6 ms·
I'm curious. You say we're flying down the slope. That's something I hear often, how our civil liberties are being rapidly threatened. Is this actually the cas
by andrepd 9y ago
I'm curious. You say we're flying down the slope. That's something I hear often, how our civil liberties are being rapidly threatened.
Is this actually the case? Removing firearms videos from YouTube seems perfectly reasonable to me. The internet is big; I'm sure you can find elsewhere to host your videos. Is a company taking steps to distance themselves from such a contentious issue equal to "flying down the slippery slope of authoritarianism"? As always when I hear these panicked comments, I fail to see how this is true.
- sergiotapia 9y ago>gleeful authoritarians each with their cute idea of how individuals are best controlled.
- mindslight 9y ago> how our civil liberties are being rapidly threatened It's not that they're being threatened, it's that they're actively being taken away. Society may react to this loss of liberty by restoring it through alternate approaches. Or, it may not. > Removing firearms videos from YouTube seems perfectly reasonable to me I mean yes, obviously there are plenty of people who want censorship for one reason or another, otherwise it wouldn't be happening. So one's own comfort with censorship is not evidence that censorship is not happening. > Is a company taking steps to distance themselves ... It's what they're doing, not why. Despite the trope, evil never shows up twirling a mustache.
- adamsea 9y agoJohn Bolton has a mustache ...
- freeone3000 9y agoI think the problem with this is that the censorship is invoked by companies against individuals, in the broad strokes, not by the government. It's hard to convince the public that corporations have power approaching or surpassing governments nowadays...
- hanbura 9y agoThat's such an often repeated and weird argument. Censorship isn't dangerous because of who is doing it but because of what it does. Censorship inhibits the spread of information and ideas, thus inhibiting the democratic process. YouTube is effectively a monopoly. You can upload your video elsewhere, but next to nobody will see it. That gives YouTube equal censorship power as a government censor. We should be equally appalled by it.
- gmueckl 9y agoThe punlic has undersood that state censorship is bad. But the new censorship systen has a layer of indirection built in in that companies are going to do the censoring instead baswd on voluntary terms of service and stuff. This is a pattern that seems little understood and therefore encounters less opposition.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoYou want to find a video about something. Where, dare I ask, will you go to look? The idea that you can find somewhere else to host your videos sounds comforting, until you realize that nobody will be there to watch them.
- mattmanser 9y agoIt's not your right to have access to YouTube's audience. Promote it yourself.
- wallace_f 9y agoIs it your right to have access to purchase services from your water/sewer utility? What about the offices of the NRA, or those of the ACLU, or you're another civil rights org and the water company's ownership doesn't agree with their movement? At what point does a business/service used by the public actually need to serve the public? If Google has a virtual monopoly on a service, why should they not be regulated as such?
- toofy 9y agoFirst thing first, this is a shining example why we should be trying to decentralize and why we should be trying to build diversity in how many providers we use to distribute content. This said, I dont think any of us have some inherent right to an audience which someone else built. And I’m not sure where this mistaken belief started. We have the right -in the US- to stand on a street corner and say stuff, but not the right that someone else has to go and round up 30,000 people and force them to listen to us. I think the right to utility services usually comes from contractual agreements between companies and the localities they serve in exchange for those companies usually exclusive roles in servicing those areas and they usually agree to being heavily regulated. If we’re going to be a country which is heavily invested in private property rights, the companies will _almost_ always have a choice in what products they decide to distribute and which products they choose to not distribute. I find it strange to imply google has a monopoly on serving videos, they may have a large and readily available audience, but they’ve spent a rather large amount of time and energy building this audience and the infrastructure needed to accommodate. It’s not like it’s difficult to go set up a website and serve videos, it’s trivial in labor and trivial in cost. People seem to be implying they feel like they’re entitled to an audience that someone else built and I think that’s a strange thing to believe. Again, let’s make other video services more popular rather than pretend YouTube is somehow the only way on the entire internet to serve videos.
- conradev 9y agoJay Freeman (saurik) gave a talk that takes these isolated incidents ("this doesn't seem too bad") and puts them all together to paint a really disturbing picture: https://air.mozilla.org/privacy-lab-orchid/ https://air.mozilla.org/privacy-lab-orchid/ It's one of my favorite talks, and I love the format: each slide is a news article.
- brohee 9y agoTalk starts at 2:57, the introduction was dragging on and dragging on some more...
- syshum 9y agoThe road to Authoritarian dystopia is paved with "companies taking steps to distance themselves from such a contentious issues" >>Removing firearms videos from YouTube seems perfectly reasonable to me. I am sure Gun Rights are also no a pressing issue for you, or you may even be Anti-Gun Ownership by private citizens... Let me ask you then, would you feel the same if this was an Issue you cared Deeply about. Pick a Social topic the you care about, then image if You Tube censored that topic from their platform.. What is your reaction. //Edit to add, before you Paint me as some conservative, I am Libertarian. In the words of Austin Peterson: “I want gay couples to be able to protect their marijuana fields with fully automatic rifles"
- chrismcb 9y agoI think your comment underlines the fact that we are on the slippery slope. You think it is OK for you tube to supress free speech, presumably because you don't like that speech either. So what is next to go? Well it looks life the personal kmeetips, mixed connections is got it the door. What next? What else don't you like that you think it will be fine for them to ban. While the internet is a big place, this like SESTA will definitely put a cool on things.
- bloaf 9y agohttps://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/501/case.html https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/501/case.htm... >...we have recognized that the preservation of a free society is so far dependent upon the right of each individual citizen to receive such literature as he himself might desire... can those people who live in or come to Chickasaw be denied freedom of press and religion simply because a single company has legal title to all the town? For it is the State's contention that the mere fact that all the property interests in the town are held by a single company is enough to give that company power, enforceable by a state statute, to abridge these freedoms. We do not agree that the corporation's property interests settle the question... Ownership does not always mean absolute dominion. The more an owner, for his advantage, opens up his property for use by the public in general, the more do his rights become circumscribed by the statutory and constitutional rights of those who use it.
- Khaine 9y agoFirst they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Socialist. Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Trade Unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me. Or in this case, maybe it should be: First they came for the firearms, and I did not speak out— Because I did not like firearms Then they came for the sex workers and I did not speak out— Because I was not a sex worker (or used them) Then they came for something I cared about and there was no one left to speak for me. Thats the thing about the slippery slope. Restrictions start with things many people find objectionable and then slowly ratchet up to cover more mainstream things.
- elsjaako 9y agoThen they came for something I cared about and I went to the video sharing website the gun and porn people set up. This isn't government oppression, there will be alternates to the services offered.
- Khaine 9y agoVideo hosting is a natural monopoly. It costs so much to store and stream videos, combined with the network effect means its incredibly difficult for effective competition. I hope that you are right that natural competitors will show up, but like a facebook competitor I suspect we will be waiting for a long time.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoIt's really surprising to see that even here people can't see where this is heading. I thought it was in a hacker's most basic instinct to be able to see how tiny little, almost insignificant, steps can lead to something big. But fine, maybe you haven't been paying attention to the other parts of this. For a start, have you talked to people outside of your bubble? Do you know what "web browser" means to most people out there? It means Google. Honestly, go out and ask people. The Internet is not such a big place any more. It is very centralised. You might think that if the worst happens you can just host videos yourself but I think you would be mistaken. To do that you need to use one of a small handful of CDNs. Good luck trying to host your own server now. It's been the case for a while that most people have had asymmetric lines, ie. a poor upload speed, so we ended up going the centralisation route. Add to that the loss of net neutrality and the prevalence of "devices" as opposed to general purpose computers and I would ask you: do you still fail to see how the slope is true?
- lovemenot 9y agoI believe many people reading this thread would have already seen first-hand the capability of new technologies to disrupt existing power structures and they'd have no problem extrapolating to present-future scenarios. As powerful as the four-horsemen might now have become, they'll surely become past-their-prime IBMs or Microsofts in subsequent generations. In this context, a responsibility of technologists is to provide another round of disruption - sooner than the last - in order to prevent incumbents from getting too entrenched.
- kadenshep 9y ago>It's really surprising to see that even here people can't see where this is heading. I thought it was in a hacker's most basic instinct to be able to see how tiny little, almost insignificant, steps can lead to something big. We do. We exist in objective reality. The reality is you're engaging in a narrative that has direct, practical negations in the real world. In front of your face. They've existed for decades. Half the people who claim to be "hackers" on here couldn't exploit a wet paper bag. They're just american centrists, full of "acksually"-ism's who happen to write code. I mean the fact that PG's writing is considered interesting or note-worthy should be your first sign that this community isn't terribly academic in any field, really. >do you still fail to see how the slope is true? Yeah. I guess I missed the part where you kind of just lightly touched on different characteristics of the current technological landscape and then just jumped right back into your conclusion.