9 ms·
This gives a consumer the ability to do whatever they want with a device[1]. Its a change aimed at stopping OEMs from providing unlicensed devices. (Edit: or re
by joshuamorton 9y ago
This gives a consumer the ability to do whatever they want with a device[1]. Its a change aimed at stopping OEMs from providing unlicensed devices. (Edit: or really from providing official Google apps on those devices. There's nothing wrong with forking Android for your device, but Google does want to control whether or not Gmail runs on it, especially if that device doesn't meet certain standards.)
[1]: See the "custom ROM" thing at the bottom. There's a caveat that the current implementation has a limit of 100 device ids. There's some discussion/debate about what that will end up meaning. If it ends up meaning 100 devices, that's fine for any consumer use pattern. It may in practice end up meaning 100 flashes, which is/could be problematic for certain users (custom ROM developers, as an example).
- michaelmrose 9y agoApparently google isn't smart enough to realize people aren't rational. People think of finite resources differently than infinite resource and any such counter is perceptively a counter ticking away towards losing access to accessing your email and apps and the logically emotional response is to ditch google entirely next upgrade cycle even if you will never reasonably reach zero.
- landryraccoon 9y agoIf you were right, Apple wouldn't be printing money as much as they do. Android users will ditch google and switch to... What? Apple? Where you can't install anything at all except through the tightly controlled Apple app store?
- glogla 9y agoWell if you get zero openness with both Google and Apple, you might as well get the privacy protection of Apple with it, right?
- jhasse 9y agoopenness isn't zero with Android, e.g. you can install alternative app stores.
- michaelmrose 9y agoYou mean where the ones where the apps you want don't exist or the one which works on Amazon. Apt sources don't require permission to use them with a particular device.
- jhasse 9y agoStill more apps than in iOS's alternative app stores.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoWhat percentage of apps are available on third party app stores? Openness isn't zero with Android, it's just an obscene fractional portion that might as well be zero.
- jhasse 9y agoOften you can sideload the ones you're missing. Also there's the AOSP. And openness to use a custom launcher, browser engine, overlays, ...
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoAOSP is crippled/barely functional due to parts being abandoned in favor of Google Apps. And as far as sideloading, where are you supposed to get the apps? The Play Store won't let you download them off the web, because that would let them out of the walled garden. Most companies won't link their APKs, they just link you to the Play Store. You might get lucky and it's popular enough to be on APKMirror, but there's really not a "good" way to sideload. Oh, and most apps require Play Services to run now, and won't work even if you do sideload them.
- ksk 9y agoIn cases where users' freedoms for legitimate uses are curtailed I believe we should be siding with the end users. Maybe in time we will see microsoft banning chrome, firefox, steam etc from running on devices not certified by MS. Its "their OS" so "its their right".
- joshuamorton 9y agoBut the end user can do whatever they want. The end user is free to install a custom ROM and use GApps. They have to jump through an extra hoop. This would be like Microsoft banning Lenovo from sticking unlicensed copies of windows on Lenovo laptops. Something which Microsoft already does.
- ksk 9y agoWell my analogy was that the 'service' MS provides is the OS Platform API, and its blocking applications from executing on their platform. Which would be ridiculous. A user should be able to run any software they want. Similarly, as a user (paid or otherwise) of Google's services, unless specific evidence is given that the user is abusing their services, Google is in the wrong here of blocking someone preemptively.
- joshuamorton 9y agoWhat end user do you feel is being blocked from using what software? I have a feeling you misunderstand what's actually happening here.
- closeparen 9y agoGoogle is not blocking third-party apps from running on its platform. It's blocking its own proprietary apps from running on third-party platforms which happen to share the same base. A more appropriate analogy might be MS not releasing Internet Explorer for the Mac... which they haven't since IE5.