3 ms·
None of those are copyrightable elements. Nor is the concept of "style", because it has no recognisable legal or musical definition. Musical copyright exists
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
None of those are copyrightable elements.
Nor is the concept of "style", because it has no recognisable legal or musical definition.
Musical copyright exists primarily in lyrics and melody for the writing ("publishing") component, and in a specific reproducible recording for the mechanical distribution component (which can include the entire song, or a small sample).
Elements that cannot usually be copyrighted include: vocal stylings, bass lines, production and engineering tricks, chord sequences, rhythms, arrangement structures.
Sometimes, very rarely, any of these can be considered distinctive enough to be the primary element that defines a song. But that's a very tough case to argue, and most suits that try it fail spectacularly.
In fact a lot of pop is made by knowingly and deliberately copying elements from various source songs and mixing them up to create a new song.
So there is absolutely no practical way this ruling can stand. If it did, it would open the industry to a wave of law suits that would reduce it to chaos.
- tmuir 9y agoI agree, which is why I used the undeniable existence of similarities between these two songs to lay out the absurdity of the idea lisper was floating.
- pdkl95 9y ago> a lot of pop is made by knowingly and deliberately copying elements from various source songs One of the defining characteristics of "pop" music is the reuse of major structural elements like the primary harmonic progression (e.g. the infamous "4 chords"[1]). Listeners that do not have a lot of music theory knowledge and experience can still follow along with the "plot" of the song because it reuses simple structures they already know. Appreciation of more complex harmonic structure and other unique features requires a lot more experience with complex types of music theory. As with all art/writing, knowing your intended audience is important. If the audience includes people without music experience/training, limiting the "vocabulary" top what they know is absolutely necessary. For a very good explanation of this that includes examples, see this[2] video essay. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M33cRNx3ohI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M33cRNx3ohI
- tmuir 9y agoIn the case of Blurred Lines, wasn't Pharrell forced to admit that he was listening to the Marvin Gaye song, around the time of the recording of Blurred Lines? That doesn't prove causation on it's own, but it does seem to blur the lines of such absolutist statements as those you have made.
- Lazare 9y ago> it does seem to blur the lines of such absolutist statements as those you have made. I could not disagree more. Again, we're talking about copyright, and copyright covers a specific expression of an idea. The fact that Pharrell was listening to an earlier, similar work is irrelevant, because listening to an earlier work around the time you wrote a new work doesn't mean your work is the same as the earlier work, any more than eating pizza around the time you wrote a new work means your work is literally a pizza. > That doesn't prove causation on it's own I think you're using the wrong framework here; this isn't a reverse engineering case. We don't need to prove that the authors of "Blurred Lines" had been exposed to "Got To Give It Up"; it's so popular and influential we can just assume it. What needs to be proven is that "Blurred Lines" contains copywritable elements from "Got To Give It Up". And contrary to the majority opinion of the appeals court, it seems quite clear it doesn't.
- tmuir 9y agoIt is ironic that you mention reverse engineering, because all of my arguments here are based in details of the most famous copyright infraction cases. The prevailing logic in this thread, whether correct or not, if that is even a quantifiable measure, is that copyright is exactly, precisely, without exception, "a specific expression of an idea", and by defining copyright so cleanly, they can similarly define what qualifies as infringement of copyright. Where this idea meets stiff resistance is when it is contrasted with all of the precedent set by high profile infraction cases, such as George Harrison/The Chiffons, The Verve/The Rolling Stones, Ray Parker Jr./Huey Lewis. Each of these, in its own way, demonstrates that there is always more context involved than people making simple absolutist statements would have you believe.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y ago> bass lines Queen would beg to differ.