4 ms·
I can understand the hatred many people here have toward Google, Facebook or other big gigantic life-controlling entities. The step to remove Google dominance
by csomar 9y ago
I can understand the hatred many people here have toward Google, Facebook or other big gigantic life-controlling entities.
The step to remove Google dominance is to find, create and nurture alternatives. For example, I started using Fastmail. I'm using some of Apple products like the Calendar and Notes. I'm using Skype for communication.
So I'm diversifying a bit though they can engage in data sharing. This reduces the monopoly power of one single entity.
Blocking Google, Facebook or another big provider will not work and if it did, it can have severe consequences. Most people (and politicians) are ignoring the massive productivity benefits that Google search is bringing. It can be used for evil, but the productivity it brings is paramount.
You can't fight Google by blocking it or destroying it. There is a reason that Google is huge: It is magical and there is no usable alternative.
To remove Google monopoly you did what Google did for Yahoo or Bing: You build an alternative. It is possible to have multiple alternatives for search like for email or smartphones (though we have only two).
The reason we don't? Google won. Android/iOS won. Linux/Windows won. Everybody gave up and just accepted it. Now everyone is screaming of "regulating" these guys. Trust me. This how you get closer to your demise (politicians and current day governments) than to their demise.
- simion314 9y agoWhy not apply the existing rules against monopolies and anti competitive actions, what changed since Microsoft almost was broken up? IMO is not competitive to have Google with it's advertising money get involved in 10 or more different activities and killing the companies that were or would have appeared there just because they have money and can run without profit.
- nerfhammer 9y agoBecause it's not actually a monopoly. Monopoly means no competition. "Monopoly" just means "big" now apparently.
- simion314 9y agoAre you sure Google is not a monopoly in search, even if is not a monopoly there are still rules on abusing a dominant position in one market. Microsoft abused the OS dominance to push a web browser, Google is doing similar things now but for some reasons the US government closes it's eyes on it. (ex I should not see on a Google search results links to download Chrome, or to google products, or Google competitor disappearing from first page results)
- majormajor 9y agoCould you elaborate on why you see it irreplaceable? I don't see how that reconciles with your personal examples of alternative tools? I, similarly, use Apple Maps more than Google Maps now, Messenger or iMessage more than Hangouts, and don't feel like things would be too terrible if I had to go further into Outlook.com or iCloud instead of Gmail/Calendar... Google's versions are better but not in a way that seems magical or impossible to replace (from my experience with my work email/calendar in Outlook).
- csomar 9y agoI actually found most of Google tools to be sub-bar. I only use Google search and I find that irreplaceable.
- ubernostrum 9y agoThe step to remove Google dominance is to find, create and nurture alternatives. Until Google's search results page for what you want to do decides to "promote" Google's own solution and "penalize" the competitor. Which is something Google already does. They claim to have only the best and purest and most angelic of intentions, but the result is still strongly anti-competitive behavior and makes competing with Google a task that ranges from merely "obscenely difficult" all the way up to "actually impossible".
- zapita 9y ago"I can understand the hatred many people here have toward Standard Oil or other big gigantic life-controlling entities. The step to remove Standard Oil dominance is to find, create and nurture alternatives. For example, I started buying petroleum from a small independent refiner. I'm using some of Royal Dutch Oil Company products like their lubricants and ointments. I'm using whale oil for indoor lighting. So I'm diversifying a bit though they can engage in price fixing. This reduces the monopoly power of one single entity. Blocking Standard Oil, Royal Dutch or another big provider will not work and if it did, it can have severe consequences. Most people (and politicians) are ignoring the massive productivity benefits that Standard Oil is bringing. It can be used for evil, but the productivity it brings is paramount. You can't fight Standard Oil by blocking it or destroying it. There is a reason that Standard Oil is huge: It is magical and there is no usable alternative. To remove Standard Oil monopoly you did what Standard Oil did for the Cleveland or Pittsburg cartels: You build an alternative. It is possible to have multiple alternatives for oil like for steel or railroads (though we have only two). The reason we don't? Standard Oil won. Carnegie Steel won. North Pacific won. Everybody gave up and just accepted it. Now everyone is screaming of "regulating" these guys. Trust me. This how you get closer to your demise (politicians and current day governments) than to their demise."
- jadedhacker 9y agoThose Rockafellers are doing just fine even today after Standard Oil was broken up. In telecommunications, the Baby Bells are doing just fine after the Bell Telephone Co. was broken up. They're just as monopolistic, price fixing, and destructive to privacy as ever.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> In telecommunications, the Baby Bells are doing just fine after the Bell Telephone Co. was broken up. And they are mostly back together again, too.
- zapita 9y ago> Those Rockafellers are doing just fine even today after Standard Oil was broken up. Yes, it took a long time to break up Standard Oil, leaving plenty of time for the Rockefellers to amass wealth. What's your point?