5 ms·
Remember Digg? Unlike the companies you listed, FB is user-facing - just like Digg. If users happen to decide that a company is not "cool" anymore or dispase i
by mrtksn 9y ago
Remember Digg? Unlike the companies you listed, FB is user-facing - just like Digg.
If users happen to decide that a company is not "cool" anymore or dispase its public figure(Zuckerberg), it may actually go away.
Remember IE(stands for Internet Explorer)? Using Firefox and later Chrome became a crusade and the almighty brand of the richest person in the world that holds the monopoly on computers platforms bled to death.
- zerostar07 9y agoThis is a media campaing, not “the users”
- kbenson 9y agoI'm not sure Digg had enough money lying around to just buy the next "cool" thing that comes along, as Facebook has done a few times now.
- mrtksn 9y agoI added IE to my example to illustrate that having all the money in the world may not save you when your brand becomes toxic. Some may say that FB users don't care but with IE it also was just geeks and devs, but it turned into a crusade and now everyone "knows" that the first thing you do after you have a fresh PC is to install Chrome.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoThe difference is, if devs don’t support your brower, your browsing experience suffers. Every developer on Earth could leave Facebook and it would not make the experience of using fb any worse. Facebook is not a software platform, it’s an ad platform. If anything fb would get better if we stopped targeting it.
- mrtksn 9y agoI remember the process, it had nothing to do with the dev support. Actually, it was the other way around - IE had all the dev support and websites broke down on Firefox but people were fanatics. There were extensions that let you render the page in IE if it's not working on Firefox. When the Chrome came along, Firefox already put a dent in IE market share and it already became socially unacceptable for techies to use IE but regular people still used IE so the devs were forced to make sure that everything works perfectly on IE too. For the masses, thanks to the developers, IE displayed the websites just fine up until the bitter end. Friends didn't let friends use IE and it was killed.
- tatersolid 9y agoIE11 still has 75% share in the banking industry. It’s far from dead, although we’re finally seeing Edge and Firefox rise a bit more sharply. Slow-moving, heavily regulated corps with lots of internal legacy apps simply cannot use Chrome with its frequent feature deprecation, weak management, and constant desire to send telemetry and who knows what else to Google servers.
- nine_k 9y agoThis is fair. But if users flee from FB, or just start using it less, it does have an impact on advertising: it becomes less effective.
- binocarlos 9y agoPerhaps part of that was that IE was really bad at it's job and as users were told about Chrome and Firefox and they tried it and it was much faster - they switched because IE was not nearly as good. Facebook is pretty good at it's job - despite questionable practices. If Facebook started to suck from a user perspective (a bit like MySpace did) - users would move to another thing in a shot.
- lambda_lover 9y agoI would disagree with the claim that Facebook is "pretty good at its job" -- the News Feed is completely full of ads and "suggested content", notifications have become complete noise at this point, and even Messenger has ads in it now, and makes it difficult to get to your actual list of online friends. In 2011, Facebook was good at its job, with a chronological news feed, meaningful notifications, and a messenger paradigm that worked much like AIM in the early 2000s -- you could see who was online, away, go invisible, etc. In 2018, Facebook has lost all of those positives, and with it a lot of user engagement, all for the sake of cramming the maximum number of ads down the users throats. And I'm not even getting into the nasty dark UX patterns, like hiding the ability to delete your profile (seriously, there isn't a link to do this anywhere on the site -- you need to search Google for it and they change the link all the time to break external guides) and showing random pictures of "friends who will miss you if you leave!" when you try to delete your account. I don't think your average user would mind leaving Facebook much if there was any actual alternative.
- kbenson 9y agoI think you're under the impression that facebook's job is to be good at showing you what you want and being useful. I'm pretty sure they think their job is to balance being just useful enough that you don't quit while maximizing revenue from you, which might entail being pretty crappy to use overall.
- Lionsion 9y ago> I think you're under the impression that facebook's job is to be good at showing you what you want and being useful. I'm pretty sure they think their job is to balance being just useful enough that you don't quit while maximizing revenue from you, which might entail being pretty crappy to use overall. This is just a minor quibble to lambda_lover's point, which still stands. Facebook may understand it's job is to shove as many ads in its users' faces as they will tolerate, but that's not why users use its app. It's users view its job as being useful to them, and being bad at that makes makes FB vulnerable to competitors or even just general dissatisfaction.
- shamino 9y agoIE may be bad, but IE is not a stock symbol. MSFT is, and I wouldn't have mind buy MSFT when IE was going down. :)
- bitumen 9y agoIt’s a turgid fantasy that you can predict, buy, and incubate the next big thing reliably. If that were true, there would be no failed VC’s.
- kbenson 9y agoAs ggg9990 noted, is not about discovering them when they are small and cheap and making money on the market increase, it's about buying them when they are got and making money on the execution of the business. Facebook isn't the VC company, Facebook is who those companies hope to sell to later.
- ggg9990 9y agoFacebook doesn’t need to predict — they can buy when it’s already big. They are able to monetize users much better than random startup social network so they are able to pay much more per engaged user than the company could get from VCs or the public market.
- hart_russell 9y agoI don't think that is an apt analogy. Facebook users become so entrenched with their social network, pictures, etc. that it is much harder to delete than a bunch of interest categories.
- jumpman500 9y agoI don't know. Once you get your photos off of Facebook I think you can leave really easily. You can still message all your important friends through sms or your chosen chat app. Snapchat exists as an alternative for casual photo sharing. Reddit or Twitter for posting news, memes or funny videos. I think people exaggerate the importance of Facebook. Young people can adapt to new technology quickly. I know I was able to drop Facebook pretty easily.
- Domenic_S 9y ago> Young people can adapt to new technology quickly. I know I was able to drop Facebook pretty easily. Older people can't. I think sharing photos with extended (ie, older) family is a huge use case for Facebook.
- jumpman500 9y agoYea but that's also a reason to leave. I know one of the main reasons I stopped using Facebook for photos was because I didn't want my Mom and extended family looking at the parties I went to at college.
- bluGill 9y agoThat is why I have to remain. I want my mom to see pictures of my kids. I want to see pictures of my nephew's lip after he got hit with a ball (6 stitches). The girl who took 4th place in the state dance competition is of interest to me because I remember her mom from high school - the first place dancer is nothing to me. The real things in life that matter are why I'm on facebook and why I cann't leave. Politics and some hobby groups are on Facebook and interesting, but the real meat is the personal photos and stories that would never be in the news.
- sjg007 9y agoSo they’ll go to Instagram?
- mrtksn 9y agoWhat happens if people start talking about how much they hate Zuckerberg and start looking for alternatives and the cool kids start suggesting each other some other social network that's technically good enough but never took off because didn't benefit from the network effect? Then anything he touches becomes toxic. Zuckerberg isn't even divisive like Trump, he may have issue finding people to rally with him against the deserters.
- eggpy 9y agoSo you're saying it's time to start plugging Mastodon[0]? Because I'm in! [0] https://mastodon.social/about https://mastodon.social/about
- Goronmon 9y agoMore of a Twitter alternative than a Facebook alternative.
- pferde 9y agoPlease, no, not yet another open and federated social media platform that is in fact not much more than an endless feed of bots posting and reposting twitter posts and rss feeds. The internet can't take much more of those. I wanted these platforms to succeed, I've had an account and tried using most of them - Diaspora, Friendica, Red Matrix, someothermatrixIdontrememberthenameof, Mastodon, identica/statusnet, ... They're all the same. (I'm sure I'm forgetting at least one or two, but they all blend together.)
- sjg007 9y agoI mean the company that can really capitalize on this right now is snapchat.
- cookiecaper 9y ago> Remember Digg? Unlike the companies you listed, FB is user-facing - just like Digg. Digg was abandoned because it broke itself. The codebase that all those users knew and depended on was completely trashed (the original author hangs out here sometimes), the site dropped a number of its key functions, and the user experience was redesigned to maximize Digg's ability to show ads, no matter how obnoxious that got, with many people saying that it was almost entirely ads by this point (I had personally stopped using Digg years before the big v4 debacle, so I can't speak to this directly). People want the path of least resistance. They'll tolerate some ads, but their tolerance ends when it's just easier to click over to the other guy's site and get a comparable experience. If you neuter/break Digg, and reddit is right there, well... The path of least resistance for Facebook users is still Facebook, regardless of the news cycle. Facebook will remain dominant until it is no longer the path of least resistance, just like everything else. Users have different levels of tolerance. The moment a switch is the path of least resistance differs for everyone, usually corresponding to their level of emotional investment in the platform and their individual tech savvy. Facebook has a lot of very invested, very non-tech-savvy users. The right types of questions to ask are along the lines of whether we're sure competitors have sufficient ground to catch up to massive incumbents and keep them honest (and in this case specifically, whether certain misrepresentations or violations occurred that should be made to materially affect market standing through government intervention). For the most part, tech is non-competitive due to terrible legislation like the CFAA.
- narag 9y agoIf you neuter/break Digg, and reddit is right there, well... That case is about an almost identical twin, but I would also consider sites that are not so similar but serving the same function. I haven't had a Facebook account so not sure what it is exactly, but people are happy as long as I have Whatsapp.
- waylandsmithers 9y ago> The right types of questions to ask are along the lines of whether we're sure competitors have sufficient ground to catch up to massive incumbents and keep them honest (and in this case specifically, whether certain misrepresentations or violations occurred that should be made to materially affect market standing through government intervention). I don't see how there could ever be any viable competition. Facebook already has many of the top engineering minds in the world who are pushing the edge of what computers are capable of, not to mention the largest database and neural network of human behavior ever created.
- FussyZeus 9y ago> If users happen to decide that a company is not "cool" anymore or dispase its public figure(Zuckerberg), it may actually go away. This is already sort of happening anyway with the "my parents are on Facebook now" problem. That I think is a much bigger threat to Facebook's future than any regulations that are coming.
- jakelazaroff 9y ago"Companies and products sometimes fail" doesn't really address the claim "the market doesn't seem to punish gross misconduct or negligence." Re: GP's examples, Uber is a "user-facing" company, and the Wells Fargo and Bank of America scandals involved consumer services. Also, it's not like companies are incapable of making conscientious decisions with regard to other companies with which they do business.
- philipodonnell 9y agoFor public companies in the US, they are mostly incapable of making decisions like this as if can be shown to negativity effect enterprise value they can be sued by shareholders that do not have the same moral issues.
- Xixi 9y agoI read these kind of comments all the time, yet I'm still to see one actual court case showing that this is true. Are you really sure that this is true?
- JetSpiegel 9y agoSmarter shareholders will just get the CEO ousted. An inside job, much cleaner than mud slinging through the courts. A distinction without a difference.
- zxcba23sdf23 9y agohttps://www.marketwatch.com/story/facebooks-stock-bounces-slightly-after-suffering-worst-week-in-6-years-2018-03-26 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/facebooks-stock-bounces-sl... I mean, something like 80 percent of Fortune 500s from a generation ago are out of business. So yeah, it seems plain Facebook will die "someday". Doesn't appear to be any time soon, though.
- eggpy 9y agoI was totally ready to call you out and that the rebranding of IE to Edge resulted in no change in adoption and Microsoft wins by default but apparently I am totally incorrect. Chrome is _by far_ dominating the browser game[0]. And while I'd rather FF take that spot, dethroning Microsoft makes my nerd heart pretty happy. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers#/media/File:StatCounter-browser-ww-monthly-200901-201707.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers#/m...
- purple-again 9y agoWow I honestly had no idea. I would of bet you $100 on the spot that Microsoft had more than 50% marketshare of browser traffic and considered you a sucker for taking the bet. I had no idea Chrome had dominated so much. I wonder what Firefox did wrong that it didn't become Chrome? It was the cool browser to use years before I ever heard of Chrome.
- mrtksn 9y agoMaybe it was Google's push for the most part but Firefox made a reputation or being cluttered memory hogg and when Chrome came along it was so fast and fresh. Firefox used to lose it's smoothness when a tab misbehaves and didn't take advantage of the multi-core processors that were getting popular but Chrome was butter smooth even if a website is not responding(due to Flash Player mostly) because everything runs in a separate process and if a website died only that tab died. It was no-brainer to switch to Chrome. Also, Google was this cool company that was giving away revolutionary products. Don't do evil was their motto.
- xienze 9y agoIt probably helps that everyone visiting google.com, far and away the most popular search website, that isn’t already using Chrome is prompted to install it.
- simias 9y agoDigg and IE "died" because there was a real practical incentive to move towards alternatives. This Facebook thing is mostly ideological at the core, in terms of day-to-day user experience it's no better or worse than it was a month ago. Digg also never was more than a small speck of dust compared to Facebook, even at the apex of its popularity. Facebook's huge network effect is hard to overcome. If you want Facebook to die you have to come up with an alternative with improved usability to convince people to switch over. Now you have do that with the added handicap of "do no evil" (so less money from targeted advertising etc...) while fighting to gain market share against some of the biggest companies in the world. My guess is that if you manage to do all of that you'll just end up bought by Facebook anyway.
- joering2 9y ago> My guess is that if you manage to do all of that you'll just end up bought by Facebook anyway. Of course.. unfortunately you can't say no when some behemoth wants to buy you. /s
- wmeredith 9y agoIt's indeed a rare breed that can, especially when the checks come with nine zeros.
- DesiLurker 9y agounless the privacy protections are codified in the company charter from day one with some poison pill type mechanism. last I heard a social network called ello was trying to do that. lately they have rebranded themselves into a 'artist social net'. IMO still worth the switch if moving with close friends. Honestly if fb were to just take the money from me and leave me alone i'd be happy to pay that ransom for my friends.
- soylentcola 9y agoAdditionally (at least for the IE example) there's another huge difference: those who wished to use an IE alternative could do so and continue to engage the same activities and access all the same content--with a few ActiveX exceptions--as they could before. Most importantly, those who wished to make the switch from IE to Firefox or Chrome or Safari or Opera, etc. could do so without requiring any additional action by others. Again, outside of a few compatibility issues on a few sites, I could change the software I used without convincing webmasters or other users to do anything. Same went for webmail. I could switch to Yahoo or Gmail or Hotmail or whatever I wanted without requiring me to convince every other relative, friend, and business contact to do the same. With something like Facebook, you can't just use a different platform to interact with those same people in the same way unless you convince them all to migrate with you. If everyone you know only wants to use Facebook, then that's your option. You can't set up your profile on Diaspora or Google+ or whatever and expect to enjoy all the things you prefer about them because there's no shared protocol like there is with web browsing or email.