9 ms·
A new Dashboard dock helps with monitoring GIMP’s resource usage to keep things in check, allowing you to make more educated decisions about various configurati
by userbinator 9y ago
A new Dashboard dock helps with monitoring GIMP’s resource usage to keep things in check, allowing you to make more educated decisions about various configuration options.
That looks so ridiculous and out-of-place in an image editing program. If it weren't for the left side, you'd think it was Visual Studio!
https://msdnshared.blob.core.windows.net/media/MSDNBlogsFS/prod.evol.blogs.msdn.com/CommunityServer.Blogs.Components.WeblogFiles/00/00/00/45/92/metablogapi/6204.635659102497602738_059EE082.png https://msdnshared.blob.core.windows.net/media/MSDNBlogsFS/p...
- TheCoreh 9y agoThat might not be useful for most users, but could be useful for people in resource-constrained environments. I have a friend with a 2010 MacBook Pro, who is constantly monitoring resource usage as he edits photos etc, and has to close apps, delete files to make space for more Photoshop swap, otherwise the computer just dies.
- nkkollaw 9y agoYou did and will keep getting downvoted (like my comment below about GIMP's usability will), but you're absolutely right. This is another case where developers decide what's cool, and of course pick features that are cool to them, not their users. Not once in my life would I ever think I'm missing that feature in GIMP.
- avian 9y agoDid you stop to think that perhaps GIMP's developers are in fact its users? I'm an engineer and I draw as a hobby. I don't mind developer-oriented features in my drawing program. If I wanted Photoshop, I would be using that.
- Karunamon 9y agoThat’s all well and good, but if GIMP is targeting devs first who are also artists, Linux remains an OS without an image editor targeted at artists first. IMO that’s an important hole in the software library that prevents wider adoption.
- callahad 9y agoKrita (https://krita.org https://krita.org) is 12 years old, and just released version 4.0 last week. HN comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16647445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16647445
- gilrain 9y agoAnd if you complain that Krita lacks photo manipulation features, you're told "Of course, because Krita is only targeted at illustrators!" The open source evangelists always have a dodge.
- zzzcpan 9y agoInkscape, mypaint and gimp is pretty much all there is to use professionally on linux. And they complement each other surprisingly well. Inkscape is the main workhorse, mypaint is for sketches and gimp is to prepare some photos and raster images to import into inkscape (you can't do a lot in gimp).
- slantyyz 9y agoIt's been a while since I've used Inkscape to import .ai files, but does Inkscape still have a tendency to mangle them when you try to import them? If you're moving from one platform to another, you want legacy files to import perfectly, especially when you don't have time to convert old Illustrator assets into svg files. On Mac/Windows at least, Affinity Designer was the first app around $50 or under that didn't mangle any of the .ai files I threw at it.
- zzzcpan 9y agoYes, you still need to convert to svg for the best result. These things will always be fragile.
- lovelearning 9y agoWhat's with the entitlement here? These are people sacrificing their time and going largely unpaid (AFAIK) for their efforts. I for one am happy and grateful that these "dodgy" open source evangelists exist and offer us all a choice for free. If I have a subjective usability problem with their software, far more constructive to take the effort to try and fix it myself than complain like a diva.
- bitwize 9y agoYou may not mind developer-oriented features, but the vast, vast majority of artists do. This is why Photoshop wins. Adobe has customers, and Photoshop's devs have to either listen to the customers, or be fired.
- seba_dos1 9y agoWhich is exactly why a feature like the one we're discussing has been included in Photoshop for ages, along with stuff like custom swap space management for image buffers? :P
- paulie_a 9y agoLast time I checked, Photoshop and most of adobe's products barely function on a 4k device, yet Gimp works nicely. It's astounding that a company that makes graphics software can't support modern hardware at all. But I guess they are the company that can't fix the tremendous piece of shit known as flash
- bkor 9y ago> Last time I checked, Photoshop and most of adobe's products barely function on a 4k device, yet Gimp works nicely. That's a surprise and nice to hear! I thought the support wasn't too great and it requires GTK+3.x or newer. It still uses GTK+2.x (see https://wiki.gimp.org/wiki/Roadmap https://wiki.gimp.org/wiki/Roadmap).
- seba_dos1 9y agoThere are some shortcomings on the UI side (you need to take care of DPI setting for starters, and you also need to configure some details separately to have usable button sizes for instance), but I'm using it on GNU/Linux with 3200x1800 13" screen and works just fine.
- nkkollaw 9y ago> Did you stop to think that perhaps GIMP's developers are in fact its users? GIMP's users aren't the handful of developers who develop GIMP. GIMP's users would be people that switch to Linux and are looking for an alternative to Photoshop. GIMP is for some reason referred to them as the go-to for image manipulation on Linux so they try it, and when they can't use it they either install Photoshop via Wine or go back to Windows. I don't know why people recommend GIMP instead of Pinta or more usable software, honestly.
- prokoudine 9y ago> I don't know why people recommend GIMP instead of Pinta or more usable software, honestly. Try adding a text line, then editing it. See if you still want to recommend Pinta. I absolutely love the idea of having a simple image editor for users who don't need most GIMP features. Pinta devs got quite a few things right, but it needs SO much more work...
- detaro 9y agoWith that logic, you can argue against any debugging facility in software. Log files? Only developers think those are cool, useless! FWIW, I have missed better tools for performance tweaking in competing (Adobe) products, so while I don't know if the one in GIMP would be useful, I can see why one would want something like it even as an end user.
- nkkollaw 9y ago> With that logic, you can argue against any debugging facility in software. Log files? Only developers think those are cool, useless! Log files aren't user-facing. A performance meter in an image editing program is completely useless to 99% of its users.
- detaro 9y agoSo performance tools are fine, as long as they are hard to find (=not user-facing)? And the percentage of users that would want them has to live with worse access to them to not scare the others with an extra menu entry?
- nkkollaw 9y agoYes. The more commonly used features are, the more prominent they should be in the UI. If not, the "Compose" or "Send" button in email clients should be as big as "view connection details" (to give you an example). That's how you reduce clutter. GIMP does that horribly, so they should probably _remove_ something, not add.
- prokoudine 9y agoThe Dashboard dock is user-facing only if the user chooses is to be user-facing. Come on, get a grip on yourself.
- prokoudine 9y agoThe feature was developed to help identifying bottlenecks in how GIMP uses cache. It was added to make GIMP faster. Do you want GIMP to be slower?
- nkkollaw 9y agoKind of a contorted way of seeing this, but I'll go for it. So, as a user I have to identify bottlenecks, now..? That would be my first question. Since you're implying that by not thinking the performance indicator is an important feature for the average user I want GIMP to be slower, yes--actually I would definitely opt for a slower, usable program than a fast unusable one, and I never thought speed was a problem of GIMP. Right now I'm running Wine to be able to edit this PSD file without going crazy trying to use GIMP's interface, so obviously speed is not what I care about. I'm sure I'm not the only one, since other problems and not speed seem to be stopping people from using GIMP as their image editor.
- prokoudine 9y ago> So, as a user I have to identify bottlenecks, now..? That would be my first question. Please do pay attention. The release notes specifically describe who did that and for what purpose, and what's in it for end-users. It's all there for you to read. Just please pay attention. > and I never thought speed was a problem of GIMP Which suggests that you never used such a basic feature as Gaussian blur in both Photoshop and GIMP. GIMP _is_ slower than it should be. It actually _is_ a problem for people with modern DSLRs. We want to fix that problem.
- zzzcpan 9y agoExactly. As someone who did use Photoshop professionally for years, I got used to Gimp's quirks in like a few days, but hit the performance wall right after that. Pretty much nothing I did in Photoshop is possible in Gimp due to performance issues.
- nkkollaw 9y agoAre _you_ paying attention (your tone is absolutely horrible, by the way)? I'm saying that I doubt the project's priorities are in line with those of its users. Are you sure that performance is a problem for most users? I have talked to people about GIMP before, and it came out 0 times, while usability was the problem that forced most people to install Photoshop or go back to Windows. In the past 3 days, I've opened pretty big illustrations (about 20,000px* 8000px) on a i35 thinker (mobile phone processor), and I had absolutely no problem opening them, scrolling around, etc. Doing basic operations like moving, cropping, and resizing layers was so cumbersome that after 3 days I gave up and installed Photoshop 7.
- lovelearning 9y agoSince it's a removable dock, I don't see what the problem is. It's a choice every user can make. Only users interested in that information for whatever reason will add it to the dock. Photoshop has it too (https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/using/performance-preferences.html#TheEfficiencyindicator https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/using/performance-preferen...)
- seba_dos1 9y agoUhm, even Photoshop has something like that. Once you work with high resolution files with lots of layers, you absolutely need to "make educated decisions about various configuration options" or you'll suffer waiting ages for every simple operation to complete.
- anc84 9y agoThe text around the image elaborates on its intended, reasonable use. > A new Dashboard dock helps with monitoring GIMP’s resource usage to keep things in check, allowing you to make more educated decisions about various configuration options. Dashboard dock > On the developer side, it also helps us in debugging and profiling various operations or parts of the interface, which is important in our constant quest to improve GIMP and GEGL, and detect which parts are the biggest bottlenecks.