6 ms·
I don't get it. You call this a character assassination, but don't elaborate on which part of the article is demonstrably false. The fact that Adtech companies
by AlexandrB 9y ago
I don't get it. You call this a character assassination, but don't elaborate on which part of the article is demonstrably false. The fact that Adtech companies such as Facebook do almost no vetting of the ad content they distribute is absolutely true and part of the problem with the ad economy.
Facebook has accrued great power, but when faced with taking responsibility for any of that power has simply shrugged its shoulders. The same goes for Google.
- mistermann 9y agoIt's not that the article is false, it's the timing. Facebook has been doing this for years, as people in the tech universe are well aware, why the sudden flood of varied content in the mainstream media? Of course, a lot of these articles are going to be good old fashioned self-serving opportunism, but another possibility might be behind the scenes coordination. Impossible? Has there ever been a coordinated propaganda initiative in the history of the world?
- Angostura 9y agoTrust me, the journalists on Bloomberg aren't running this story because they think Facebook threaten's Bloomberg's business. They are running it because they think it is a juicy story.
- mistermann 9y ago> because they think Facebook threaten's Bloomberg's business A coordinated propaganda campaign rarely has anything to do with the underlying business of the various media outlets being used to run it.
- Angostura 9y agoSo, how does this well-orchestrated conspiracy get its message to journalists that "you should investigate this" without the investigative reporters spotting that there is a well-orchestrated conspiracy?
- fortythirteen 9y agoNone of this is false, but none of this is new information, either. Watchdogs have been saying all of this for years.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoBut because you/I/we know does not mean that everyone knows. For a lot of people what is being lres3nted is not clear even though some have heard something about it previously. This is something media channels pick up on and push the stories when there is interest.
- netsharc 9y agoSo... it's not a problem? This feels like responding "Of course Harvey Weinstein's been creepy to young women, people has been saying he's creepy for years."...
- throwaway2048 9y agoLoving this rhetorical flipover on HN from "nobody cares about ad companies being scumbags" to "its old everyone already knows about it, why is it such a big issue now"
- projektir 9y agoI question the benefit of the "none of this is new" response. I don't really see what it ever adds to any conversation.
- ThomPete 9y agoThe question is not whether it's false. The question is what is the purpose of making this a problem for facebook but not for your TV channels or for Twitter etc. Don't underestimate how well this works for the traditional media. It both help undermine one of their biggest competitors and it creates traffic by keep sensationalizing what is really completely normal practice and have been for as long as there have been advertising. Shady advertisers, pollute... those aren't the media reporting thats the media shaming what they themselves do all the time.
- manjushri 9y agoSeems like you're arguing whataboutism. Yes, the old media are being hypocrites and are seemingly dragging their big rivals down with them. For the standpoint of the average person with no financial investments in these companies, why is this so problematic?
- dfxm12 9y agoThe same goes for Google. It has nothing to do with the validity of the article. This is a "character assassination" because of singling Facebook out. I understand putting Facebook in the headline will get you clicks right now, but why not paint a more full picture?
- soziawa 9y agoI don't think the same goes for Google is true. While both show you ads Google puts them in the context of websites in the internet which is not a priori trustworthy. Facebook on the other hand puts them into the context of people you follow and trust, this makes the ads themselves seem more trustworthy.
- anonymouz 9y agoGoogle banned the product that this article is about; Facebook cozied up to them. So far only for Facebook evidence has surfaced of these very shady practices. See the difference? > Google banned Voluum over cloaking concerns, but that didn’t derail the company—Facebook was where the action was. vs. > It’s not just affiliates who think Gryn is at the pinnacle of the industry. In June, just before the conference, Facebook’s newly installed executive in charge of fighting shady ads, Rob Leathern, had invited him to the company’s London office to explain the latest affiliate tricks.
- Fnoord 9y agoBecause Facebook is both relevant news, and a huge company who's core business is our data in exchange for a service.