4 ms·
You’re hinting at a deep problem with our current economic system. It really does produce monopolies or oligopolies with far too much concentration. History doc
by ianai 9y ago
You’re hinting at a deep problem with our current economic system. It really does produce monopolies or oligopolies with far too much concentration. History documents this functionality: the Trust Busting of the late 1800s was a reaction to clearly concentrated markets, for instance.
The solution is clearly to produce more things closer to the demand source. But I don’t see many examples of that.
As a crude suggestion, maybe carbon adjusted energy costs would incentive local production with shipped-in raw materials.
- watwut 9y agoLarge factor is that few companise being able to give away product for free kills competition. Gmail being free (and good) and without ads made competition of many smaller companies impossible. Few companies being able to operate products at loss for years makes competition impossible for smaller players.
- ianai 9y agoIt was ever decreasing prices that got Alcoa into lots of scrutiny from regulators in the late 1800s. It’s taken as a tactic to push competition out of the market.
- jakeogh 9y agoGoogle is dying. They bubbled themselves. Trading "free" for market share only works for a finite time. See FB. Their pivot to skynet will only accelerate it. If google wants to survive, they better shape up and put their awesome software contributions front and center, remove the broken pillars, and stop trying to weaponize their 3 letter control grid. Everyone knows they are social engineering the search results, all the way down to their stupid doodles. It's an open joke.
- galdosdi 9y agoYou are aware that Google has revenue, right?
- jakeogh 9y agoSo does Facebook. So did MySpace. Heck PAC's are funding major news chans, you really think the goog machine didn't get serious help?
- galdosdi 9y agoSo what's your thesis for how Google will fail? They get a cut out of a plurality of the ad clicks on the web. Do you think people will stop using the web or stop clicking on ads or what?
- jakeogh 9y agoBrand destruction. People already make jokes about "google it; but don't actually". I cant remember the last time I clicked an ad. How about you? Google is not "the web". In "conservative" circles it's more than dead. Only it's bubble prevents you from knowing that. It's doodles are like the bad joke of the day. People love to see what the next one is, but not for reasons goog would like. I got annoyed enough that I made https://github.com/jakeogh/dnsgate https://github.com/jakeogh/dnsgate and as you know, there are plenty of similar things. It's only a matter of time. I hope you take don't this the wrong way. I'm being as honest as I can. Google has done amazing things. Android won the mobile market for linux. Google video lit an entire subculture, and youtube for all it's recent problems is an amazing platform. Their software contributions and open source scientific progress are wonderful things. But, I fear it's too late. They took the social engineering too far, and the owners are too invested in it to fix it.
- asah 9y agoUm, no: Google maps, apps, hosting and X/waymo. Each are very large businesses using b2b business models and growing quickly to someday stand side by side with websearch/ads/YouTube.
- galdosdi 9y agoHahahahahaha. All those doofuses who hate the Google brand still end up reading articles on websites that pay some company that nobody realizes is a Google subsidiary to manage their ads, and they click on those ads. If that's not a strong moat (in the morningstar financial sense) I don't know what is!
- watwut 9y agoYes, but in the meantime smaller companies can't compete. And meantime here is over dozen years. There is also something to be said about (looking back) astonishing naivete of tech people who bought the whole "don't be evil" motto and who sincererly believed that since founders are tech school graduates, they are guaranteed to be ethical unlike those evil business majors.
- jakeogh 9y agoRight on. Lets not let the problem-reaction-solution cycle fix it.
- ci5er 9y ago> If google wants to survive, they better shape up and put their awesome software contributions front and center, remove the broken pillars, and stop trying to weaponize their 3 letter control grid. Would it be possible to restate this in explicit humanese, please?
- jakeogh 9y agohttps://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ Pillars (I should have said columns) is slang for the management from back when JFK took on the CIA. The president's first visit after his election was to the CIA, he made that reference, obviously people unaware of these things thought he was talking about the columns in the room;)
- jakeogh 9y ago3D printing. We gotta win the DRM/RightToRepair fight. It's the anti "dangerous objects" people who are the biggest obstacle, until it's pointed out, they don't realize they are on the wrong side of the GPC/CRYPTO/Copyright fight.
- ianai 9y agoBeing against violence isn’t being on the wrong side of anything. If you want to head resistance for 3D printing off from anti dangerous object people, as you call them, work toward eliminating the factors that make people print dangerous objects.
- jakeogh 9y agoSo only the criminals get the open source printers. How do you propose to do that? Statistically, you should be all for banning feet and knives.
- ianai 9y agoTogetherness. You said that I’m statistically against feet and knives. You’re suggesting I can only be for or against 3D printing. There’s no room for actually dealing with a violence issue through an alternate means in your dichotomy. If society wants to decrease its incidence of violence then it needs to learn to both let people “be” and reinforce positive social situations. Violence begets violence. Victims of verbal attacks may get overcome with the attacks and strike out against them physically. Violence can escalate to the point of, literally, the annihilation of all life on earth. Or, people can try and find ways to let each other be and work together. Provide all people with a basic human respect and dignity. Not everyone deserves a mansion, but they all should be able to seek “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” For the record, I’m all for 3D printing. I want everyone to be able to print a gun but not feel the need to ever use it to kill another. We can do that if we move past the divisive, bipolar rhetoric and address our actual problems.
- jakeogh 9y ago