6 ms·
> me wonder whether we’re on — or at least near — a slippery slope. What's with the reservation? Feel that wind in your hair? We are currently flying down the
by mindslight 9y ago
> me wonder whether we’re on — or at least near — a slippery slope.
What's with the reservation?
Feel that wind in your hair? We are currently flying down the slope, cheered on by the pantheon of gleeful authoritarians each with their cute idea of how individuals are best controlled.
The only question is whether we'll have a chance to stop after the centralized surveillance industry has been fully coopted for their goals, or whether the momentum will carry us all the way to oppressing the refuge of Free p2p communications.
- IAmEveryone 9y agoSlippery Slope was coined to describe a logical fallacy. It's funny how things sometimes turn out... Specifically, it's not a meaningful argument because it's far too broad, and applies to more or less anything. Example: "Now they're just banning asbestos and lead. But next year it'll be wood and orange juice!"
- Joeboy 9y ago> Slippery Slope was coined to describe a logical fallacy. Is that true? I always assumed the fallacy was named for the already existing expression.
- wjn0 9y ago> Is that true? I always assumed the fallacy was named for the already existing expression. Funny! I'd never thought of that. For those curious, Wiktionary says that it's actually from the Latin, "fallere", to deceive [1]. [1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fallacy https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/fallacy
- jpttsn 9y agoWho could be against saving the forests and decreasing harmful sugar consumption?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fastball 9y agoSarcasm?
- gnicholas 9y ago> What's with the reservation? I phrased it this way to avoid outcry from people who disagree that we’re on the slope — but who cannot disagree that we must at least be near the slope.
- blitmap 9y agoIt stinks that people are allowed to create legislation like this which is almost certainly extreme/careless in how it affects companies/citizens, yet we must be reserved with how we call out the issues. We have lost footing on this slope.
- andrepd 9y agoI'm curious. You say we're flying down the slope. That's something I hear often, how our civil liberties are being rapidly threatened. Is this actually the case? Removing firearms videos from YouTube seems perfectly reasonable to me. The internet is big; I'm sure you can find elsewhere to host your videos. Is a company taking steps to distance themselves from such a contentious issue equal to "flying down the slippery slope of authoritarianism"? As always when I hear these panicked comments, I fail to see how this is true.
- sergiotapia 9y ago>gleeful authoritarians each with their cute idea of how individuals are best controlled.
- mindslight 9y ago> how our civil liberties are being rapidly threatened It's not that they're being threatened, it's that they're actively being taken away. Society may react to this loss of liberty by restoring it through alternate approaches. Or, it may not. > Removing firearms videos from YouTube seems perfectly reasonable to me I mean yes, obviously there are plenty of people who want censorship for one reason or another, otherwise it wouldn't be happening. So one's own comfort with censorship is not evidence that censorship is not happening. > Is a company taking steps to distance themselves ... It's what they're doing, not why. Despite the trope, evil never shows up twirling a mustache.
- adamsea 9y agoJohn Bolton has a mustache ...
- freeone3000 9y agoI think the problem with this is that the censorship is invoked by companies against individuals, in the broad strokes, not by the government. It's hard to convince the public that corporations have power approaching or surpassing governments nowadays...
- 9y ago
- dilap 9y agoseems not unlikely that anon p2p networks will be made illegal w/in the next 5 years or so in the west.
- toyg 9y agoTo be fair, there is a ton of literally harmful material in some “free” networks - stuff that was made by hurting vulnerable people (often minors) or that will directly enable actions aimed at hurting others. This crap actively looks for the less-policeable corners of our marvellous communication networks, burrows, and then spawns to the four corners of the world. Just washing our hands of these items, writing them down as the cost of freedom, is not going to cut it.
- dilap 9y agoyeah, that's how the argument will go. it's just a trade-off. do you value freedom or security? a side-effect of security is you're also creating the conditions for tyranny. choose wisely!
- mindslight 9y agoWhat is going to cut it? I think the onus is on the censors to detail the full technical extent of their plan, rather than to just keep repeating "not enough". Because the way I see it, as long as there exist pedophiles who aren't lucky enough to work at the government agencies charged with cataloging child porn, there will be a desire to trade in it. And reducing its availability drives up the price, and thus increases the demand to make more. My personal solution is to just not look at it, but I understand this may be hard for some in the same way that it's hard for congresscritters to keep to themselves in public bathrooms.