3 ms·
There were no Constitutional grounds to overturn the lower court ruling. There were, however, numerous procedural grounds to do so. The Constitution says expl
by gamblor956 9y ago
There were no Constitutional grounds to overturn the lower court ruling. There were, however, numerous procedural grounds to do so.
The Constitution says explicitly that the purpose of copyright is to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts". I'm pretty sure that letting someone copyright a whole genre will have the exact opposite effect.
A reasonable person could argue the opposite: that allowing a person to copyright a genre would provide a terrific incentive to create entirely new genres, opening up far more modes of expression than a single new song would do.
- krapp 9y ago>A reasonable person could argue the opposite: that allowing a person to copyright a genre would provide a terrific incentive to create entirely new genres, opening up far more modes of expression than a single new song would do. But, no new incentive to create new genres as a means of creative expression will exist, that don't exist already. Genre uniqueness, itself, has little value as a creative endeavor - most of the genres that exist build on prior work, and are similar to the genres they transformed. Once companies have laid claim to all existing musical genres, styles, themes, beats, feels, etc., The purpose of genre will become the manufacture of legally distinctive identities, rather than meaningful forms of creative expression.