5 ms·
The longstanding root of the problem is that we're relying on software that is under the control of an adversarial party, especially for creating a UI. This nec
by mindslight 9y ago
The longstanding root of the problem is that we're relying on software that is under the control of an adversarial party, especially for creating a UI. This necessarily means that incentives are misaligned, and we are left as an unaccompanied homo sapien to be outwitted by the machine in front of us that we may have paid for, but that does not work for us.
It will be interesting to see where the GDPR goes, especially with regards to surveillance companies we don't directly interact with. But as long as we continue to do things like utilize a specific retailer's software for researching and planning purchases, the incentives are for that retailer to design that software to push us into funneling as much business (and extraneous personal data!) as possible to themselves.
- kobrad 9y agoTo make things worse UI is still a largely unsolved matter. Imagine being in the time of tillers instead of steering wheels but somehow splice in privacy and personal data. The more I read about this the more everything feels like a bad scifi novel.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWhat do you mean by "UI is still a largely unsolved matter"? The way I see it, UI was solved somewhen in the 70s. Since then, we're only redoing the same building blocks with more or less glitter, and composing them in the same usual ways. The problem is, really, that user-hostile interfaces are designed on purpose, to trick users.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xg15 9y ago> The longstanding root of the problem is that we're relying on software that is under the control of an adversarial party, especially for creating a UI. One of the original ideas of the "semantic web" was that the entities that provide data and the entities that display the data should be decoupled and freely combinable by the user. That idea didn't gain particularly large support with website developers. I wonder why... /s
- always_good 9y agoBecause there isn't much incentive to do something that makes it easier to not get paid for your content? It already rubs me the wrong way when Google scrapes content from sites. I'm not surprised the dream failed if that's what it was.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> the entities that provide data and the entities that display the data should be decoupled and freely combinable by the user Honest question: does Google AMP [1] fit this mold? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerated_Mobile_Pages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerated_Mobile_Pages
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoIsn't that still tightly coupled from the publisher to Google?