4 ms·
Why would spinning the wheel backwards cancel out the gyroscopic effect? The gyroscopic effect makes it hard to tilt the wheel left or right (from the perspect
by jrockway 16y ago
Why would spinning the wheel backwards cancel out the gyroscopic effect? The gyroscopic effect makes it hard to tilt the wheel left or right (from the perspective of the rider). Spinning the wheel backwards makes it hard to turn the wheel right or left, which has the same stabilizing effect.
I get that there is some effect other than the gyroscopic action of the wheel (how else could you track-stand, after all), but I don't feel like this device proves or disproves anything.
Also, the "begs the question" and the footnote explaining why it's OK to misue that expression was annoying. (If you have to write a paragraph about why you want to use incorrect English, wouldn't it be easier to just edit the misused construction. "This leads us to ask, ..." Write that, and you save yourself a footnote, and people will think you're not bad at writing. </rant>.)
- wnoise 16y agoThe gyroscopic effect does not _directly_ make it harder to turn, it causes a reaction force (torque, really) at right angles to the applied force. With two counter-rotating wheels, these reaction forces work against each other.
- hristov 16y agoNo they don't. Any spinning wheel will create a force that tries to preserve its axis of rotation. If you have two counter-spinning wheels that share the same axis and try to tilt them, they will both try to preserve the same axis of rotation and thus exert a force in the same direction.
- wnoise 16y agoHave you done the experiment? "Syd12107" has claimed to in this thread: http://www.physicsforums.com/archive/index.php/t-173215.html http://www.physicsforums.com/archive/index.php/t-173215.html The result was that counter rotating gyroscopes had no net effect. The only thing that matters is total angular momentum. The resistance to being tilted is a _secondary_ effect. The push gets translated into motion at right angles to the push, and this motion gets translated into push at one more right-angle, exactly countering the original push. For two counter-rotating gyroscopes, this first-stage motion of one is exactly countered by the other, leading to no net effect. Really, truly.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoThat exactly matches my experience and calculations.
- hristov 16y agoYou are exactly right. This article suffers the common misconception that two wheels spinning in opposite directions and same speed cancel out the gyroscopic stability. And this is simply not true. In fact two wheels spinning in opposite directions and same speeds will actually double the gyroscopic stability (as opposed to one wheel of the same speed). However, two wheels spinning in opposite directions may cancel out other spinning wheel effects.
- jules 16y agoWhich other spinning wheel effects?
- yread 16y agoPrecession
- jules 16y agoPrecession is caused by the gyroscopic effect.
- lincolnq 16y agoWait, so if you have two identical wheels on one axis, spinning in opposite directions, and you rotate the axis, are you saying you'll experience precession or you won't? My intuition (and physics understanding) says you won't. But the top-level post is saying you will still experience "gyroscopic stability". Is that true?
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoYou're right, your understand is right, you won't experience "gyroscopic stability." I've done it. You don't. I believe that people who believe otherwise are working on misunderstandings of perceptions. It's nototiously easy to confuse several effects in this. Careful experiments are required with tight controls on error bars, etc. It's easy to be fooled. Eric Laithwaite is a classic and high profile example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Laithwaite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Laithwaite
- jules 16y agoThe torque is tau = I*domega/dt When we have two wheels spinning in opposite directions the torque is tau = I*domega/dt + I*d(-omega)/dt = 0 The gyroscopic effect doesn't actually make it harder to turn a wheel. It's just that if you turn it in the xy-plane, it automatically turns in the direction perpendicular to the push (the yz-plane). When a human is physically turning a wheel he will try to stop that from happening, thus the feeling that it's hard to turn the wheel. Note that in particular the gyroscopic effect does not produce any force in the direction opposite to the pushing force. You have a wheel spinning one way, and say that if you try to turn it clockwise in the xy-plane then it will turn clockwise in the yz-plane because of the gyroscopic effect. If you have a wheel spinning the opposite way, and if you turn it clockwise in the xy-plane then it will turn counterclockwise in the yz-plane because of the gyroscopic effect. Adding the two effects cancels them.
- jlees 16y agoHe's Australian, they misuse English wilfully all the time. ;)