doing Some of them, maybe.
- slg 9y ago>…if you use a VPN, then you can check for traffic here as well. This is conditional on the assumption that the device is doing what it tells you it is doing. Like the point in my previous comment, if you believe the device is lying to you about when it is recording, why do you trust that it isn't hiding non-VPNed connections from you? Smart speakers can not physically transfer data themselves and can only forward data over WiFi or Bluetooth. >HomePod has an Apple A8 processor, and Google Home has some sort of ARM SoC. These aren't low-powered machines; on the contrary, they can run 24/7 since they're always powered. The A8 is a 4 year old processor and the HomePod is by far the most expensive and powerful of these devices. Maybe I was downplaying their potential processing power too much, but the fact still stands that a modern smartphone is much more powerful than a modern smart speaker. >I think this makes them more likely to be overlooked, more than anything. And phones aren't overlooked when they spend almost 24/7 within a few feet of the owner? I am not saying these devices don't present any potential issues. I am just pointing out that the risk is lower than the one we have already accepted by using smartphones. Stressing over compromised smart speakers is like stressing about whether you locked the door to the third floor balcony while not caring that the front door is unlocked.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cornholio 9y agoThe fundamental difference is that a smartphone will record and send the data remotely only when you have applications or malware to that effect. So you still have nominal control. Smart speakers are sending the audio to the mothership by design, it's the way they work in normal operation.
- Retric 9y agoSmartphone radios use quite a bit of energy. So, they can't be used to record 24/7 without the drain becoming really obvious. These things send back full audio to be processed by design. So, it's not a question of possible it's up to the provider what they want to do with the recordings the device is directly sending.