5 ms·
GPU companies seem to be notoriously closed and in general secretive about their products; nVidia is only one of the more prominent current examples, but AMD/AT
by userbinator 9y ago
GPU companies seem to be notoriously closed and in general secretive about their products; nVidia is only one of the more prominent current examples, but AMD/ATI wasn't that nice in the past either. AFAIK Intel was the first to release detailed specs on its GPUs.
Ideally, one should be able to go to their websites and download full documentation (and drivers with source) on any of their products, as well as actually order the bare GPUs chips. Instead, thanks to their desire to control the entire manufacturing and distribution chain, it's a convoluted NDA-filled process. Personally, I don't really get it; why would a company put all these barriers in place to would-be customers of their products, and thus restrict their revenue? I'm almost willing to bet that there would be many more buying and using their GPUs if they left the market more open.
Microchip is one prominent example of the "other way" --- full documentation for their microcontrollers, and even direct ordering from the website. They are very successful. Unfortunately no GPU manufacturer seems to be doing this.
- wtallis 9y agoNVidia and ATI/AMD experienced more than a decade as a duopoly where everyone who wanted a powerful graphics chip bought one from one of those two companies. Their only big growth opportunities were to expand the number of gamers. Open specs don't help much with that. In the meantime, computer graphics has long been a patent minefield, and Hollywood has been pressuring the chip makers to play along with their DRM schemes. Both of those are strong incentives to not be fully open.
- userbinator 9y agoTheir only big growth opportunities were to expand the number of gamers. Open specs don't help much with that. It would increase the number of companies who could produce their own designs and thus diversity the market; and GPGPU might've come sooner if the documentation was far more widely available.
- wtallis 9y ago> It would increase the number of companies who could produce their own designs Their own designs for competing GPUs, or their own designs for graphics cards incorporating NVidia and ATI GPUs? There's never been a shortage of the latter, and there's never been an incentive for NVidia or ATI to help enable the former. I don't think GPGPU would have happened much earlier, but I do think open hardware specs would have drastically changed the evolution of GPGPU tooling. There would have been upstream backends for GCC and LLVM before closed frameworks like CUDA could have gotten a foothold. But none of that was going to happen until the GPUs were actually capable of running general purpose code.
- pjmlp 9y agoGPGPU started the day shaders were possible. There are SIGRAPH papers from 2003 about how to use GPU Assembly with texture data for doing non graphics related computations.
- zaarn 9y agoWell, on one point, AMD does have fully open source drivers for Linux at this point so there is atleast that. Nvidia still deploys a binary blob (which might work with your kernel or not)
- ksec 9y agoI was rather hoping one day GPU could be used as simple as CPU, and Drivers is barely needed. The problem with today's graphics pipeline is the amount of code and work required in Drivers. In the past have many GPU vendors, most of them could not get their drivers working right or performance enough. And Nvidia and AMD has no incentive of opening up, because their years of work in the drivers set are a barrier of entry for anyone who wants to step in to make a decent GPU. May be Intel's forthcoming GPU will be a little more opened? May be Apple's has a Metal GPU in the making for Mac?
- rjsw 9y agoThat was the idea behind Larrabee [1], I always felt that the potential ease of programming was undersold. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larrabee_(microarchitecture) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larrabee_(microarchitecture)
- oblio 9y ago> May be Apple's has a Metal GPU in the making for Mac? That won't help anyone cause sure as hell, Apple won't allow you to order the chips from their site.
- ksec 9y agoI mean on Apple's platform. And assuming this create some advantage for Apple, others things will move in that direction. ( slowly )
- naveen99 9y agoI’m rather hoping that the cpu cache hierarchy will one day be as programmable is the GPU local, shared, global memory.