4 ms·
> Laws like this are very hard to vote against because of TV ads opponents of politicians could run demonizing them. I've never understood this argument. Many
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> Laws like this are very hard to vote against because of TV ads opponents of politicians could run demonizing them.
I've never understood this argument. Many bills are a thousand pages long and involve dozens of completely unrelated subject matters.
If you vote for the bill your opponents will be able to use it against you because some parts of it are unpopular. If you vote against it your opponents will be able to use it against you because some parts of it are popular.
So how is that an argument to vote for it? If anything it's an argument to vote against it. If you vote against it you can at least provide a defensible reason -- you were voting against the bad parts of the bill, not the good parts of the bill.
By contrast, voting for a bill with poison in it is completely indefensible because the alternative exists to hold out for a bill with only the good parts.
People understand that doing nothing is better than doing something bad.
- aaomidi 9y agoThe argument really stands where senate votes nearly unanimously on a bill and then a court strikes it down for being too overreaching. We've had this happen with a lot of "child pornography" laws in the past. I'm waiting for ACLU to take this to the courts.