5 ms·
This begs the follow up question: Why can’t my browser always send zero cookies for all third party requests in all tabs? Presumably the like button wouldn’t w
by alkonaut 9y ago
This begs the follow up question: Why can’t my browser always send zero cookies for all third party requests in all tabs?
Presumably the like button wouldn’t work - but that’s what I want. So the Q is: what will break that I didn’t want to break?
- cachvico 9y agoSingle sign-on? (e.g. logging in to Trello with your Google account)
- romanovcode 9y agoIf you get tokens by callback urls you don't need any 3rd party cookies.
- cachvico 9y agoThat's not relevant to the question.
- bugmen0t 9y agoIt breaks federation, i.e., Single SignOn. But there's a thing for Firefox which does it for all sites. Called First Party Isolation.
- DesiLurker 9y agoknowing what fb is doing with your data, why would you still want SSO?
- billysielu 9y agoAn idea.. imagine putting SSO stuff into a Container and setting First Party Isolation off for just that Container.
- throwaway2048 9y agoive had it disabled for years and never had any kind of issue with single signon websites
- cryptonector 9y agoIt breaks things like "sign-in with github credentials" in CIs. But you know, these should be exceptional, therefore the default should be to load third-party content without cookies. The problem is that some content is loaded without your having to click on something (where you'd have a chance to right-click and request loading with selected credentials).
- andor 9y agoNot necessarily: OAuth Basic Flow does not require third-party cookies. With Basic Flow, you'd get redirected to github.com, making it a first party request. Github will then redirect you back passing an authentication code as a URL parameter.
- moosingin3space 9y agoI use uMatrix for this purpose, and to block third-party frames to defend against clickjacking. That said, Multi-Account Containers still are very useful.
- latexr 9y agoI’ve been blocking third-party cookies for years and using OAuth authentication in several places. Don’t remember ever having an issue.
- theothertom 9y agoThe main thing I notice break when I enable things like "no cross origin cookies" is history on the AWS console. Stuff like "roles you've switched to" and "services you've used recently" get forgotten.
- pritambaral 9y agoYou can disable third-party cookies in Firefox. See https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/disable-third-party-cookies https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/disable-third-party-coo...
- bzbarsky 9y agoThe site of one of the banks I use relies on third-party cookies, because it outsources parts of the site functionality. Sites that put a checkout flow hosted on a different hostname in a subframe break. Some forms of "sign in with X" break.
- latexr 9y ago> Why can’t my browser always send zero cookies for all third party requests in all tabs? It can. Blocking third-party cookies is available in the browser settings of at least Firefox, Chrome, and Safari. I think it’s even on by default in the latter. I’ve been using it for years and never seen a broken page as a result.