4 ms·
>> You could not form a true description of the innards of the computer if your entire view of reality was confined to the desktop. And yet the desktop is usef
by phkahler 9y ago
>> You could not form a true description of the innards of the computer if your entire view of reality was confined to the desktop. And yet the desktop is useful. That blue rectangular icon guides my behavior, and it hides a complex reality that I don’t need to know. That’s the key idea. Evolution has shaped us with perceptions that allow us to survive. They guide adaptive behaviors. But part of that involves hiding from us the stuff we don’t need to know. And that’s pretty much all of reality, whatever reality might be. If you had to spend all that time figuring it out, the tiger would eat you.
What he's overlooking in that desktop metaphor is that there are people who understand ALL of the inner workings down to atoms. No single person has it all in their head, but the software was written by human minds to run on hardware created by human minds that understand the device physics down to a very low level. A user of the software doesn't have to have a full model of the reality - in fact that was the entire point of the desktop metaphor, to make it simple for people so they don't NEED to understand it all in order to use it. For most users that is sufficient level of understanding, and if everyone took the full deep dive we would indeed all be eaten by tigers. But that only says none of us has a full model of reality, it does not say our model of reality is wrong in any way.
I find it amusing that he chose a metaphor designed to hide the complexity of reality from people while ignoring the fact that it was done that way deliberately by people.
- dajomu 9y agoIt seems that he chose it exactly for that reason though. The desktop is an abstraction built upon successive abstractions to hide reality from us so that we can do what we need to do. Computers have 'evolved' to what they are today to essentially improve their fitness to their environment, even if that means that it is impossible for any one person to fully understand how they work. In this case it kind of supports his idea that evolution would lead to a similar kind of model of reality in our heads. But the most interesting thing seemed to be the fact that if you remove objective reality from his models you can just build on successive layers of abstraction and the model still works. I know this metaphor doesn't hold up in all cases, but it seems like it's a pretty good introduction to this idea.