3 ms·
Mastodon does everything signed and unencrypted. This includes followers-only and private messages. I can't in good faith recommend Mastodon.
by snvzz 9y ago
Mastodon does everything signed and unencrypted. This includes followers-only and private messages.
I can't in good faith recommend Mastodon.
- kodablah 9y agoPardon my naivete towards Mastodon, but unencrypted at rest (i.e. an implementation thing) or in transit (i.e. TLS not supported in the protocol)?
- slipstream- 9y agoUnencrypted at rest.
- detaro 9y agoNot end-to-end encrypted. TLS is recommended (or even required, not sure), but the instances involved can see the contents of private messages.
- kodablah 9y agoOut of curiosity, if the messages themselves were encrypted externally, would this solve most people's concerns? Or is the metadata that is leaked (I assume to/from, timestamp, size) also unacceptable? Also curious for those that have this beef with Mastodon, would transit anonymity help alleviate some of the concerns w/ data transparency?
- snvzz 9y agoNote metadata includes where someone is posting from. Connect to post something without encryption means your location is revealed to anybody observing the network. This is indeed dangerous.
- daveid 9y ago>Connect to post something without encryption means your location is revealed to anybody observing the network. Where are you taking this from? You think connecting to your Mastodon server you have an account on somehow broadcasts to the whole network?
- snvzz 9y agoIf a message is sent through an unencrypted connection, anybody sniffing the network gets: - Your message - Your account name - Your ip address (thus location) - The time at which this happens If the message is sent through an encrypted connection, but the federation connection between the servers is unencrypted, a powerful enough observer could still deduce the above.
- zaarn 9y agoA powerful enough observer will be able to observe two of the three properties no matter if TLS is used or not. Most Mastodon servers have TLS, exceptions usually included instances deployed to localhost. Mastodon doesn't technically require it but all clients I've seen do and the web interface relies on some features that are only available in a trusted context (HTTPS and localhost) I don't really see the problem though, which instance you sign up to is up to you. You can sign up to a HTTP-only instance if you want. The privacy of your data is in the hands of your local administrator more than any powerful observer (and servers you send messages too, like with email, for which all your complains are valid too since it functions similarly).
- snvzz 9y ago>Mastodon doesn't technically require it That's a serious issue. If plaintext is allowed, then expect getting people to downgrade to plaintext will be trivial, because "it just works". It's a serious mistake, but a well understood one by today. Mastodon is relatively new, and they should have known better than to do this.
- tscs37 9y agoWhy does it need to be signed and encrypted? We have PGP, Signal and Co. for that. Mastodon is a microblogging service, it's perfectly fine to not sign all messages (though ActivityPub does support signing) Mastodon is as trustworthy as your instance administrator, so you'll have to find a place where you can trust your admin.
- snvzz 9y ago>Why does it need to be signed and encrypted? We have PGP, Signal and Co. for that Note it IS signed. It's just not encrypted. It needs to be encrypted, too, because it's the reasonable expectation when private messages and followers-only messages exist. Additionally... should I be some location and post something, I'd be broadcasting my location, even if that isn't intended. All because it's not encrypted, where it should be. >Mastodon is as trustworthy as your instance administrator, so you'll have to find a place where you can trust your admin. That'd be true if it was peer-to-peer encrypted. But it is not; all messages are plaintext on the wire.
- daveid 9y ago>should I be some location and post something, I'd be broadcasting my location, even if that isn't intended Can you tell me how and where you would broadcast your location via Mastodon? There are no geolocation features in Mastodon. >It needs to be encrypted, too, because it's the reasonable expectation when private messages and followers-only messages exist. Has anyone attempted to encrypt a message to 64,000 recipients yet? I don't think restricting a message to followers is an applicable model for e2ee. Direct messages yes, I can see the point in that.
- snvzz 9y ago>Can you tell me how and where you would broadcast your location via Mastodon? For a network observer, your IP address, associated with your account name. >I don't think restricting a message to followers is an applicable model for e2ee But requiring TLS between clients and servers, and between servers (for the federation), is applicable. >Direct messages yes, I can see the point in that. The average joe expects direct messages to really be private. If they're not, that's bad.
- swiley 9y agoAll of the messages I post on Mastodon and twitter are intended to be public, just like the things I write on my website. End to end encryption would only make things harder without actually protecting anyone's privacy.
- snvzz 9y agoSure, but does that include followers-only and private messages? Also, lack of encryption allows for selective censorship on the fly.
- confounded 9y agoDevelopment resources are pretty limited, for now it seems fine to use the right tool for the right job; there are plenty of E2EE chat services that can be used, and if there’s significant interest, a norm for favoring one will likely develop (like with imgur and Reddit, for example).
- snvzz 9y agoFair. In this case, do the right thing and disable private messages. Either offer it properly or do not offer it at all. It's irresponsible otherwise.
- eitland 9y agoOh come on! Twitter by default broadcasts everything you write to the entire world! Why should open source solutions be held to a higher standard?
- snvzz 9y ago>Twitter by default broadcasts everything you write to the entire world! To be fair, at least your connection to twitter is encrypted. This means that an observer can't tell it's your IP that's posting on twitter as you. That is, your location. Thus twitter is actually better. A court order would be needed for them to disclose IP addreses, at least.
- daveid 9y ago>To be fair, at least your connection to twitter is encrypted What!? Are you talking about TLS? Because this is true for Mastodon as well then.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoThere is some discussion on this matter that you should engage with: https://github.com/tootsuite/mastodon/issues/928 https://github.com/tootsuite/mastodon/issues/928