4 ms·
Ignoring all the ad hominem about Jonah Lehrer here -- I recall a number of other discussions on HN about how the scientific method and science are different, h
by hammock 9y ago
Ignoring all the ad hominem about Jonah Lehrer here -- I recall a number of other discussions on HN about how the scientific method and science are different, how something is broken, about the irreproducibility of studies, about reversion to the mean, etc. Don't be distracted by who authored this piece.
- ubernostrum 9y agoIf a particular person has been demonstrated in the past to be an unreliable source, it is not fallacious to say that they have been demonstrated in the past to be an unreliable source. Not every comment about a person is an example of the ad hominem fallacy.
- darkerside 9y agoWell, ad hominem is certainly a logical fallacy, and discrediting the article by discrediting the author is a clear example of it. However, logic is not the only basis in which to challenge an article. I agree the information is relevant, and I think it's worth people understanding that logical arguments are not the only ones that carry water.
- ubernostrum 9y agoCasting doubt on an article by pointing out the documented, verifiable unreliability of its author or primary source is not an example of the ad hominem fallacy. HN has an unfortunate love of the fallacy fallacy.
- darkerside 9y agoI'm not arguing that impugning the author's credibility is fallacious here. Only that it's logically fallacious. Doesn't make it wrong, but a worthy distinction nonetheless.
- conistonwater 9y agoI also don't think it's ad hominem to mention his reputation (in this case, because he earned that reputation himself), but I want to mention that this piece completely mangles its description of the whole reproducibility crisis [1] and you would have to look elsewhere for a genuine discussion of the issues. This article isn't it. [1] The key example I think is this: he talks about the "decline effect", that you do experiments and find effects that later disappear ("When the experiments are done, we still have to choose what to believe."), but completely misses the point that when a low-power experiment finds an effect (with a correspondingly large type-M error), it is not the effect that declines, the effect never existed in the first place, it is the experiment that was done poorly and should be discarded. It would be the most boring banal statement possible to say that scientific ideas can only be found by well-conducted experiments, but he doesn't do even that.