2 ms·
Amen. The greatest success I've had is using a hybrid approach of agile and waterfall. But, let's face it, Agile is anything but agile when it comes to the pro
by jasona 16y ago
Amen.
The greatest success I've had is using a hybrid approach of agile and waterfall. But, let's face it, Agile is anything but agile when it comes to the process. The Agilists out there will be the first to beat you over the head when you don't follow the process by the book.
- btilly 16y agoAgile is anything but agile when it comes to the process. The Agilists out there will be the first to beat you over the head when you don't follow the process by the book. There is a delicious irony here. The first bullet point of the Agile Manifesto is that individuals and interactions matter more than processes and tools. (See http://agilemanifesto.org/ http://agilemanifesto.org/ if don't know what I'm talking about.) The heart of the Agile movement at the start was that no one process fit all situations. So they tried to come up with whole families of methodologies exactly so that teams could choose the one that best fit their situation. Some of those methodologies proved popular. (eg Scrum.) Some people made a living out of pushing those. And voila! The message became, "Here is a magic methodology that is right for all situations, which we'll be glad to teach you about in our next expensive seminar!" And so it happens. It seems that all revolutions are destined to become what they were revolting against.
- chromatic 16y ago* The message became, "Here is a magic methodology that is right for all situations, which we'll be glad to teach you about in our next expensive seminar!" * Would you hire someone to manage your software development process who's only qualification is sitting through an expensive three-day seminar? Would you trust an organization which does so? If not, why the surprise that such projects struggle?
- btilly 16y agoThere is no surprise. But many people's only exposure to agile is this, and the result is that people wind up with an unfairly bad impression of what agile means. That said, I've used a variety of agile methods for years, but I'm quite sure in ways that would make many of the presenters of those seminars object very strongly to my calling it agile.
- ams6110 16y agoMeet the new boss, same as the old boss
- mattm 16y agoSoftware development can never truly be waterfall or agile. The best development always lies somewhere in between. If the process were only waterfall, the project would never even be started because all the specs would take forever to write out. If the process were only agile, there would be chaos because there is no long-term thinking involved.