4 ms·
In Germany we had the case of Dr. Andreas Shell who spent five years fighting Shell oil company. He had registered shell.de and used it primarily as a family we
by weinzierl 9y ago
In Germany we had the case of Dr. Andreas Shell who spent five years fighting Shell oil company.
He had registered shell.de and used it primarily as a family website but also offered a translation service [1].
The case went to the Federal Court of Justice (German: Bundesgerichtshof, BGH), the hightest court in the system of ordinary jurisdiction in Germany. Andres Shell lost and the reasoning was that the "First Come, First Served Principle" can be overruled by the "Priority Principle", which says that the better known party has priority.
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/19980204065557/http://www.shell.de:80/ https://web.archive.org/web/19980204065557/http://www.shell....
- justherefortart 9y agoThat's pathetic.
- AckSyn 9y agoThis is one example of many about how german law is ridiculous.
- pmarreck 9y ago> can be overruled by the "Priority Principle", which says that the better known party has priority So basically, the entity with the most money. Got it. I'm impressed by many German things (note: firstborn American and all my ancestors are German), but not this.
- strathmeyer 9y agoIn America they just ruled that URLs were property and therefor could not be stolen. Never understood why the plaintiffs didn't just steal the judges' phone numbers.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoI can understand the ruling. If you read "shell.de", do you think of Andreas Shell the attorney or Shell the mineral oil company? The name has been trademarked for eternity, why should trademarks used as domain names be treated any different? Anyone can use a name, but only for the thing it represents, German law has always been applied that way. The edge case is Deutsche Telekom and their sprawling claim on magenta, not this.
- azinman2 9y agoBecause the Internet wasn’t created for trademarks. People can have the same name as a trademark, which likely goes back much further before the trademark was created.
- PostOnce 9y agoWell, suppose your site is "foobar.de" and you have been running a business from it for 10 years, and tomorrow, a rich man spends 100 million euros on advertising his new business Foobar Inc, and is overnight the better known party -- what kind of backwards legal system would hold that money trumps all other rights? First come first serve makes more sense, so long as it's not trademark infringement (i.e. he's not selling oil) on a preexisting trademark.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoThe pragmatic approach would be for the smaller party to change names. This actually happened. Google couldn't operate Gmail under that name in Germany because a direct mailing company had registered it before and had been operating under that name for years. Eventually the domain changed hands, but that was only sometime after 2010.
- PostOnce 9y agoPragmatic for the rich only. The disadvantaged party now has to foot the bill for changing names and thereby losing customers who may not again find them. Why should a society give that sort of obsequious deference to the wealthy? What benefit to we gain? It's not as though shelloil.de or the German language equivalent would be so hard to find, or cost them any money or business at all, since no one goes to shell.de to buy oil directly -- it's pure vanity and cost some man his moral right. It's disgraceful. I would not want to live in a society where being rich gives you more rights, not just in practice, but in law, if that's in fact the case. Further, I scoff at this concept of pragmatism. Life is more than pragmatics, pragmatism can easily become a synonym for cruelty, as it has in the past, whether that's consumer safety, government funded medical, animal welfare, or any other situation that was previously dictated by economic pragmatism, to the detriment humanity.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's very sad.