5 ms·
I’m like you, I’m in the UK anyway but even in the US I wouldn’t be into guns, but find the more technical and historically oriented channels like Forgotten Wea
by simonh 9y ago
I’m like you, I’m in the UK anyway but even in the US I wouldn’t be into guns, but find the more technical and historically oriented channels like Forgotten Weapons fascinating. If it gets shut down it will be a real shame.
But the pro-gun lobby in the US are bringing all of this on themselves. The level of gun violence in the US is appalling, and is clearly becomming unacceptable to many and possibly a majority of Americans. Every attempt to mitigate it is actively opposed by the gun lobby, often with patently ridiculous measures designed to be ineffective. So I have no sympathy for the gun lobby. If they want to own guns and preserve an armed culture I think its entirely reasonable for the rest of America to expect them to do so safely. If they can’t come up with an effective regulatory system they can live with and which protects the public from gun violence, then I think they won’t have a moral leg to stand on when the rest of the country takes their toys away from them. Guns with effective and safe regulation, or no guns at all and the responsibility for coming up with what that safe and effective regulation is sholod fall on gun owners. Here in the UK we went with pretty much no guns at all. I hope America keeps its traditions and culture, but not at any price when that price is paid in blood.
- ams6110 9y ago> But the pro-gun lobby in the US are bringing all of this on themselves. I wrote a much longer reply but decided that arguing this topic here is probably not appropriate. Suffice it to say that the notion that the "pro-gun lobby" is in any way opposed to safe ownership of guns or supports mass shootings or other criminal gun violence is absurd.
- DanBC 9y agoOne of the most vocal pro-gun owners on HN would repeatedly make posts supporting mass murder whenever the topic of laws to reduce murder by gun were discussed. He'd say that gun owners would kill many people if guns were made illegal. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11604135 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11604135 > And let's be clear, in this putative Civil War 2.0, we're threatening to kill gun-grabbers wholesale and retail, with guns being one of the least effective means when compared to tactics like killing Blue cities. People kill other people, guns are inanimate objects. There are like 15 posts very similar to this, although some are flagged.
- eropple 9y ago'hga was also the poster who was banned for (too late, IMO) telling a Jewish person to "self-deport" because he didn't want them--you know, (((them)))--in his country. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13056816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13056816 He offered elsewhere a clearly reasonable return to the "pre-1965 demographics of the US." And so very positively spoke of "moving past the concept of equality before the law." And he isn't alone. There are some real scary correlations between the gun-fetishists--and I say that having grown up around firearms; I am not scared of them any more than I am scared of any other recklessly used tool with a toxic culture surrounding them--and generally toxic and antisocial worldviews. But the causation is not the guns, to be clear; the machismo-driven culture that leads to the guns is the cause.
- luma 9y agoExcept when sensible restrictions on gun buying are propsed, that same lobby loses their mind and immediately opposes it. The NRA is no longer a sporting association, they are a far-right political lobby and are finally being recognized as such. They can change this and get back to their original mission, or continue their current collision course with the rest of America who want sensible gun policy.
- mieseratte 9y ago> Except when sensible restrictions on gun buying are propsed Because every "compromise" gets turned into something else to be attacked. That "Gun show loophole" was an explicit concession, that is something offered in compromise, is now being turned into something to be attacked and revoked. There is no "compromise" - the goal is ban and confiscation. We've seen it time and time again. How many times must one put their hand on the iron before they realize it burns?
- kybernetikos 9y ago> There is no "compromise" - the goal is ban and confiscation. We've seen it time and time again. What makes you say this? Even in heavy gun control countries, some forms of shooting (e.g. pest control, hunting, target) and gun ownership are still generally legal. Exactly what gets made legal and illegal is precisely what is being debated, but I'd be incredibly surprised if you ended up with total ban and confiscation. I think a compromise is exactly what everyone wants.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> but I'd be incredibly surprised if you ended up with total ban and confiscation. Haven't some heavy gun control regimes in the US ended up as de-facto total bans? IIRC, one city "allowed" legal gun ownership (or maybe just legal handgun ownership), but it required police approval, which was almost never granted.
- jkaplowitz 9y ago
- simonh 9y agoI am in no way suggesting that the NRA, or gun owners in general support mass shootings. I am saying that if they want to keep their guns, the responsibility fall on them to come up with a regulatory regime that actually works to prevent such things happening with such appalling regularity. If the gun lobby comes up with effective regulations that preserve their interests and that also work, this problem wouldn't exist. This is their problem to fix.
- akkat 9y agoI don't know what the NRA is doing but it looks like it is working. Here is a graph showing a long term decline in gun deaths in America. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c6/Gun_Deaths_by_Year%2C_Australia%2C_America.pdf/page1-800px-Gun_Deaths_by_Year%2C_Australia%2C_America.pdf.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c6/Gu...
- toomanybeersies 9y agoForgotten Weapons is in a good position where he has enough viewers, and enough Patreon supporters, that he could move to another platform (or host his own) and would probably survive. The sad thing is that it will stop other, new creators from being discovered.
- simonh 9y agoIt will probably also kill the growth of the channel. I got into Forgotten Weapons and InRange TV last year, but if they hadn't been on Youtube I'd probably never have found them. It's a terrible shame, they make great, highly informative content.
- Theodores 9y agoTobacco is the analogy, you don't want to see people smoking on TV and in films but you would not want a documentary on the history of film to be banned just because some of the actors in it are smoking. Regarding main story, I used to work in broadcasting and it was clear from the oscilloscopes when some porn was on air or on a tape. This was not an exact science, but experienced engineers knew what the 'scope was telling them. This was a long time ago and I am sure Google would have machine learned porn a long time ago. No evidence for that but I doubt it is a recent innovation. Therefore this enabling of the feature that enforces the Terms of Service is probably due to changes up ahead in the legal landscape and not because Google suddenly decided they wanted clean servers.
- sempron64 9y agoCould you elaborate on "clear from the oscilloscopes"? That sounds interesting.