9 ms·
As usual, a bunch of nonsense by people who have no idea about this. The fundamental problem is that digital advertising is a 12-figure global industry with pr
by manigandham 9y ago
As usual, a bunch of nonsense by people who have no idea about this.
The fundamental problem is that digital advertising is a 12-figure global industry with practically 0 oversight and regulation. This is an industry that sells influence at scale. Anyone with a credit card can start changing how people think and act but there are absolutely no real consequences for bad actors.
Even the most minimal laws around who can advertise and how would radically change everything. Google has even more data than Facebook. Amazon has just as much. Your ISP has just as much. These silly little projects to chase the latest scandal will do nothing in the long run. The only way to fix anything is to regulate the core, not try and fix every little symptom that occurs.
* Before the inevitable comments, yes advertising works, yes it works on you no matter how much you think otherwise, and no adblockers dont magically solve everything.
- BrentOzar 9y ago> yes advertising works, yes it works on you no matter how much you think otherwise And even if you think it doesn’t, it works on enough other people to make it a worthwhile spend if you want to win an election or get regulation passed.
- bloak 9y agoI'm sure some advertising "works" on some people, but I've met some of the people who buy the advertising on behalf of big companies that produce consumer goods, the people who decide which advertisers get the big contracts and which campaigns get approved, and those people were not exactly of a scientific bent. I think it would be very easy to con them, and probably they get conned a lot of the time. Also, I can think of a couple of cases in which I was planning to buy a product, but changed my mind because of an advertisement for the product. In one case the advertisement made me consider a particular aspect of the product, which lead to me reevaluating and choosing an alternative product. In the other case the product was an alcoholic beverage, which I liked the taste of, but the advertisement made me embarrassed to be in any way associated with the product. In a way that proves that advertising works, but I would guess it's a lot easier to influence people against something rather than for it, even accidentally. And this is perhaps very relevant to political advertising, which often is "against" something.
- BrentOzar 9y ago> I think it would be very easy to con them, and probably they get conned a lot of the time. “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.” John Wanamaker Advertisers are used to this.
- bloak 9y agoI would guess that if John Wanamaker wasted only half of his advertising budget then he was doing better than most.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> As usual, a bunch of nonsense by people who have no idea about this This attitude is startling similar to what I heard on Wall Street during the crisis. “Of course we bet against our counterparties! They’re counterparties, not clients. If they didn’t read the prospectus they’re morons who deserved to lose their money.” When you’re providing the public with a good, arguing that non-experts can’t comment is an argument for regulation, if only to force a common language.
- manigandham 9y agoI'm not sure how you interpreted that, especially since I'm arguing for regulation. It's not that others can't comment but that their ideas (in this linked article) are poor and betray the lack of experience of the advertising industry that underlies it all. Facebook is not a new threat and focusing on it as a special instance completely hides the other major actors in the world that are doing and allowing the same thing.
- xienze 9y ago> Before the inevitable comments, yes advertising works, yes it works on you no matter how much you think otherwise, and no adblockers dont magically solve everything. So in other words, the results of pretty much every future election, even those won by Democrats, will always be in doubt, because there’s always going to be advertising and shitposting, right?
- edanm 9y ago> This is an industry that sells influence at scale. Anyone with a credit card can start changing how people think and act but there are absolutely no real consequences for bad actors. Isn't this true of almost any industry which lets you put out information? E.g. news publishing? Book publishing? Blogs? I mean, what exactly would you do, ban all communications? Maybe I missed something, but it seems like everyone just assumes that advertising is the #1 biggest influence on most people, and was used to completely change the tide of democracy, when in reality it seems to me that it's a small part of the problem, at most. I'm serious about the question btw - what would you do? You say regulate at the core. I'm not saying necessarily don't regulate (though that is where I lean) - I'm asking, what exactly do you propose?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> what would you do? 1. Break up Facebook under anti-trust law. Social network share is as dangerous as, if not more dangerous than, market share. 2. Pass an American GDPR. Consumers get an absolute right to audit and delete their data. Explicit consent is required for each instance of third-party sharing. Companies are liable to their users for breaches, with a minimum amount claimable through an easily-accessibly regulator.
- hammock 9y ago1) requires a doj investigation and high court ruling, not to mention your particular case "social media share" is without precedent
- jodrellblank 9y agoTime to set a precedent then.
- wpietri 9y agoWell, 1 could also be taken care of by Congress passing a new law. But I think the more interesting alternative is Zuck deciding to do it on his own. There's no reason he couldn't create a nonprofit and give it the "natural monopoly" pieces. That would certainly include identity and the social graph, and maybe a publishing interchange. Then Facebook could step back and compete on the non-monopoly pieces. The client, of course. But all the add-ons. Groups and events and marketplace and whatever else. Google, Twitter, Amazon, and probably Apple would probably quickly create their own social clients. And would also join some nonprofit advisory board, which would help to set protocols and standards.
- gt_ 9y agoSpot on. Advertising is a strange beast. An emphasis on taking media theory seriously would do us a lot of good. I actually think the internet has led to more awareness of the issue but the decades prior gave us a dismal trajectory. Whether advertising itself is inherently bad for us is one thing. It's abstract side effects as a are another, and that is what we are concerned with here, but we have to first accept the the realities of the course we have been on in order to correct it. Media, interface of advertising, is often thought of as frivolous. This is the same interface through which religion has enraptured it's audience for all the centuries. We can approach the issues in a rational way. Branding and advertising uses the same concepts in a different context and form. How branding and advertising affect us is a messier discussion than whether it does or not. We have accepted a life experience (emotions, desires, meanings) overwhelmingly defined by advertising. As such, our livelihoods are entangled with it and almost all of us depend on advertising to make a living. Maybe we should consider whether we are incentivized to be complacent about this core problem in the same way an individual living in an extremist religious society is incentivized to conform. I'm not sure.
- stale2002 9y ago> and no adblockers dont magically solve everything. They dont solve 'everything', but they solve quite a lot. We can tell how effective they are, by how much many ad funded website complain about them. Harm minimization is still a useful strategy.
- manigandham 9y agoThey don't solve much at all, other than blocking annoyances and improving the browsing experience. The ads blocked by most adblockers is a tiny part of the advertising you are exposed to. It's also a great signal that shows that you are an "adblock user". Everything bit of data is used and you are not special or hard to reach.
- eertami 9y ago>yes it works on you no matter how much you think otherwise, There's no need to add such preposterously inflammatory self-righteousness to your comment, it worked fine without this, but I think you just want people to call you out on it because you believe it but know many people (quite rightly) do not. And then when you (as you say, inevitably) get called out you can act like you're right because you predicted someone might point out that you're wrong. But that's not really how this works.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 9y agoWhat do you mean by "that's not really how this works"...? Whether advertising works or not has already been well proven through scientific methods and trillions in market cap so it's not about whether you believe in it, which is precisely why I added that comment. Since you seem to think it doesn't work though, I'll ask you for what your evidence is?
- eertami 9y agoI mean you don't get to act like you're right by predicting someone will point out you're wrong. Advertising does work obviously, hence the market, but it doesn't influence everyone - that's what I take issue with.
- manigandham 9y agoWhy do you take issue with that? Who is not influenced at all? And based on what exactly?
- eertami 9y agoMe, based on the fact that I am me. Your statement presumes more about people than you can possibly know.
- johnnyOnTheSpot 9y agoSo much this. Nothing has major has changed regarding Facebook.
- wyager 9y agoDeciding who is allowed to influence people via advertising by law just transfers all that power to the government. A vastly better solution is to equip people to fight advertising technologically so it’s not cost-effective.
- tomrod 9y ago> This is an industry that sells influence at scale. --- >* Before the inevitable comments, yes advertising works, yes it works on you no matter how much you think otherwise --- Show me the lift (in other words, prove it). I'm extremely dubious about any claim related to digital advertising having direct effects over a baseline. It is easy to make a claim that it changes the millieu, to appeal to second order effects. So, prove it. Show me the academic papers. Show me how those papers generalize outside of the specific economic/operation structure they studied. I mean, look at Google Search. When searching, the top link is generally an ad. My (admittedly biased "no it doesn't work on me no matter how much you claim it does") experience is that I _always_ skip the ads. Even if it is for the company I am looking to purchase from. Because I am averse to digital ads. I can't trust what the ad is selling isn't skeasy. I am not the only one who does it. So is digital advertising being supported only by people who are easy to 419/Nigerian Prince scam or something? On a tangential note note, this is Amazon's burgeoning issue with its Marketplace and third-party ripoff sellers, now that eBay isn't on top.
- wpietri 9y agoYour alternate hypothesis is that the companies collectively spending hundreds of billions of dollars per year on advertising are not getting anything for it? Why don't you take a swing at proving that?
- tomrod 9y agoFolks already have, at Microsoft, Yahoo, and Google.[0] The issue isn't showing lift, it's having sufficient power to know the test you ran isn't cherry-picked or BS. [0] https://courses.cit.cornell.edu/jl2545/4550/materials/lewisraoQJE.pdf https://courses.cit.cornell.edu/jl2545/4550/materials/lewisr... Also, the onus to prove the claim that digital marketing has an effect is not logically on the interlocutor, but on the claimant. Knowing many marketing folks across many industries, their incentives aren't usually tied to incremental lift but rather gross channel volume. So if they can cannibalize from more effective sales or advertising channels they do so, without qualms. I've heard the claim like grandparent comment has made before for years. Yet, when pushed, it is suddenly a golden cow. This is concerning, precisely due to the figure you cite of billions of dollars.
- roenxi 9y agoThere are a lot of details about Facebook that scare me, but the line between good and bad aspects is very thin. Usually it is a little easier to tease out my complaints. Influencing opinions isn't in itself a bad thing. Even being influenced to spend money isn't necessarily a bad thing. Being influenced with political ideas is on face first impressions a good idea and I might call it the first step towards understanding. The combination of scale and selectivity of the Silicon Valley majors seems like it is creeping into a difficult place though. I've always been quite interested in American politics and it is curiously hard now to identify what the message directly to voters is on Facebook. Advertising on Facebook et al is relatively private and personalised vs a newspaper where everyone gets the same ad. Also an issue here, once politicians get involved in identifying 'bad actors', there is a real risk that their political opponents get identified. Any regulation should proceed very slowly and thoughtfully.
- justonepost 9y agoyes, it’s important to look at the invisible actors as well. Facebook and google are front line brands in your face. We have to remember the invisible trackers and ISPs as well, sometimes much worse because they are not scrutinized and cooperate more with government.
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoYeah we just need to regulate who can tell people about their products, services, issues, etc. Then the world will be perfect just like it is in China where nobody says anything without th governments approval. What could go wrong?
- manigandham 9y agoYou're jumping to conclusions. We already regulate advertising by the FTC to ensure you cant outright lie in a TV commercial. The point is that digital advertising is much newer, faster and far more vast in scale. The fact that you can run ads for scams and not get caught, or just create a new account when you do, shows the issue. Facebook and every major ad network already "audit" every single creative that passes by, with rules on what you can and cant do. Clearly even they don't let things go by unchecked.
- BurningFrog 9y agoAdvertising works because speech works. Regulating speech is a cure worse than the disease.
- manigandham 9y agoThere's a difference between carefully earning an audience versus forcing your message upon billions of people within seconds. Advertising is commercial speech and already regulated by the FTC (in the US) which is why you can't say false things for an ad. The problem is that it has not been updated to deal with modern digital advertising's speed and scale.
- rafiki6 9y agoHere's an inevitable comment since you make such an authoritative statement with 0 ounce of evidence to back it up. Internet Advertising is not as effective as you believe it is. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/06/a-dangerous-question-does-internet-advertising-work-at-all/372704/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/06/a-dange... Advertising works when it leaves an impression or memories on you: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/08/why-good-advertising-works-even-when-you-think-it-doesnt/244252/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/08/why-goo... That's what makes good advertising good. The medium also matters tremendously. Internet advertising only really works when you don't know what you're looking for to begin with, which is rarely the case as most human behavior when it comes to the internet is intentional (i.e. I search on Google for "plates", that's why Google AdWords shows me sponsored links for plates) http://journals.ama.org/doi/abs/10.1509/jmr.11.0503?code=amma-site http://journals.ama.org/doi/abs/10.1509/jmr.11.0503?code=amm... Moral of the story? Complicated psychological phenomena are complicated and let's not oversimplify them to fit our narrative.
- richforrester 9y agoThere's different types of advertising though. And it's not necessarily blatant advertising that's the issue. A lot of ads are designed differently. Article form. Informative video content. A promoted Facebook post that ends up in your feed. Really any type of content that's pretending not to be an ad. That's advertising too. And that too, influences people. About tonnes of things. Not necessarily products. And think about it inversely too. If there's 2 groups of people posting ads: if group 1 has more money, they can effectively push group 2 out. These too are part of the problem.
- jack9 9y ago> 0 ounce of evidence to back it up The same principle used when TV lineups are advertised on the TV network channels themselves, is what advertising capitalizes on best. Brand awareness has plenty of psychological evidence behind it. The number don't lie when you get put on the premium channels (or the Google Play recommended top 10). Ads aren't usually effective at doing what advertisers want (more than brand awareness or opportunity hurdles), which isn't a shocker. Advertisers get sold services by other people in advertising.
- phjesusthatguy3 9y ago> The fundamental problem is that ~3 billion people have subscribed to the newsletter of the abyss, and the abyss has friends with which it shares it's insights.
- verylittlemeat 9y agoThose inevitable comments about advertising not working come up every time for a reason. Advertising is a classic example of the prisoner's dilemma. All that money being spent is an arms race, not an indicator of the power of advertising. The idea that money controls how people think is appealing when you remove all agency from the population and just assume they're naive sheep but that's a self-serving perspective. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma#In_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma#In_econom... Seeing as how you work in marketing and advertising I'm not sure anyone should take you at your word. “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
- manigandham 9y agoAs your other comment showed, "status" and "status-quo" are just as important. A brand will spend money to signal that they have the success to be able to spend that money, something that has had close to a century of study. You can also see this in how Silicon Valley companies "signal" through fundraising, which is just another form of advertising. You have an interesting perspective but I assure you that it is not new. Please don't take my word for it, instead here's a good article since you're referring to economics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signalling_(economics)
- manigandham 9y agoA day after this comment, a perfect story underlining all of it: "How Facebook Helps Shady Advertisers Pollute the Internet" https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-03-27/ad-scammers-need-suckers-and-facebook-helps-find-them https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-03-27/ad-scamme...