3 ms·
That sort of rank partisanship can barely be hidden. It's discrediting. FB is clearly in the worse here, even if they were entirely within their rights while
by cryptonector 9y ago
That sort of rank partisanship can barely be hidden. It's discrediting. FB is clearly in the worse here, even if they were entirely within their rights while Cambridge Analytica was entirely not. What's legal is not always what's right.
- InTheArena 9y agothis. It's becoming clear exactly what the cost of social surveillance is in our lives. This is just one of many significant problems with it. There have always been jackasses willing to sacrifice morals (or rightness) in favor of power. Social networks just make it easier to ignore signals that should humanize power.
- mistermann 9y agoWhat's even more interesting to me is that /u/WalterGR is so biased that on this topic, unless he's lying, his brain literally cannot differentiate between identical and similar, and he is far from the only person behaving like this. Since we're on HN, odds are he's otherwise a fairly smart person. This isn't just a typical argument about a matter of opinion - identical and similar are two distinctly different words, but he will be simply unable to see the relevance of that to what he has written above. I've been on the internet a long time, and there have been flame wars and various disagreements since forever, but there is something very, very different happening with people's minds now. EDIT: Once again, immediate downvotes with no rebuttal. Shocking. And while this is frustrating, and a bit scary for the future that critical thinking is almost nowhere to be found, the childish partisanship combined with self-important delusions is an interesting insight into the psyche of young university educated Westerners. > Neither of those citations say that what the Obama campaign did violated Facebook's policies. > The "But the Obama campaign did something similar!" is an argument based on false equivalence, used to muddy the conversation. e·quiv·a·lence iˈkwivələns/ noun noun: equivalence; plural noun: equivalences the condition of being equal or equivalent in value, worth, function, etc. sim·i·lar ˈsim(ə)lər/ adjective adjective: similar 1. resembling without being identical. "a soft cheese similar to Brie" synonyms: alike, (much) the same, indistinguishable, almost identical, homogeneous, homologous; More
- sctb 9y ago> ...his brain literally cannot differentiate between identical and similar... You're way out of civil and substantive territory with things like this. Please resist the temptation. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mistermann 9y agoI sincerely believe this is something new and interesting. Suggesting someone has acted based on a subconscious psychological affect is less insulting than accusing someone of conscious or deliberate error (which happens routinely on HN), is it not? Which has the harsher punishment, second degree murder or first? Serious question. Would you deny that there has been a noticeable decline in objectivity of commentary in the last year? I can agree singling one person out could be considered harsh, but make an honest effort to ignore the perceived "rudeness", is the failure of basic logic not a little striking here? If the topic wasn't controversial, do you think a similar situation would arise? I take what you say seriously, and kindly ask for the same consideration in return.
- sctb 9y agoI'm sorry, but I don't follow all of that. The main issue with the original comment is simple: it is not within the guidelines on Hacker News to say that another user's brain is malfunctioning, or other things of that sort. > Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mistermann 9y agoThe point is, it's a double standard. The guideline you quote used to be broadly followed, but is now broken regularly. And his brain isn't malfunctioning, it's just behaving the way the human brain works, the vast majority of people on HN are quite broadly knowledgeable, I highly doubt you're that ignorant of human psychology, more likely you don't care for my opinion. Besides, read my edit above - whether it was accidental or deliberate, the person was being incredibly intellectually dishonest. It wasn't too long ago that that counted for something on this website. I suppose it still does, but what's new is that it is trumped by political correctness. If you're going to bother with a reply, how about you address my "intellectually dishonest" charge? Demonstrate how I am incorrect.