5 ms·
If enough people didn't have access to insurance, then there would be pressure on hospitals to find ways to reduce prices (so that their volume could go up). As
by whatshisface 9y ago
If enough people didn't have access to insurance, then there would be pressure on hospitals to find ways to reduce prices (so that their volume could go up). As it stands the medical industry is allowed to hold the poor for ransom ("accept our increased costs or they won't get treated") against the US's deep but finite pockets.
Before, we had the (very poor) demand elasticity of people paying everything they had and then maxing out every credit source, and predictably prices rose to around that point. Now, we have no demand elasticity at all, and prices can be expected to rise well above the average person's net worth + credit access.
If you look at any microeconomic equilibrium chart, you'll see that the price is held in a balance between people buying and people holding off due to price. When the good is healthcare, the human cost of "holding off" is very high, and usually involves inability to pay. Unfortunately our economic system tends to fly off the rails if this balance is disrupted, no matter how noble or urgent the cause.
- komali2 9y ago>pressure on hospitals to reduce prices Elsewhere it has been said: choosing between bankruptcy for your family or cancer care for your child isn't an actual choice, it's two loaded guns pointed at your skull. One held by the hospital, the other by the insurance company. The reason first world countries choose universal healthcare is that healthcare is a human right. Full stop. It is not an economic issue. If you want to get economic about it though you'll lose because as it turns out a healthy educated populace is more productive than one that loses productive families here and there to lances of bankruptcy from the unpredictable nest of human disease.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 9y agoI also feel the moral imperative that you're describing. Nobody should have to tell their child that they're too expensive - to be honest, I can't imagine anything worse. We were literally using lives as an economic mechanism, but now that we're not doing that we need to use something else in their place. The price of healthcare will continue to skyrocket unless we find something a little less horrifying than other people's lives to use as a balancing weight; although I won't claim to know whether it would be more possible to design a working market system or socialize it successfully. Priority 1, stop making Soylent Green out of people. Priority 2, re-establish the food supply in a better way, because we need to eat.
- AFNobody 9y agoI'm not sure its fair to argue that universal healthcare is a human right despite the fact it makes economic sense. Humanity survived just fine without real healthcare and healthcare is not essential to a fair balance of power b/t the government and its citizenry. Universal healthcare needs to be argued on the economics of the issue because that is the only practical way to make it sustainable. The "feel good" stuff about it being a human right will fail when stress is applied to America and stress is coming. The US, frankly, has peaked and it is all downhill from here.
- whatshisface 9y agoYou also have to watch out that asserting positive rights that are sometimes impossible to provide (like healthcare) will confuse people when governments attempt to claim that other, deeper rights are "impossible to give." (For example, they might try to argue that they can't afford to not torture, comparing it to how their impoverished country can't give everyone free internet.)
- komali2 9y agoWhy is that? If a country tries to claim it cannot afford not to torture, can't we simply point to all the countries that manage without it, as I do for the healthcare debate?
- dragonwriter 9y agoAs anyone who lived through the more recent Bush Administration witnessed nearly daily, people claim “not torturing” is an impossible right to give while denying all positive rights—and acted on that argument—so I fail to see the relationship.
- whatshisface 9y agoDenying every right is the last step of the manuver I'm describing, the first step is to re-define right to mean comfort. Bush-era politics just went straight to step 2 and it didn't work on us. I suspect that the current UN rights council may be an example of this in action. See: the track record of the members on negative rights, the number of positive rights on their list of rights.
- shard972 9y ago> The reason first world countries choose universal healthcare is that healthcare is a human right. Full stop. I'm sure they said that in soviet Russia too. It's all good to say X,Y or Z is a right until you actually cash in on that right. I mean you don't even have to look to the soviet union, what is goinig on with the VA? Obama was working to fix that smaller universal healthcare system from actually just waiting years for people to die but I haven't heard any good news comming out of there recently. The rest of your claims are just nonsensical in this context since your just assuming universal healthcare works because the government decrees it to be universal.
- komali2 9y agoOn Reddit, to responses like this ("America is incapable of universal healthcare because... Reasons") I like to link to the Wikipedia pages of the multitude of other countries with far lower GDPs solving the problem. I can probably predict the response but on the chance I'll be surprised - why can't America solve the problem when Taiwan, Switzerland, Sweden, France, Germany, the UK, Canada, Finland, Norway, etc etc etc have or nearly have? (I have received healthcare in several of these countries and an readily prepared with counterpoints to the inaccurate "healthcare isn't good / lines are long in those countries" arguments, fair warning)
- cmurf 9y agoAmericans pay double in health care costs per capital than any industrialized nation. And we don't have better outcomes. All of those countries have universal healthcare. Citation, OECD.
- intended 9y agoHow can you knowingly discuss demand elasticity and then apply to healthcare? Healthcare is a non typical market and the cost of a persons health is irrationally high to that person.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 9y agoThink about this: Everyone on a boat has twenty dollars and absolutely needs an EpiPen to live. You have a supply of EpiPens and want to get as much of their money as possible. There's zero elasticity between 0 and 20 dollars, but you better not charge $21! Now, imagine that there was only one person who needed an EpiPen, but everyone else was willing to pitch in as much as it took to help them out. If the supplier of the medicine was perfectly evil, the price would be $20 times the number of people. Perfect self-interest is a pretty good model of any industry, including pharma, so I think this is a good picture of the situation. The ACA was careful to keep something like a market system in place, which is why we're faced with a problem that can be understood with microeconomics.
- intended 9y agoInsurance markets are really really old concepts. Healthcare is known to be a market which has non standard policy imperatives The cheapest, simplest and most effective system is single payer with everyone in a single pool. Every major first world power achieves better outcomes for lower costs than America. Your theoretical premise would have merit if this was only theoretical, and we had no real world evidence that this was a bad idea.
- whatshisface 9y agoI'm describing market actors with phrases like "perfectly evil," so I hope my comments aren't coming across as policy proposals. All I was arguing is that uninsured people running out of money was a pressure that used to be restraining the price increases but now isn't. I really feel like this discussion is suffering from false-dichotomy-itis: I've actually been very careful to avoid saying anything beyond my point, about (say) whether or not single payer is a good idea for the US.
- Feniks 9y agoUnfortunately doctors have a moral and legal imperative to treat everyone regardless of medical insurance. Yes it would be a lot easier if a hospital could deal with non paying patients by chugging them off the roof but the reality is that almost nobody wants that.
- crzwdjk 9y ago> pressure on hospitals to find ways to reduce prices This might be the case if hospitals had to actually show their prices rather than sending bills after the fact for a price you aren't allowed to know when you consent to treatment. It might also help if competition were allowed, but for hospitals it is pretty much not in a lot of states. To open a new hospital in many states, you need a "certificate of need", which is basically a document demonstrating that you won't be competing with the existing hospitals. So much for "free market health care".
- sjg007 9y agoMedicaid and medicare are what keep hospitals open. Most of the volume comes from those patient populations.