4 ms·
> bad actions of a few What bad actions? If you mean an AI car killing a person - that's hardly "an action", that's an accident. Classic human-driven cars kill
by qwerty456127 9y ago
> bad actions of a few
What bad actions? If you mean an AI car killing a person - that's hardly "an action", that's an accident. Classic human-driven cars kill people every day yet are allowed to continue operation. Do people really expect self-driving cars to be not just more safe than classic but actually 100% safe?
By the way I myself don't drive at all and only use public transport (and a bicycle to ride the countryside). A major reason stopping me from driving is I can't logically understand how can I make sure I am not going to kill anybody if I drive at a speed considered normal (rather than something ridiculous like 15 km/h) and somebody may jump out right in front of my car suddenly (which is very very far from an impossible encounter).
I am totally car-phobic yet I really doubt suspending self-driving cars operation can make the roads more safe. I trust AIs much more than humans when it comes to subjects like this - they can fail occasionally (especially in guaranteed failure situations like when a pedestrian emerges right in front of you all of a sudden) but are seemingly less prone to fail than humans are.
- jonathanstrange 9y agoOne problem with these comparisons is the misinterpretation of statistical data. For general policy making statistics are useful, but for personal decisions you need to take them with a grain of salt and switch on your brain. Human traffic accident statistics include the totality of reckless drivers, street racers, and drunken idiots. Would you readily be a passenger when they drive? I wouldn't. At the same time, the statistics also include the calmest, best, and most reasonable drivers you've ever met in your life. I think it's reasonable to expect self-driving cars to always drive better than your average drunk college student with 1 year of driving experience and instead perform more like the best drivers you've ever met. So yes, self-driving cars should perform above the human average.
- knuththetruth 9y ago>What bad actions? Uber disabled the safety systems included with the car that was involved in the incident. They relied solely on their own, half-baked tech when these systems could have saved the life of person who was killed: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-26/uber-disabled-volvo-suv-s-standard-safety-system-before-fatality https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-03-26/uber-disa...
- qwerty456127 9y agoThanks. This makes sense then. Why did they do this?
- knuththetruth 9y agoOne can only speculate at this point, but the only thing consistent about Uber is their recklessness and disregard for others.
- mkempe 9y agoIndeed. Good engineering does not consist of disabling proven safety mechanisms for the sake of ones under development.
- collingreene 9y agoI remain interested in why the lidar didn't work in this case and I hope more details emerge so we can learn what happened. But it seems logical that Uber would disable the onboard built-in volvo crash detection feature, it would be adding another variable for a car that is intended to test one thing at a time. Its hard to see this solely as the "uber is being reckless" narrative instead of "maybe this is just how all self-driving cars are tested". I am happy to be proven wrong certainly
- MertsA 9y agoIf the Volvo crash avoidance system actually took action then things have obviously already gone very very wrong and it's not like braking when that happens would ever be a bad thing. That's like saying we should remove safety nets from underneath tightropes lest it get in the gymnast's way.
- blensor 9y agoWhy do you think the LIDAR did not work? The LIDAR might have worked just fine but what the system taking the output of the sensor did with the data is the question. If you want to know what we would expect the LIDAR to have seen in such a situation we did a simple simulation of such a scene here [1] If the LIDAR was defective the system processing the sensor output should detect that there is no data coming in and the problem should change the cars behavior accordingly not just drive on as if nothing is wrong. [1] http://www.blensor.org/lidar_accident.html http://www.blensor.org/lidar_accident.html
- simion314 9y agoThis incident brings to light the fact that this Uber car is blind, the person did not jumped in front of the car from behind some obstacle. I can't drive a car because of my bad eyes so it makes sense that when we see that blind cars( or with blind spots) drive on roads we don't like it.