3 ms·
Btw, it's spelled "Mastodon". > If you want to decentralize the servers then you MUST also decouple user accounts from the server they signed up with. I somew
by Tepix 9y ago
Btw, it's spelled "Mastodon".
> If you want to decentralize the servers then you MUST also decouple user accounts from the server they signed up with.
I somewhat disagree. Email is a decentralized service that works well and its accounts are coupled to the server you signed up with. It merely requires you to do some research when picking a node² or running your own.
Ideally there would be some provision in the protocol that allows you to transfer your content and notify your friends whenever there is an address change. You could do this with a digital signature. You could also bolt on a decentralized identity that's on the blockchain, e.g. register a domain with namecoin (which is completely decentralized) and point it to your current social identity. Problem solved¹.
--
¹ to be fair, registering a domain with namecoin is not trivial at the moment.
² perhaps pick one that requires payment, that creates an obligation to provide the service
- daveFNbuck 9y agoI didn't do much research when picking a node and now I'm locked in to Gmail way more than I am to Facebook. If I stop using Facebook, I lose access to a few people I'm not actually talking to anyway. If I stop using Gmail, not only do people lose the ability to contact me, it also breaks my account on most other services I use online.
- Tepix 9y agoYes. It's convenient but it's bad for privacy and locks you in. I'm not using any SSO for that reason.
- Steltek 9y agoThere's less friction in moving to a new email provider. You sign up, you blast your contacts "Hey folks, got a new email address", and you're off to the races. Social networks have circles, permissions, and all sorts of other clinginess. Additionally, there are features in email that you won't expect from these nodes like a useful (to muggles) data export. I can pull down my email with IMAP or POP, close that account, and still have access to all of my old email. Hell, I could _reply_ to one of those old conversations using my new account/provider and keep right on trucking.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]