5 ms·
You are right. There have been studies that news coverage of these school shootings leads to copycat attacks. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
You are right.
There have been studies that news coverage of these school shootings leads to copycat attacks. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-big-idea/2018/2/22/17041382/school-shooting-media-coverage-perpetrator-parkland https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.vox.com/platform/amp/the-bi...
Why doesn't Congress pass a law limiting how school shootings can be covered by news media? It might save student lives.
There is an amendment that prevents that you say? Well the first amendment talks about freedom of the press. The founders could not have imagined online news, tv and cable news or social media. Maybe we only allow stories published on actual printing presses, and ban coverage on online, tv, and social media of school shootings.
Also, even with presses, the printing presses of the 18th century were not like our automated presses of today that can print hundreds or thousands of pages per minute, no those presses were single shot presses where you had to reload after each page. Maybe they were only talking about those kind of presses when they named freedom of the press.
- robotrout 9y agoThe feeding frenzy the corporate media indulges itself in, whenever an event like this occurs is regrettable. It's a prisoners dilemma, since any corporate media outlet that does not ramp up to "National Enquirer" level hysteria, will be overshadowed by those who do. To solve such a prisoners dilemma would seem to require regulation, so that those who want to be good actors are not punished by losing viewership to bad actors. Japan's (lack of) coverage of suicides to prevent copycat behavior can serve as a model.
- unsayable 9y agoThe first amendment wasn't written with social media in mind, just like the second amendment wasn't written with semi-automatic rifles in mind. The US needs to enact common sense speech control to stop these tragedies from propagating. Secondary thought: maybe if we restrict online speech to those over 21, we could stop a lot of bullying that leads to these problems in the first place, and as an extra benefit this kind of ban could stop children from posting things online that will negatively impact them later in life.
- robotrout 9y ago> maybe if we restrict online speech to those over 21 Even as an old guy, I hate that solution. Something about "Those who give up liberty for security deserve neither", except it's not the kids giving up their liberty, it's you taking it from them. I also can't imagine how you could stop it. There's lots of people under 21 that can code.
- unsayable 9y agoPerhaps if you had to pass a background check, then you could be allowed to engage in approved speech? In 2018, speech can cause just as much damage as a car, and we all agree you need a license to operate a car. A license could probably help with the "fake news" epidemic too. Sure, it's hard to totally stop people from using speech irresponsibly and hurting others, but if we aggressively prosecute unlawful speech, we could probably reduce the amount of harm done by people speaking their minds.
- robotrout 9y ago> aggressively prosecute unlawful speech What country are you from? I hope you are not from USA. No matter where you are from, I have to tell you that you are on a path that will lead to the slaughter of millions, if you achieve your goals. I am sorry your history teachers hid from you, the examples of when and how this occurred in the recent past. I can only tell you that you and your age cohort have been ill served by the school system and I hope to protect my family from the consequences of that failure, somehow.
- unsayable 9y agoYes, I'm from USA. And to be honest, I'm just trying out some new ideas here. I half-expected to be skewered here for proposing speech controls similar to gun controls, but it's actually becoming a mainstream view. The recent gun control marches have really opened up my eyes to this. I used to be a proponent of free speech, gun rights, drug legalization, and all the other internet libertarian ideas about freedom. I realize now that the culture is changing rapidly around me and that those old ideas about freedom put you on a path toward isolation, public scorn, and possibly criminality. You may need to reconsider your ideas about freedom before you get shunned in a way that hurts your family. Watch the gun control movement, the people trying to solve "fake news" with regulation, and other social movements. They're having great success at trading in freedom for security, and it seems inevitable that the same types of controls will be applied to speech. It's probably better to adapt early to the new normal and be on the "progressive" side than it is to side with hate mongers, gun activists, and drug addicts to promote freedom. You might think you can protect your family from societal change with critical thinking and appeals to classical liberal ideas, but I believe those ideas are the most likely to get you ostracized in our current environment. I think your best bet for protecting your family now is to conform early and often. We're going to sacrifice freedom for perceived security anyway, so you might as well get on the correct side of it before you become an outcast. Your comment about what "history teachers hid" from a generation and your need to "protect my family" place you somewhere near "alt-right" in the current landscape. You have to ask yourself if that's really where you want to be.
- pjc50 9y agoI know this is a parody, but my belief is that speech is actually more relevant than guns per se; after all, as people repeatedly point out, the US is not the only country with guns. Most of the mass shooters are "self-radicalised". > Also, even with presses, the printing presses of the 18th century were not like our automated presses of today that can print hundreds or thousands of pages per minute This is essentially what the "fake news" argument is about: if you publish enough hate speech, you can cause a massacre even without guns. A Rwandan radio station was a major contributor to the massacre of around a million people, and the genocide was largely carried out by hand with machetes and arson.
- sincerely 9y agoI know you're trying to prove a point but news outlets have actually changed their reporting and stopped publishing details of suicides because of the copycat effect.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoBut they don't do that for school shootings. Media companies are selling student lives in exchange for advertising money. Think of the innocent children that have been killed by copycat killers, just so media companies could make a few more dollars in advertising!