5 ms·
> continuing to build a world where they are more and more necessary My grandmother can still, to this day, recount living in an apartment with no furniture ex
by vorpalhex 9y ago
> continuing to build a world where they are more and more necessary
My grandmother can still, to this day, recount living in an apartment with no furniture except a mattress, with my grandfather who was employed as an engineer in New York. It took, by her estimate, about two years to have enough furniture before she was willing to invite over any sorts of company.
Today you can furnish an apartment reasonably with about a months worth of wages. I know this because I helped take a friend who makes a bit over minimum wage to IKEA to get all their furniture for an apartment they moved into.
The myth of decline is that - a myth. The economy is better then it has been in decades, violence is at an all time low, and jobs are widely available in many areas of the country.
I have friends who complain about the economy "being destroyed", who max out credit cards to buy brand new cars and buy expensive home theaters. I have one friend who despite making six figures a year, took a predatory payday loan because she had spent her wages on expensive unused tools.
That's not to blame "millennials" anymore than to blame any other generation. Bad financial choices have existed since the dawn of human history, but in many cases today they are choices, not pre-supposed economic outcomes. We can help correct that by teaching good finance skills (budgeting, doing things yourself instead of hiring people, focusing on cheaper hobbies, etc).
- falcolas 9y agoSo, your proof that decline is a myth is that you can buy cheap, moderate quality, mass-manufactured furniture that didn't exist in your grandparents age? Something seems awry there.
- m_mueller 9y agoI think GP does have a point while missing the bigger picture. Yes, low to average income people can today afford more stuff to make their life a bit better. But they also can‘t afford an apartment close to work (loosing anywhere from 2 to 5 hours of their day they cannot spend e.g. with their kids) and they cannot afford college tuition. That‘s what‘s creating perpetual poverty, i.e. low social mobility, which is IMO one of the most important aspects of a fully developed nation.
- vorpalhex 9y agoMy grandmother couldn't afford a chair. Most people today have reasonably furnished apartments, smartphones, some kind of vaguely functional computer with (low speed) internet access, and probably a car. Food went from being very expensive (people actually died of starvation not that long ago!) to being so cheap that obesity is a major epidemic among the poor. Since 1940, the percent of the US with a high school degree went from < 50% to over 80%. The percent of the US population with a college degree went from < 10% to over 20%. What is your argument that the economy is in decline? That you don't magically get a two story house with a yard, a new car, and the ability to support a family of four? That has never once been the case in US history. It's a great myth in the past that the 1950s were somehow a magical time when everyone had a house and the income for a family, but it's that - a myth.
- ryandrake 9y agoNot sure how the cost of chairs is relevant, compared to the costs of things like housing, student debt, health care, transportation, you know, the things that are actually keeping people today from saving. I make about 4X what my parents combined made as schoolteachers, yet my housing costs about 10X what theirs cost. In order to get that great price I had to move about 2 hours from work (and pay for the required transportation), compared to their 10 minute commute. I came out of grad school six figures in debt, whereas theirs was cheap enough that they barely had to finance it. They paid for reasonably priced doctor visits out of pocket, compared to my high deductible "healthcare plan" that still has me dropping $hundreds for a single X-ray. But I have a cellphone so I'm a reckless spender.
- pdeuchler 9y agoThis is, of course, because technology has brought those costs down. Or in the case of education, government subsidies have made college "free". Not because living wages or the economy have improved.
- jiveturkey 9y ago> Food went from being very expensive (people actually died of starvation not that long ago!) to being so cheap that obesity is a major epidemic among the poor. Food being cheap is not the reason for the obesity epidemic. It's because food has become of such poor quality. Also, it is engineered to cause you to overeat. Otherwise, I agree with your overall point.
- legulere 9y agoMass produced goods including furniture is cheaper nowadays but everything else is more expensive. This includes essential things like housing and healthcare. Further the needs have also grown: without a car it’s impossible for most people to have a job
- vorpalhex 9y ago> but everything else is more expensive Yes and no. One thing to keep in mind is inflation, so we always need to compare prices to average incomes. A house is listed as being <10k in 1940, but the average yearly salary was also <2k, and the minimum wage was $0.30 per hour. However, things have genuinely gotten more expensive in some cases usually due not to the economy, but due to safety. That's a good thing - we no longer have asbestos and lead paint, cars are safer, and working fire alarms are a thing. However, those things do cost money. You can no longer buy an all metal box that goes 80mph without seatbelts or airbags. I find the car claim to be somewhat of a red herring. Yes, you need a car now whereas before a bicycle might of sufficed. However, a decent car can be had for two thousand dollars - not a pretty one, but a functional one. You might be able to go cheaper if you have any mechanical ability, but we'll assume the average person doesn't have that. In addition now of course you need drivers insurance, and you probably need to take a drivers ed course before getting your license. Those things do add cost, but they also save lives.
- mcguire 9y agoYes and no. The median home value in 1940, adjusted for inflation to 2000, was $30,600 ($2,938 pre-adjustment).[1] The median income for a man was $9,948, using the same inflation factor of 10.406639 ($956, unadjusted).[2] The median home sales price in 2015 was about $300,000[3] while median household income was $54,000.[4] [1] https://www.census.gov/hhes/www/housing/census/historic/values.html https://www.census.gov/hhes/www/housing/census/historic/valu... [2] https://www.npr.org/2012/04/02/149575704/the-1940-census-72-year-old-secrets-revealed https://www.npr.org/2012/04/02/149575704/the-1940-census-72-... [3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS [4] https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2016/demo/p60-256.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2016/demo/p60-25...
- qntty 9y agoMy grandparents also lived through the depression. And how did they cope with it? Joined a labor union, joined the socialist party. Maybe not such a bad idea?
- mod 9y agoAs a counter-anecdote, my grandmother is still alive: she was born in 1918. She just voted for Trump, to give you an idea of where she stands politically. She coped with it by scrimping and saving every penny. She literally washes saran wrap to reuse it, despite having enough pension these days to get by. She saves grocery-store bags. She eats every crumb on her plate. She never wastes leftovers, ever. She went to college at 40 years old, which was not thought of highly in her time, and had a 20-year career as a schoolteacher. She still corresponds with some past students, who are her last living friends. My grandfather's college fund (to be a dentist) was wiped out, the bank closed. He worked at a GE factory his whole life, work that I will say was far beneath his potential. He never complained. He once traded his easy job on the line for a much harder one, where he had to lift each engine block twice to inspect some fiddly bit on it. He traded to get a 5-cent raise. If you offered my grandfather a government subsidy, he might not have been able to conceal his contempt. I don't think the decisions of any of the individuals we've mentioned are great indicators of what's correct or incorrect, but the depression didn't influence everyone the same way.
- dvtv75 9y ago> He traded to get a 5-cent raise. A five cent raise in today's currency or back then? Per hour or week? Assuming it's hourly, if it's from "then" could you convert it to modern currency, or present it as an percentage increase so we can understand what kind of relative increase that was? Five cents sounds like nothing today, but 70 years ago it would have been significant.
- bzbarsky 9y agoAccording to https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm $0.05 in 1930 works out to $0.73 today. Figuring out a percentage increase is a bit complicated without knowing how much mod's grandfather earned. According to https://www.archives.gov/publications/prologue/2012/spring/1940.html https://www.archives.gov/publications/prologue/2012/spring/1... in the 1940 census average (yes, not median) annual income was $1368, which works out to $24,505 in 2018 dollars, or $12.25/hour assuming 40 hour weeks and 2 weeks of vacation. So at a guess, $0.05/hour was less than a 10% raise, but more than 1%. I expect it was /hour, not /week, because weekly wages would have been in the ballpark of tens of dollars. Disclaimer: I am not mod, and this is not my grandfather we're talking about.
- qntty 9y agoNobody's denying that the world has improved. The relevant question is "where are we relative to where we could be, given all that we have to work with?" One answer, in the opinion of many informed people, is that we (Americans) haven't done nearly as much with what we have as we could have potentially done.
- rgbrenner 9y agoIt took, by her estimate, about two years to have enough furniture before she was willing to invite over any sorts of company. ... Today you can furnish an apartment reasonably with about a months worth of wages. You do understand there's a difference between a month of wages and having a month of wages saved to spend, right? Considering most people live month to month... saving an entire month would take many people more than 2 years.
- ahtu123 9y agoReally shows how some people in HN have never experienced poverty. If a households main income earner is making minimum wage they will not be making shopping trips to IKEA to furnish their whole apartment lol. IKEA is cheap but the $50 you have left over after bills won't get you much. Many months you will have a negative balance after you've paid for essentials.
- ApolloFortyNine 9y ago>If a households main income earner is making minimum wage Maybe you shouldn't start a family when you are making minimum wage, in a city with a high cost of living.
- ahtu123 9y agoI don't see what that has to do with what I said but sure, the poor shouldn't start families.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoThen start lobbying the red states to stop placing restrictions on birth control and family planning.
- your-nanny 9y agoIt surely seems now that the biological imperative is just a luxury for the rich...
- ghostbrainalpha 9y ago
- specialist 9y agoDid your grandparents retire? At what age? How are they doing now? For comparison, when do you plan to retire? Now do the same run down for your entire cohort.
- vorpalhex 9y agoMy grandfather retired at 67 due to failing health. He was primarily supported by his military pension, and to a smaller extent by a pension from working at a major grocery store. My grandmother only worked odd jobs, but collects a small amount of social security. She's still doing quite well and spends most of her time reading library books and painting (though notice both of those are extremely cheap hobbies). I'm a distinctly unfair comparison, since I could retire as early as 55 to 60 (I doubt I will, I do terribly when left without something to do, but who knows.) That being said, I recognize my situation is very unlike most of my peers. My cohort falls into three categories: + Those with high income and good financial management. Like me they are capable of retiring without any government assistance at 60ish in most situations. + Those with high income, but no financial management skills. Even now with no family to support and no "required" debts, they struggle to remain afloat. Simply throwing more money into the fire doesn't help it turns out. + Those with low income. Universally, and not for lack of intelligence, they have no 401k, no major longterm savings. If they retire it will be through programs such as Social Security (assuming it still exists). This is the group that worries me the most, because I don't have any answer for how to improve their situation. They're simply caught in the spiral of not having enough money to make progress on saving. Please don't take my argument as "Everything is perfect now!". Mostly my argument is, "Things aren't majorly worse and are generally better." Nor am I making the claim that the future will forever be better - Social Security might collapse, pension programs dry up, etc. We shouldn't stop assisting the poor, teaching financial literacy, or behaving intelligently. Simply that the average condition of people is better than it was.
- specialist 9y ago"Please don't take my argument as..." Ok. Peace. "...average condition of people is better than it was." My generation (X) griped about student load debt, which seemed crippling at the time. No comparison with today's kids. Then pile on housing costs, rising insurance premiums, day care & pre school (for anyone choosing to have kids), ... I despair for the millennials.
- sgt101 9y agoOk, I earned approximately $18k when I was a research assistant, 20 years ago, and my possessions when I graduated were : 2 pairs levis, 4 t-shirts, 2 sweaters, 1 coat, 2 pairs shoes (trainers, boots), 1 formal shirt, bag of socks and underwear (I can't remember). I had a watch also. My dad gave it to me - I guess I had privilege. Ok, ok - I also had a car! Sort of - a citroen BX (look it up and marvel). I had gone on holiday once in 4 years, also I had my thesis bound and I had many nights at the pub. Also I used not to heat my attic flat (I was tough), my mother came and helped me move out when I got my first job before graduation. She cried. My point isn't boo hoo, I had a blast, but my point is that I struggled like hell on more than minimum wage 20 years ago. I had no commitments, I was going to earn money in the future (even pre dot.com compsci was a valuable bsc, and even 20 years ago a Ph.D in ML was even more valuable). I had no children, I wasn't french. I had my health (dear god I was a living marvel) I was pretty, I was loved and supported. It isn't personal sin by people making six figures, it's utter shit poured down on people who are both clueless and helpless, and frankly people (like you, like me) qualify to judge by living it. I don't qualify, but I can tell you something factual, without all the advantage that my middle class parents gave me (most of which was growing up with the expectation that I would go to University and study science and if I didn't I was a shameful idiot who could go and work as vegetable picker - fear is a motivator) all the financial skills in the world, all the cheap hobbies and all the diy would not have helped. And by the way if you spend 45 hours a week digging holes how do you think you would contemplate home building projects? Yes, some people work their way out of it, some people are extraordinary, and some people can have great luck and get the cards to fall for them. But most people are just... most people - everyday people. And most times, you get average breaks. Well, you can do the maths and work out the joint distributions - bad things can happen to good people, normal people don't need much to go wrong, and people who will struggle don't need anything to go wrong. A wise man wrote : She came from Greece, She had a thirst for knowledge. She studied sculpture at Saint Martin's College. That's where I caught her eye. She told me that her Dad was loaded. I said, in that case I'll have a rum and coca-cola. She said fine, and in thirty seconds time she said, I want to live like common people. I want to do whatever common people do. I want to sleep with common people. I want to sleep with common people, like you. Well, what else could I do? I said, I'll see what I can do. I took her to a supermarket. I don't know why, but I had to Start it somewhere, so it started there. I said, pretend you've got no money. She just laughed, and said Oh you're so funny. I said, yeah? Well, I can't see anyone else smiling in here. Are you sure you want to live like common people? You want to see whatever common people see? You want to sleep with common people? You want to sleep with common people, like me? But, she didn't understand, She just smiled and held my hand. Rent a flat above a shop. Cut your hair and get a job. Smoke some fags and play some pool. Pretend you never went to school. But still, you'll never get it right. When you're lying in bed at night Watching roaches climb the wall, If you called your Dad he could stop it all. Yeah. You'll never live like common people You'll never do whatever common people do. You'll never fail like common people. You'll never watch your life slide out of view, And dance and drink and screw Because there's nothing else to do. Sing along with the common people. Sing along, and it might just get you thru.' Laugh along with the common people. Laugh along, even though they're laughing at you And the stupid things that you do 'Cause you think that poor is cool. Like a dog lying in a corner, They'll bite you and never warn you. Look out. They'll tear your insides out 'Cause everybody hates a tourist. 'Cause Everybody hates a tourist, Especially one who thinks It's all such a laugh. Yeah, and the chip stains' grease Will come out in the bath. You will never understand How it feels to live your life With no meaning or control And with nowhere left to go. You're amazed that they exist And they burn so bright, While you can only wonder why. Rent a flat above a shop. Cut your hair and get a job. Smoke some fags and play some pool. Pretend you never went to school. But still, you'll never get it right. 'Cause When you're lying in bed at night Watching roaches climb the wall, If you called your Dad he could stop it all. Yeah. You'll never live like common people You'll never do what common people do. You'll never fail like common people. You'll never watch your life slide out of view And dance and drink and screw Because there's nothing else to do. I want to sing with common people, like you. I want to sing with common people, like you. I want to sing with common people, like you.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoThat's a patently false statement. Inflation has been 3% a year for decades and wages have stayed flat. Your example of home furnishings has been improved by industrialization. Property value have skyrocketed, vehicle prices have skyrocketed, college, healthcare... Things you NEED have become way more expensive. Luxury goods have gotten cheaper.
- dlp211 9y agoWages have remained flat when inflation is taken into account, i.e. real wages are flat, nominal wages continue to increase. We also have seen upward movement in median household income recently, and we should expect that trend to continue. So the idea of flat wages may be coming to an end. What hasn't remained flat is the wages paid to the top N% which has greatly increased and accelerated the wealth gap. It is this gap that leaves people less satisfied despite being generally better off.
- MaybiusStrip 9y agoI would qualify: people aren't just dissatisfied because of the "unfairness" of growing inequality. The growth of the wealth gap has some very real ramifications, ie: on the distribution of power in politics.
- greedo 9y agoAs if the poor ever had any power in politics. Huey Long might have been a lightning rod for poor people, but it's not as if their votes have been courted since I've been alive.
- sokoloff 9y ago>Inflation has been 3% a year for decades and wages have stayed flat. Every time I read this claim and go looking for data, I find data that says that real wages are roughly flat, which means that they have kept pace with inflation. (That's the definition of real wages: that they are in inflation-adjusted terms.) It seems a common journalistic (and often political) talking point to say exactly what you said, which makes the math or reading comprehension challenged assume something quite different. While the author or speaker is not technically lying, they are merely misleading the reader/listener with a confusing (and sometimes confused) combination of nominal inflation and real wages. See figures 3 and 4 here: https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/ https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/ > Property value have skyrocketed, vehicle prices have skyrocketed This next chart is in nominal dollars (meaning, not inflation adjusted): http://ritholtz.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/pricechanges.png http://ritholtz.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/pricechanges.... It shows that vehicles have not gotten more expensive (even as they've gotten much, much better, safer, more reliable, etc) and that housing and food/beverages have inflated by less than wages and by roughly the same amount as general inflation (which is no great surprise, given that they are a substantial component of the inflation calculation and that it would be difficult to sustain inflation over a long period of time in a consumer-driven economy in the absence of [nominal] wage growth for consumers). College and healthcare have indeed risen much more quickly than wages or general inflation. Do you have contrary sources?
- Spooky23 9y agoI think that you're correct. People who knew me early on in certain contexts thought that I was "rich" comparatively speaking. They didn't see the 10 year old car, 4 roommates (in a cheap city), camping vacations, sale clothes, etc. I was debt free quickly. I'm in a fairly well compensated gig now but kept the habits. The car is a 2003, my house is older, vacations are in nicer hotels but we drive, etc. That's not to say that people have challenges that are tough... but so did I!
- pepelepuanteur 9y agoWhether or not a bad financial choice is a out of necessity is highly situation-dependent and the situation doesn't look great for the majority of millennials. I think this point sometimes gets lost among the HN crowd for whom a bad financial decision is most often a choice. Things like the extraordinary rise in the cost of higher education -- which has become a near defacto requirement to obtain a livable wage -- should not be discounted. The example of student debt is particularly salient because it appears to materially impact the vast majority of millennials. Even those of us fortunate enough to be making six-figure incomes spend many years pouring money into debt instead of retirement or brokerage accounts. In most cases this setback leads delays in home ownership, starting a family, and retirement. This is a problem that cannot be remedied by teaching good financial skills.