5 ms·
I think the same way. In the end, advertising creates harm to people. Put aside the numbers, and vacuous phrases like "creating value to the shareholders". The
by andrepd 9y ago
I think the same way. In the end, advertising creates harm to people. Put aside the numbers, and vacuous phrases like "creating value to the shareholders". The net impact on advertising is harm to people. It's about using tricks, potentially with very harmful side effects, to manipulate people into buying your stuff.
Sometimes I imagine how a world without any type of commercial advertising would be...
- colechristensen 9y ago>It's about using tricks, potentially with very harmful side effects, to manipulate people into buying your stuff. There is a lot of this, but that is not the whole of advertising. Ads can be informational and useful. Take the previews at a theater before the feature. Those are ads, they are paid for, and a lot of people like them. If you like movies you'd probably like to know what movies are coming, it's useful for you and useful for the studios. It's a positive sum game. >Sometimes I imagine how a world without any type of commercial advertising would be... There would be more of a concentration on other ways to get messaging out. If companies couldn't buy search engine advertisements they would concentrate more on SEO. It's not "advertising" but it has the same effects. There are plenty of side ways into achieving the same propaganda goals.
- wpietri 9y agoPeople could also watch trailers on the Internet without being forced to. In fact, people already do. If your theory is correct that people want to watch trailers in theaters, then if we ban advertising (that is, the paid placement of content), then they will go on watching them because theaters will show them without being paid to do so. Although they'll likely see fewer misleading trailers for low-quality films, because theaters will no longer have a conflict of interest when deciding what to show. It's true that companies would spend more on SEO, but that's in effect a fight between search engine companies (who want to find what users want) and other companies (who want to be found whether or not it's what users want). That seems like a fair fight to me.
- chrismcb 9y agoIt would be very very very very boring. There would be very little entertainment, at least no professional entertainment. It write all be small amateurish stuff. But you wouldn't know about it, because it couldn't be advertised.
- wpietri 9y agoThat's just ridiculous. I hear about plenty of professional entertainment even though I very rarely see ads. How? Reviews, bookstore clerks, word of mouth, online recommendations, social media discussion, and event listings. Entertainment is a big industry because people want to be entertained, not because somebody told them what to watch. They would seek out entertainment in a world without ads. How do I know? Because they already do.