3 ms·
I think you'd be surprised how much more similar Google is to these things. They absolutely bought and bribes their way into their monopoly reach, by paying to
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I think you'd be surprised how much more similar Google is to these things. They absolutely bought and bribes their way into their monopoly reach, by paying to be the default on everyone's browsers, having other software bake Google Toolbar into their install wizards (later replaced by Chrome), etc.
Also, given the HTTPS Everywhere push (mostly led by Google), usually only sites like Google and Facebook get to see your traffic, ISPs get cut out of most of the deal.
And for most people, Google or Facebook is, in fact, their gateway to the Internet: They get everywhere they go through one of these two captive environments.
Finally, telecoms are already subject to significant regulation, even with the recently repealed privacy rule, no, ISPs can't just go selling your search history, marketing by certain political groups to the contrary. (Whereas Google and Facebook both, effectively, can.) Meanwhile, tech companies have operated with little to no regulation at all, and unlike telecoms, which have a whole federal agency dedicated to regulating them, tech companies' reach isn't restrained by much outside of the FTC, which isn't even fully staffed, and definitely isn't doing their jobs.
- drawkbox 9y agoAny big company has to lobby a bit but the ISPs only do that and do have local monopolies with false competition so you can't really choose another competitor in many places. ISPs haven't built any market products people want to use that they will willingly give up their data for. Google and Facebook are ad networks that tracking is inherent because they are free and they make their money from ads. ISPs are for internet access and privacy, you pay them so they don't sell your data. Now they want to be Google/Facebook without building a search engine or social network. They bought their monopoly with bribes so they could become ad networks/tracking networks. People have the expectation that their data isn't being sold by their ISP currently, but they are and it is fully legal now. Google and Facebook aside, do you want your ISP tracking you and selling your private data?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoGoogle and ISPs both have monopolies, but ISPs have local monopolies and Google has global monopolies. In 2017, Google wasn't just "a" lobbyist, they were "the biggest" lobbyist, dwarfing any ISP's. When you say "Google and Facebook aside", it feels like you are literally missing the entire point... You have an elephant in your sinking boat, and you're worried about the weight of the dog.
- drawkbox 9y agoWe know that the companies are big and possibly seen as monopolies, the question was still unanswered though. Do you want your ISP tracking you and selling your private data? Do you think that is the place of an ISP? If you do like your ISP tracking and selling your private data, we'll have to agree to disagree. I think there is no place for ISPs to be evading privacy and selling your data. It isn't about competition. I expect tracking from free services I am not paying for that my data is the product. I expect tracking from companies that make their money from ad/marketing to do that. I do not expect tracking and privacy invasions from my ISP, my front door to the internet. My ISP is also not a small dog, it is a massive media company and a monopoly in addition to my provider. At least with Google/Facebook you can use DuckDuckGo/bing/etc or other social networks and block Google/Facebook if desired. I can't route around my ISP, there is no local competition and what competition there is amounts to false competition. From the FCCs own data, most people only have 1 or maybe 2 real competitive ISPs in their area and virtually no competition at 100Mbps, zero options for gigabit [1]. I can easily walk around Google and Facebook and block them, my ISP is a big big mean dog because I am paying for my privacy invasion, services that run on the internet are corgis and they are free but fun to play so they attracted people's data by providing something people want. They do both lobby but that is primarily because ISPs and others do so heavily and you must compete at that level or lose. > FCC report finds almost no broadband competition at 100Mbps speeds [1] > Even at 25Mbps, 43 percent of the US had zero ISPs or just one. [1] [1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/fcc-report-finds-almost-no-broadband-competition-at-100mbps-speeds/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/fcc-r...
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt's funny that you link Jon Brodkin, because I was going to point out all of what gave you this erroneous impression was from a select handful of media properties which have incredibly close ties with Google... You ignored that Google and Facebook are also the front door to the Internet, and that you cannot evade their privacy violations by just "not using them". You've also continued to not address that Google is a much larger monopoly than any company you're upset about. Adding all of the ISPs together would not even approach the scale of threat provided by Google, in money or reach. You've seemed to decide that violating your privacy and security is okay for some companies and not others without really a reasonable distinction how. Especially given that Google and Facebook are both media companies (and ISPs), and so are Comcast and Verizon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]